New details emerge about blaze which destroyed judge's beachfront home
Share and Follow

Investigators have concluded that there is no evidence to indicate that a fire at a beachfront mansion in South Carolina belonging to a judge was the result of arson.

The home at Edisto Beach, owned by Circuit Judge Diane Goodstein, 69, and her former senator husband Arnold Goodstein, 81, was consumed by flames on October 4. Initially, it was thought that the incident might have been an arson attack.

However, on Monday, Mark Keel, Chief of the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, stated that there is ‘no evidence to suggest that the fire was started deliberately.’

‘SLED agents have preliminarily found there is no evidence to support a pre-fire explosion,’ he added, according to theĀ New York Post.

The fire in the four-bedroom, four-bathroom $1,155,200 home in Edisto, South Carolina, sent three of the judge’s family members to the hospital.

The former senator was forced to jump out from the first floor of the house to get to safety.

He reportedly sustained multiple broken bones in his hips, legs, and feet following the fall.

Goodstein’s son, Arnold Goodstein II, was also hospitalized.

Circuit Judge Diane Goodstein, 69, beachfront home burnt down on October 4th

Circuit Judge Diane Goodstein, 69, beachfront home burnt down on October 4th

The fire in the four-bedroom, four-bathroom $1,155,200 home in Edisto, South Carolina, sent three of the judge's family members to the hospital

The fire in the four-bedroom, four-bathroom $1,155,200 home in Edisto, South Carolina, sent three of the judge’s family members to the hospital

The family was rescued by paramedics and emergency workers in kayaks, according to the St. Paul’s Fire District, the outlet reported.

South Carolina Chief Justice John Kittredge said in a message to FITSNews that the fire resulted from an ‘apparent explosion.’

‘Judge Goodstein was walking on the beach when the fire started. Her husband, Arnie, was in the house with children and perhaps grandchildren. The family had to escape by jumping from a window or balcony.’

‘Arnie’s injuries may have been the most serious, for he was airlifted to the hospital.’

Goodstein had reportedly been receiving death threats in the past few weeks, sources told the outlet.

‘She’s had multiple death threats over the years,’ one judge close to Goodstein said.

Ex-senator husband, Arnold Goodstein, 81, suffered serious injuries and was reportedly airlifted

Ex-senator husband, Arnold Goodstein, 81, suffered serious injuries and was reportedly airlifted

TheĀ mansion of a South Carolina judge and former senator was determined not to have been caused by arson

TheĀ mansion of a South Carolina judge and former senator was determined not to have been caused by arson

Just last month, she was involved in a controversial case determining whether voters’ personal information in South Carolina could be handed over to the government.

Goodstein issued a temporary restraining order in early September, stemming from a lawsuit challenging whether the South Carolina Election Commission can give voters’ data to the Department of Justice, The Gazette reported.

However, the order was later overturned after a six-page opinion from the Supreme Court took issue with Goodstein’s process in barring the state from complying.

Goodstein was criticized by the Supreme Court’s order, signed by all five justices, for failing to detail the type of damage that would be caused by the release of voters’ personal information.

Specifically, the information of Calhoun County voter Anne Crook, who filed the suit to fight the release of her information to the federal government.

Goodstein was also said to have failed to explain whether she believed the lawsuit was likely to succeed, which is required for a court to intervene, according to the order obtained by the Gazette.

The circuit court judge also instructed the Election Commission not to comply with the request for voter information until they had received notice of the lawsuit, which the court deemed a violation.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Doctor who sold ketamine to 'Friends' star Matthew Perry gets 2 1/2 years in prison

Doctor Sentenced to 2.5 Years for Illegally Supplying Ketamine to ‘Friends’ Actor Matthew Perry

A doctor involved in supplying ketamine to “Friends” actor Matthew Perry leading…
Chicago Public Schools reaches $17.5M settlement over Little Village Lawndale High School Dean Brian Crowder sex abuse case

Chicago Public Schools Settles $17.5M in Landmark Little Village Lawndale HS Abuse Case

In a significant development, Chicago Public Schools (CPS) has reached a settlement…
Turning Point finally denies Candace Owens' Charlie Kirk claims

Turning Point USA Breaks Silence: The Truth Behind Candace Owens’ Allegations Against Charlie Kirk

Turning Point USA has issued a response to Candace Owens regarding her…
Massive 14-foot shark dies after being stranded on Massachusetts beach during migration

14-Foot Shark Found Deceased on Massachusetts Beach Amid Migration

A tragic event unfolded off the coast of Massachusetts earlier this week…
Brian Walshe told cops his missing wife left for a flight on Jan 1, JetBlue records keeper says otherwise

JetBlue Records Contradict Brian Walshe’s Claim About Wife’s Jan 1 Departure, Police Report Indicates

On Wednesday, the murder trial of Boston art fraudster Brian Walshe continued…
Luigi Mangione appears in Manhattan Criminal Court for an evidence hearing, Tuesday, Dec. 2, 2025, in New York. (Curtis Means/Pool Photo via AP)

Unfolding Drama: Luigi Mangione’s Court Hearing Coincides with UnitedHealthcare CEO’s Death Anniversary

NEW YORK (AP) — The murder proceedings against Luigi Mangione in New…
California Christian college student founds pro-life club after school rejects Students for Life chapter

California Christian College Student Launches New Pro-Life Club Following School’s Rejection of Students for Life Chapter

A determined pro-life student at a Christian college in California has successfully…
Shared Table Food Pantry in Opportunity Enterprises in Valparaiso, Indiana fills plates, trains people with special needs

Empowering Lives: How Shared Table Food Pantry in Valparaiso Combines Nourishment with Life-Changing Skills for Special Needs

VALPARAISO, Ind. (WLS) — At first glance, the Shared Table Food Pantry…