Google barred from exclusive search engine contracts but no break up
Share and Follow

Google must share data with rivals to open up competition in online search, a judge in Washington ruled on Tuesday.

Nonetheless, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta dismissed the request from Donald Trump’s Justice Department to dismantle the internet powerhouse by compelling it to divest its Chrome browser.

It was the culmination of a landmark antitrust case that imposed sweeping remedies aimed at restoring competition in online search.

This ruling followed a year after Judge Mehta determined that Google unlawfully maintained monopolies in online search and related advertising, securing exclusive distribution deals valued at billions annually.

Google CEO Sundar Pichai argued that the data-sharing proposals sought by the Justice Department might enable the tech giant’s competitors to reverse-engineer its technology.

The company has already said it would appeal. That means it could be years before Google has to comply with the judge’s ruling.

In a 230-page ruling the judge also said Google would not have to sell off its Android operating system.

He wrote: ‘Google will not be required to divest Chrome; nor will the court include a contingent divestiture of the Android operating system in the final judgment.

‘Plaintiffs overreached in seeking forced divesture of these key assets, which Google did not use to effect any illegal restraints.’ 

Trump’s Justice Department, headed by Attorney General Pam Bondi, had argued that the Chrome browser is a key gateway to the internet and facilitates a third of all Google web searches.

But the judge said forcing a sale of it would be ‘incredibly messy.’

The Justice Department had also argued that Google should be ordered to stop ‘compelled syndication.’

That process sees it make agreements for its search engine to be the default one used in browsers and phones.

It paid $26 billion to companies including Apple and Mozilla for such deals in 2021, and is expected to be allowed to continue.

Following the ruling, shares in Alphabet, Google’s parent company, jumped 8 percent.

Shares in Apple also immediately rose 4 percent.

Sundar Pichai, CEO of Google, will not see his company broken up following a landmark antitrust ruling

Sundar Pichai, CEO of Google, will not see his company broken up following a landmark antitrust ruling

U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi, head of President Donald Trump's Justice Department, which had argued Google should be forced to sell off its Chrome browser

U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi, head of President Donald Trump’s Justice Department, which had argued Google should be forced to sell off its Chrome browser

Judge Amit Mehta had found last year that Google illegally maintained monopolies in online search through the exclusive agreements.

But in is ruling he said banning them could have too serious an impact on other businesses.

He wrote: ‘Cutting off payments from Google almost certainly will impose substantial, in some cases crippling, downstream harms to distribution partners, related markets, and consumers.’

Instead, he ordered Google to hand over search index data and user interaction information that rivals can use to improve their services.

Google must also offer syndication of search results to rivals.

Google shares rose after the ruling which did not require it to sell Chrome

Google shares rose after the ruling which did not require it to sell Chrome

Overall, the judge’s ruling was seen by experts as largely in favor of Google.

Gene Munster, managing partner, at Deepwater Asset Management, said: ‘The regulator’s bark is bigger than the bite.’

In April, Google lost a separate antitrust case over digital advertising.

A judge in Virginia, just outside Washington D.C., ruled the tech giant illegally built ‘monopoly power’ in a victory for online news publishers.

That case was also brought by the U.S. Justice Department, and the Daily Mail’s Chief Digital Officer, Matthew Wheatland, was a key witness.

Bondi called it a ‘landmark victory in the ongoing fight to stop Google from monopolizing the digital public square.’

She added: ‘Google is a monopolist and has abused its monopoly power.’

Judge Amit Mehta delivered a 230-page ruling in the case

Judge Amit Mehta delivered a 230-page ruling in the case 

The cases are part of a wide government offensive against alleged monopolistic practices by technology giants.

It has support from both Republicans and Democrats, and involves cases launched under both President Trump and President Joe Biden.

There are currently five pending antitrust cases brought by the U.S. government against major technology companies.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Feds in Minneapolis immigration operation can’t detain or tear gas peaceful protesters, judge rules

Judge Blocks Feds from Detaining or Using Tear Gas on Peaceful Protesters in Minneapolis Immigration Operation

A federal judge in Minnesota has ruled that immigration enforcement officers in…
Federal judge restricts ICE agents amid ongoing Minneapolis area protests

Federal Judge Limits ICE Authority During Minneapolis Protests

In a significant decision on Friday, a judge in Minnesota issued a…
Islanders' sloppy play costs them winnable road game to Flames

Islanders’ Costly Mistakes Lead to Defeat Against Flames in Crucial Road Matchup

CALGARY, Alberta — In a twist of fate, the Islanders emerged victorious…
National Guard troops will likely remain in DC through 2026, official says

National Guard Presence in Washington, D.C. Expected to Continue Until 2026, Official Reports

In a strategic move to maintain security in the nation’s capital, National…
Duval County high school graduation rate hits new high, surpassing state

Duval County High Schools Achieve Record-High Graduation Rates, Surpassing State Average

Graduation rates for Duval County, encompassing charter schools, soared to an impressive…
Footage shows hunters from world's biggest uncontacted Amazon tribe

Rare Footage Reveals World’s Largest Uncontacted Amazon Tribe: A Glimpse into Their Untouched Way of Life

Remarkable new footage and photographs have emerged, showcasing the world’s largest uncontacted…
Trump announces shock tariff on EIGHT European countries

Trump Unveils Surprising Tariff Measures Targeting Eight European Nations

In a surprising move, Donald Trump has declared his intention to impose…
BBC news presenter 'hisses' when rapper tells her Jesus is his hero

BBC News Host Responds Uncomfortably to Rapper’s Choice of Hero

BBC News presenter Geeta Guru-Murthy found herself at the center of a…