New fallout for University of Illinois Chicago drug testing lab accused of providing flawed results in marijuana DUI convictions
Share and Follow

CHICAGO (WLS) — Well over a year ago, the ABC7 I-Team started digging into accusations of a lab scandal at the University of Illinois.

ABC7’s exclusive reporting uncovered serious questions about a likely flawed test that now has thousands of marijuana DUI convictions in question.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

And the fallout continues as new evidence, and accusations of fake science at the lab are coming to light.

Reporter Maya Dukmasova with Injustice Watch, the Chicago-based nonprofit journalism organization that recently released its own extensive investigation into the lab, joined ABC7 to discuss the scandal on Saturday morning.

You can read their article on the Injustice Watch website.

Police and prosecutors are still scrambling trying to determine which cases are damaged and which defendants may be wrongly locked up.

“I know that I was not under the influence that morning,” said Corey Lee.

Lee still sits behind bars, convicted of driving under the influence of marijuana.

In 2018, he was involved in a crash in rural Illinois that killed a father and his adult son.

Lee’s case, along with many others, were charged based on blood test results from UIC’s now shuttered AFTL lab.

SEE ALSO | Thousands of marijuana DUI convictions may be in jeopardy after report on UIC drug testing lab

“It’s really simple. Fraudulent science equals fraudulent convictions. Step up to the plate and release the people that have been convicted based on this rogue lab. Do the right thing,” said DUI defense attorney Don Ramsell.

After an extensive investigation by the I-Team, internal memos and emails revealed potentially flawed test results from the lab generating inaccurate numbers of a cannabis molecule called THC.

The tests were used to determine whether someone was illegally driving under the influence of marijuana.

The lab was also accused in court filings of covering up the flaws in testing methods since 2021.

“This is what I would describe as a festering scandal,” said Rush University Medical School Forensic Pharmacologist Jim O’Donnell. “The consequences are great… You know, there’s people who are charged with felonies. Their life is certainly affected.”

Following our reporting, the DuPage County state’s attorney announced the dismissal of more than a dozen cases involving the faulty tests.

Other county prosecutors and police departments in the metro Chicago area are now reviewing cases, including in Cook County.

Recently, the university’s law firm released results of an internal investigation absolving the lab and UIC of wrongdoing, concluding the lab’s methods were “at all times appropriate and met accepted scientific standards” and that none of the analysts “knowingly provided false testimony.”

READ MORE | University of Illinois Chicago releases report on faulty blood tests used in marijuana DUI cases

But the report also says the lab’s methods should have been “been modified” to distinguish between two related forms of THC.

Officials with UIC have repeatedly declined interview or comment requests from the I-Team.

ABC7 Chief Legal Analyst Gil Soffer says those investigation results are not an exoneration, especially with a key figure at the lab, Jennifer Bash, declining interviews by UIC’s lawyers.

“First, will there be a criminal penalty here? Will someone be found to have deliberately misled somebody else? Unclear from this report, it didn’t find that someone had misled, but it also doesn’t rule out that possibility, and I could see further inquiry there. The other question is, could somebody, the lab, be held liable in negligence for what happened here?” Soffer said.

The I-Team contacted Bash, whose tests methods at the lab and her testimony as an expert witness in many DUI cases are now being called into question.

She declined an on-camera interview but said in a written statement, in part, “I was very disappointed when I read the article and saw that it was filled with inconsistencies and falsehoods. Acting in good faith, I provided detailed responses to questions concerning the science behind the testing I conducted. Those responses have been either distorted or ignored. Throughout my career I have presented facts based on sound scientific principles. While I understand that disagreement among experts is not uncommon in the courtroom, a differing scientific opinion should never be equated to dishonesty. The testing methods I used and the results obtained were scientifically sound and I am unaware of any ANAB findings to the contrary.”

Bash is still certified by the American Board of Forensic Toxicology and can still testify in Illinois courtrooms.

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
The Southern city defying America's housing market collapse

Southern City’s Resilient Housing Market Defies National Downturn

Once overshadowed by more prominent Southern cities such as Charleston, Atlanta, and…
Texas substitute teacher, boyfriend charged in child sexual assault investigation

Texas Educator and Partner Face Charges in Disturbing Child Sexual Assault Case

A former substitute teacher from Texas, along with her boyfriend, faces charges…
Here's how to watch Patriots vs. Jets live for free

Stream Patriots vs. Jets Live: Your Ultimate Guide to Watching for Free!

New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if…
There’s plenty of cause for pessimism for NYC commercial real estate in 2026

Outlook for NYC Commercial Real Estate in 2026: Concerns on the Horizon

The outlook for New York City’s commercial real estate in 2026 appears…
FBI gives update on daycare accused of $4M taxpayer fraud

FBI Unveils Latest Developments in $4 Million Taxpayer Fraud Case Involving Daycare Facility

FBI Director Kash Patel has announced an intensified effort to tackle fraud…
Head of America's 'free enterprise' college optimistic about academia despite left-wing bias: 'there is hope'

Why the Free Enterprise College Leader Sees a Bright Future Amid Academic Left-Wing Bias

PHOENIX — Despite the prevalent perception of excessive administrative layers and a…
Update on girl, 13, who was shot in the face by her stepdad

Latest Developments on the 13-Year-Old Girl Injured in Shooting Incident Involving Her Stepfather

A teenage girl is fighting for her life after being shot in…
FBI agents detail Kash Patel's 'diva' behavior over screen time

FBI Agents Reveal Kash Patel’s Demands for Screen Time: Inside the Diva Drama

FBI agents have recently unveiled concerns regarding Director Kash Patel, alleging that…