A Facebook post that appeared during an ordinary scroll stunned readers: A New York woman was saying goodbye to friends, relatives and supporters while publicly detailing the collapse of her marriage and announcing that she planned to end her life.
“For the last four years, I have woken up every day to a nightmare like no other,” Catherine Kassenoff wrote in her final message on May 27, 2023. She said she could “no longer endure” what she described as abuse by Allan Kassenoff, her husband of 16 years. “Don’t let my death be in vain,” she wrote.
The post exposed the devastating breakdown of a marriage between two prominent New York lawyers. Catherine had worked in Governor Kathy Hochul’s office, while Allan was a patent litigator representing companies including Pfizer and Samsung. Following Catherine’s death, Allan left his partnership at Greenberg Traurig.
Their divorce became an intensely contested custody dispute. Catherine said Allan had used what she characterized as a corrupt legal system to keep her away from their children, while details from the case spread across TikTok and other social media platforms.
On the same day she published her final post, Catherine sent an email to hundreds of people, including friends and members of the legal system. She called it her final “swan song” and attached court records, therapy documents and videos of her estranged husband that she said demonstrated “exactly how abusive Allan Kassenoff is.” The email opened with the words: “This is a story that ends with my own assisted death in Switzerland.”
Three years after her death, the dispute is being revisited on television. He Said, She Said: Till Death Do Us Part, which begins streaming on Paramount+ on November 17, examines the family’s tragedy through interviews with Allan and the couple’s three daughters, who were 16, 15 and 13. The girls allege that Catherine was the abusive parent, claims they say have left the family grieving, distressed and facing death threats.
Katherine Klein, a nanny who worked with the family and said she was the last person to speak with Catherine, told the Daily Mail that portraying the mother of three as abusive after her suicide was not “fair.”
Klein said she received Catherine’s email on May 27, 2023, and called her immediately. She pleaded with Catherine not to go through with her plan, but said Catherine told her it was already too late. Her decision had been made—and, according to Klein, the process had begun.
In her final message on May 27, 2023, Catherine Kassenoff said she could “no longer endure” what she described as abuse by her husband of 16 years, Allan Kassenoff
“For the last four years, I have woken up every day to a nightmare like no other. I can no longer endure the abuse and terror of Allan Kassenoff… I have also endured the emotional devastation of being without my children for so long…”
“She’s no longer here,” Klein said, speaking regretfully about her friend while declining to discuss the details of their final call.
Klein said she had personally witnessed hostile exchanges between Catherine and Allan. “It’s not fair how he wore her down and, like, beat her to dust in a sense,” she said. “He pulverized her verbally and mentally. It really wears a person down.”
Catherine and Allan met in New York City in 2005. They were 37 and 33, respectively, and worked at the same law firm. Their shared careers brought them together, and Allan said he was drawn to Catherine’s “no-nonsense” personality.
“It was an attractive quality,” he said in the documentary series.
Religious differences became an early source of tension. Allan grew up in an Orthodox Jewish family in New York, while Catherine’s family in West Virginia were Egyptian Coptic Christians. Catherine converted to Judaism before the wedding, but disagreements between the families made choosing a ceremony difficult.
The couple ultimately eloped to Puerto Rico about a year after they began dating. It is unclear whether either family attended.
Catherine wanted to become a mother, and the couple began building a family soon after their marriage.
Before they had been married for two years, Catherine was diagnosed with a rare and aggressive form of breast cancer. The illness and its treatment placed considerable pressure on the relationship. According to details Catherine later included in her final post, she told a therapist that Allan “showed that he was not good at handling stress.”
While Catherine was dealing with cancer, the couple adopted a daughter, Alexandra “Ally” Kassenoff. Catherine later pursued in vitro fertilization because she wanted more children. Allan said in the documentary that she was prepared to undergo the treatment “with or without me.” They eventually had two more daughters through IVF: Charlotte “Charley” Kassenoff and Josephina “Jojo” Kassenoff, even as the marriage became increasingly strained.
