Things to know about the retrial of Karen Read in the killing of her police officer boyfriend
Share and Follow


Prosecutors in Karen Read’s second murder case on Tuesday introduced a series of angry voice mails that she left for her Boston police officer boyfriend in the hours before he was found in the snow.

These recordings, along with evidence of scores of missed calls to John O’Keefe, followed testimony from a meteorologist who described the snow storm that night as a “classic nor’easter,” and said freezing temperatures would have made the “ground impenetrable.”

Prosecutors say Read, 45, backed her SUV into O’Keefe, 46, and left him to die after dropping him off at a party hosted by a fellow officer. Her lawyers say she was framed in a police conspiracy and that someone inside the home that night in January 2022 must have killed him.

A mistrial was declared last year. Read’s second trial on charges of second-degree murder, manslaughter and leaving the scene has appeared to be similar so far.

Karen Read was angry or distraught?

Prosecutors called State Police Trooper Nicholas Guarino, who retrieved cell phone data from O’Keefe’s phone.

He detailed how the data show Read called O’Keefe nearly 30 times that morning. The first batch continued for nearly an hour after 12:35 a.m. Most were missed calls. She also left several profanity-laced emails, including one in which she accused O’Keefe of sleeping with someone else and leaving his two adopted children home alone.

“John I (expletive) hate you,” she yells in one voice message that was played to the jury.

The calls from Read resumed several hours later. Most didn’t connect, but one voice mail just after 6 a.m. sounded like it came from the scene and included a muffled voice, apparently Read’s, screaming and sounding distraught.

Investigator from scene questioned

Both sides questioned a former Canton police lieutenant about evidence-gathering at the scene. In the first trial, Lt. Paul Gallagher testified about the use of red Solo cups to gather O’Keefe’s blood, and a leaf blower to clear snow.

Gallagher agreed this time that a plastic cup is not normally used to collect evidence, but he said the circumstances required quick thinking and improvisation.

“If we didn’t collect that biological matter, we weren’t going to get that biological matter,” Gallagher said.

On cross-examination Monday and early Tuesday, Jackson aggressively questioned Gallagher on the methods police used in the investigation.

He questioned why police didn’t search inside the Albert house nor interview the homeowner Brian Albert, who was also a Boston police officer. Gallagher responded they had no reason to do so, since “nobody could put John O’Keefe in the house including Ms. Read.”

He also questioned why Gallagher didn’t seek home security footage from a house across the street, which was owned by another police officer. Gallagher said he was familiar with that camera and believed it would only show the front step and front lawn of that house.

Jackson also sought to raise doubt about the chain of custody over evidence at the scene. He pressed Gallagher on the evidence collection, questioning why police didn’t go back to the station to get proper equipment including swabs and an evidence bag. Instead, they relied on a neighbor’s cups, and transported the materials in a grocery store bag to the station.

“With an evidence bag, you know exactly where it came from and who is handling it,” Jackson said.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Iranian sleeper cells may be hiding 'in plain sight' waiting to target rural US areas, terrorism expert warns

Iranian sleeper cells may be hiding ‘in plain sight’ waiting to target rural US areas, terrorism expert warns

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A counterterrorism expert says…
ICE agents capture suspected violent MS-13 gang member, another illegal alien after police let them slip away

ICE agents capture suspected violent MS-13 gang member, another illegal alien after police let them slip away

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Federal authorities in Indiana…
Texas rep defends vote against emergency alert bill amid floods

Texas representative explains why he voted against emergency alert legislation during floods

() A Texas state representative defended his vote against a $500 million…
New Israeli report says Hamas used sexual violence as a 'weapon of war' in Oct. 7 attack

A recent report from Israel reveals Hamas used sexual violence as a ‘weapon of war’ in October 7 assault

Newly released interviews and documentation further bolster evidence that Hamas systematically used…
US will 'have to' send weapons to Ukraine, Trump says days after Pentagon pause

US will ‘have to’ send weapons to Ukraine, Trump says days after Pentagon pause

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! President Donald Trump on…
Feds bash 5-year sentence for Chicagoland ex-mayor guilty of extortion

Government officials criticize the 5-year sentence given to former mayor from Chicagoland for extortion conviction

Cooperation might get the former mayor of Chicago suburb McCook a leaner…
Video shows teen 'takeover' Glen Ellyn Park District's Sunset Pool on Saturday, 1 arrested for illegal use of fireworks: Police

Police arrest one person for using fireworks illegally at Glen Ellyn Park District’s Sunset Pool on Saturday, video captures teen ‘takeover’.

GLEN ELLYN, Ill. (WLS) — A suburban park district is investigating what…
Pressure from Trump for trade deals before Wednesday deadline, but hints of more time for talks

New Tariff Increases on Over a Dozen Countries Warned by Trump

WASHINGTON () More than a dozen countries face increased tariffs after President…