Georgia judge flubs verdict reading, tells defendant he is guilty
Share and Follow


A Fulton County judge misspoke while reading a defendant’s verdict in a Georgia courtroom Friday, telling him he was guilty when the jury deemed him not guilty.

Alton Oliver was on trial over the 2022 killing of a Fulton County deputy and faced six counts, including three of murder, NBC affiliate WXIA of Atlanta reported.

Video from inside the courtroom shows the moment the judge accidentally told Oliver he was guilty.

After confirming with the jury that the paperwork was correct, the judge read the verdict: “We the jury find the defendant guilty as to all six counts.”

Oliver and his legal team sat in silence but people in the courtroom started audibly questioning the judge’s reading, prompting him to double-check the paper.

“Didn’t I say ‘not’?” the judge asked the room, to which a number of people replied “no.”

He apologized, then re-read the statement, this time correctly. People in the courtroom laughed and applauded.

After learning he had been acquitted, Oliver hugged his defense team, the video shows.

Earlier in the week, Oliver testified that he acted in self-defense when he shot Deputy James Thomas after Thomas repeatedly drove by Oliver and made unwanted sexual advances, WXIA reported.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Venezuela’s acting leader was once a DEA 'priority target': report

Report Reveals Venezuela’s Interim Leader Previously Labeled as DEA ‘Priority Target

Venezuela’s interim President, Delcy Rodríguez, has been identified in intelligence files from…
Viral protest video against Iran’s supreme leader sparks copycat demonstrations worldwide

Global Wave of Protests Erupts as Viral Video Challenges Iran’s Supreme Leader

A captivating video featuring an Iranian refugee setting aflame an image of…
Faithful & Firm lions to briefly come down during seawall reconstruction

Rebuilding Seawalls: Temporary Relocation of the Iconic Faithful & Firm Lions

Local artists in St. Augustine are set to rejuvenate the iconic Bridge…
Portland DA cracks down on drug crimes as Seattle pulls back on enforcement

Portland DA Intensifies Drug Crime Crackdown Amid Seattle’s Shift in Enforcement Strategy

While Seattle takes a step back from prosecuting drug possession, Portland is…
FILE - This Aug. 7, 2025, satellite image shows construction of large white tents for a new immigrant detention center at Fort Bliss, a U.S. Army base outside El Paso, Texas. (Planet Labs via AP, File)

Tragic Loss: ICE Reports Suicide of Detainee at Texas Detention Center

An immigrant from Nicaragua was discovered dead last week at a Texas…
Minneapolis software engineers mistaken for ICE agents while eating lunch harassed by anti-ICE crowd

Minneapolis Software Engineers Mistaken for ICE Agents Face Harassment from Anti-ICE Protesters During Lunch Break

A group of software engineers in Minneapolis faced a barrage of insults…
Kristi Yamaguchi reflects on 1992 gold as she looks ahead to Milan Cortina

Kristi Yamaguchi Remembers 1992 Gold Triumph While Eyeing Future at Milan-Cortina Winter Olympics

Renowned figure skating legend Kristi Yamaguchi shares her Olympic experiences and insights…
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor faces flood risk at his new Norfolk home

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor Confronts Flood Risk at Newly Acquired Norfolk Residence

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor is considering subscribing to an Environment Agency alert system due…