The family settled into a large home in Westchester County, New York, where photographs of the children filled the walls. From the outside, they appeared to be a prosperous family with two accomplished parents. Behind the wood-paneled walls, however, the household was far less settled.
Arguments over parenting, household responsibilities and personal conflicts grew more frequent. Allan later described the marriage as a “rollercoaster,” marked by severe lows, constant fighting and occasional highs that he was reluctant to discuss in detail.
Allan said he loved being a father, but acknowledged that his demanding legal career often kept him at work late and left Catherine handling much of the day-to-day care of the children.
Catherine and Allan met in New York City in 2005, when they were 37 and 33, respectively
Less than two years after the wedding, Catherine was diagnosed with rare and aggressive breast cancer
Cynthia Monaco, a friend of Catherine’s, told the documentary’s producers that she never saw much affectionate behavior between the couple and described Allan as “immature.”
“When everyone urged her to leave an explosive marriage, she said her children had a beautiful life and she did not want to disrupt it,” Monaco wrote in a GoFundMe campaign after Catherine’s death.
The family faced another medical crisis in 2017, when Catherine was diagnosed with breast cancer for a second time. Few details about that illness have been made public.
By May 2019, separation and divorce proceedings had begun. Both parents started documenting the other’s conduct and arguments, creating a trove of footage that would eventually be submitted in family court and shared with the public.
In court filings, Catherine accused Allan of verbal and physical abuse and said his account falsely portrayed her as the person harming their children. Allan denied those allegations.
A custody evaluation stated that Catherine had “an unspecified personality disorder, predominately histrionic and narcissistic traits.” It also accused her of gaslighting the children, alienating them from their father and coaching them.
Catherine’s psychiatrist offered a sharply different assessment during a temporary custody hearing in 2020. The doctor, who said she had treated Catherine for more than a year in connection with alleged spousal abuse, emotional and physical abuse, the divorce and separation from the children, testified that Catherine “does not exhibit any features or problems relating to mental health issues.”
The custody evaluation described Allan as “emotionally unsophisticated” and said he contributed to a “noxious atmosphere.” It also concluded that his angry outbursts were provoked by Catherine’s presence and behavior, and observed that he tended to leave rather than confront her. The court found no evidence that Allan had abused the children, and he was never criminally charged.
The evaluation led to the girls being removed from Catherine’s care. They were approximately 10, eight and six at the time, and the court-appointed evaluator concluded that Catherine’s mental-health issues left her unable to care for them.
During the COVID-19 lockdowns, Catherine maintained contact with the girls largely through video calls. In-person visits required a paid third-party supervisor.
Despite advice from her lawyer and the court, Catherine continued discussing the case publicly. She posted critical comments about Allan and shared videos of tense family interactions, including footage in which Ally appeared to defend her sisters during one of Allan’s angry outbursts, as shown in the documentary.
As a partner at Greenberg Traurig, Allan represented clients including Pfizer and Samsung as a patent litigator
Their marriage deteriorated as disputes over parenting and long-standing personal conflicts intensified
The custody fight cost both parents a substantial amount of money.
“The financial situation was dire. Catherine grew thin from stress,” Monaco wrote in the GoFundMe appeal.
A now-deleted interview with Ms. Magazine, reviewed by the Daily Mail, said Catherine depleted her retirement savings to cover legal expenses and supervised visits, which reportedly exceeded $70,000.
In an email previously published by the Daily Mail, Allan told Catherine he would “never stop” preventing her from having unrestricted access to the children and said he had spent at least $3 million on the case.
“Even if this Court awards you my last dollar, I will never stop protecting them,” Allan wrote. “Until the day I die.”
Two months before her death, Catherine sued Allan and his attorneys, accusing them of false imprisonment. Neither that lawsuit nor the divorce was formally resolved before she died.
Switzerland’s assisted-dying process can take between six weeks and six months and requires documentation concerning a patient’s suffering. It remains unclear how long Catherine had been planning her death. Those close to her said they were blindsided, and she did not tell her friends, relatives or medical team before pursuing assisted suicide.
A medical report dated April 9, 2023, by former psychiatrist Colin Brewer concluded that Catherine was of “sound enough mind” to end her life. Brewer told The Free Press that he spoke with her several times over a period of months.
Brewer described Catherine’s decision as an “existential assisted suicide.”
Alongside the custody dispute, Catherine was facing a third breast cancer diagnosis, which she described as terminal in her final post. Allan later disputed that characterization. Catherine cited the illness as one factor in her decision, but Brewer said the custody battle carried greater emotional weight.
According to Brewer, Catherine was more distressed by what she believed was her husband’s mistreatment of her, which caused “understandable misery,” than by the prospect of a terminal illness.
After publishing her message and speaking with several concerned people by phone, Catherine died at the Pegasos Swiss Association. Confirmation of her death took several weeks to reach the family through international government records. Her death brought the marriage to an end, but not the conflict surrounding it.
Catherine did not tell her friends, family or medical team that she was seeking assisted suicide, leaving those around her shocked on May 27, 2023
Both Catherine and Allan spent large sums during their bitter custody dispute
In the documentary, Allan described Catherine as “a very difficult person to get along with.” He compared her death to that of a suicide bomber, arguing that it was as much an attempt to damage him as it was an effort to escape her emotional suffering.
Ally, now 16, said in the series that her relationship with Catherine changed after her younger sisters were born.
“My mom told me, when I was like four or five, that I was adopted,” Ally told filmmakers. “I was adopted because she couldn’t have kids, and as soon as she was able to have her own kids, I was not her kid at that point.”
Several family nannies, though not all of them, told the documentary’s producers that Catherine had been abusive toward the children, particularly Ally. Klein gave a contrasting account, saying Allan abused Catherine and frightened the girls. Allan has repeatedly denied abuse allegations.
Kim Hull, who worked for the family in 2009, alleged that Catherine punished Ally by dripping water on her throughout the day to keep her from sleeping. Hull also said she found marks that resembled fingernail scratches on Ally’s back when the child was a baby.
Mylene Gry, a nanny from 2015 to 2016, alleged that Catherine shouted at Ally, who was under 10 at the time, telling her: “You have no friends… you’re never going to get married.”
Gry said she was afraid of Catherine and compared Ally’s treatment to that of Cinderella, claiming the girl was expected to act as a “maid” to her sisters.
The parents’ recordings, made during the dispute, became central to the documentary. The footage captures angry exchanges, personal insults and the visible distress of the children.
In one clip, Allan said he “hated” Catherine and regretted their time together. In another, he called her a “fat loser” and allegedly threatened to release a video of her wearing only underwear. Other recordings show him walking away during arguments and, at times, refusing to care for the children. Allan has acknowledged being angry in the footage but denies that his conduct constituted abuse.
Recordings made by Allan showed Catherine criticizing the girls when they failed to meet the academic and extracurricular expectations she had set. In one video, she mocked Ally over taking a chocolate bar and lying about it while Allan urged her to treat their daughter “civilly.” She was also accused of encouraging the children to criticize their father while being filmed.
The documentary says Child Protective Services was alerted to the family’s conflicts.
Ally, who was 13 when her mother died, told the filmmakers: “I told my school that my dad kicked me. I don’t remember why, and my mom thought it was like the best thing ever that I said that.”
Ally also said she could not remember her father physically abusing her. Allan has denied the allegations.
Allan said in the series that the judge ultimately ruled in his favor because of the video evidence he submitted.
In one recording featured in the documentary, Allan said he “hated” Catherine and regretted their relationship
“Even if this Court awards you my last dollar, I will never stop protecting them,” Allan wrote in an email
Although Allan said the girls initially did not take sides, recordings shown in the series depict them expressing fears about their safety to Catherine. She urged them to contact police if they believed it was necessary. In some videos, the girls speak quietly in French—a language Catherine shared with them—apparently trying to keep their conversations from being overheard by Allan.
When Ally went to a nearby police station, Catherine reportedly followed in her car while trying to comply with court restrictions surrounding visitation.
Allan became concerned that Catherine was encouraging the girls to reject his care. He also accused her of impersonating their nine-year-old daughter Charley and sending emails from the child’s account describing severe distress and suicidal thoughts while in Allan’s care.
Catherine denied sending the messages, but the court sided with Allan and ordered that all of her visits be supervised by a third party.
Charley, who was 12 when Catherine died, said: “I never thought for myself. My mom, like, put her voice through my mouth.”
Audio included in the documentary indicates that the children’s therapist asked Charley about the email. Charley did not deny sending it, but said she had no suicide plan and was expressing how much she missed her mother.
Other recordings show Catherine crying during supervised video calls as her daughters appeared increasingly distant.
Natalie Blundell, whom Catherine met through a support group for mothers involved in family-court disputes, said she could understand the desperation Catherine may have felt, even while acknowledging that her behavior could be highly emotional.
“When you’re pushed so far and you’re desperate to end this madness and see your kids again, you would try anything,” Blundell said in the series. “I think, as any mother would, you will do what you need to do.”
Andrew Firsh, a friend, colleague and attorney for Catherine, described the Kassenoffs’ family-court proceedings as exceptionally harsh.
“When I came into the case, I had never worked in matrimonial court,” he told producers. “This was a war.” He recalled Allan’s lawyer telling him: “Matrimonial practice is a cesspool. I do what I have to.”
Another attorney for Catherine, Evan Wiederkehr, said she felt “shackled” by the judge’s rulings.
“If you weren’t insane before, it’s enough to make you insane,” Wiederkehr said while discussing the case.
Before her death, Catherine was permitted longer visits with the girls. According to the documentary, however, the visits left the children feeling even more resentment, and the relationship did not recover.
Charley and Jojo eventually began refusing visits, leaving Ally as the only daughter who continued attending. Ally said she was still seeking her mother’s affection. When she confronted Catherine about the alleged abuse, Ally said her mother fell silent.
“There was about two minutes of silence,” Ally recalled. “And then she said, ‘I’m sorry.’ And that was it. She didn’t feel any emotion about it at all.”
Wayne Baker, a friend of Catherine’s and executor of her estate, said Catherine remained focused on her children. He recalled her saying: “The court said I cannot live with my children, but I cannot live without them.”
Catherine’s friends continue to reject the suggestion that she was abusive.
Monaco described Catherine to the Daily Mail as a “wonderful person,” adding: “I owe a tremendous amount [to her], including my decision to have two children.”
The two women had experienced similar cancer diagnoses, and Monaco said Catherine’s determination to become a mother despite her medical challenges had been deeply meaningful to her.
Catherine’s final requests to her closest friends echoed the message in her last social media post: She wanted her daughters to know her version of what had happened.
“The reason Catherine’s friends agreed to participate in this documentary was because it was going to go forward without her, one way or the other,” Monaco said. “We thought we should try and give her a voice.”
Allan said in the documentary that Catherine was “a very difficult person to get along with”
Before her death, Catherine discussed the case publicly, criticized Allan and posted videos of tense family moments online
The Daily Mail has contacted Allan Kassenoff for comment.
A friend who spoke to the Daily Mail anonymously said she intended to honor Catherine’s wishes.
“When her girls are of age and independent from Allan, I will gladly tell them and share all of my correspondence with their mother,” the friend said. “I will gladly tell them everything I know and remember about their beautiful mother.”
“It makes me sick to think that they’re going to smear her,” the friend added. She had not watched the documentary but said Catherine had previously tried to tell her story through an exposé about the failures of the family-court system. “No one was interested,” she said.
Although He Said, She Said gives Allan an opportunity to present his account, Baker told producers that Catherine left one more message: a video intended only for her daughters, which they have not yet watched.
“She just tries to explain to the girls what lessons she learned during her life—the importance of reaching your goals and not allowing past events to determine the course of your life,” Baker said. “She wanted them to understand that her decision to end her life was not because of anything they did.”
The Daily Mail has contacted Baker for comment.
If you or someone you love is experiencing suicidal thoughts or actions, call the National Suicide Hotline at 988.