Islanders likely have unfortunate answer to toughest roster question
Share and Follow

The Islanders’ toughest roster decision, at least for now, has been made for them.

Cal Ritchie will be sidelined for 1-2 weeks following a lower-body injury sustained in the preseason finale against the Flyers, as announced by the Isles on Friday.

With the NHL’s roster deadline for opening night set for Monday and the Islanders set to kick off their season on Thursday night in Pittsburgh, this essentially rules out the possibility of Ritchie, the 20-year-old prospect who has spent the past three weeks vigorously trying to secure a lineup spot against the Penguins, being included.

Despite a stellar training camp performance, it was always going to be unlikely for Ritchie to make the initial 23-man roster because there wasn’t a clear spot for him in the lineup.

The Islanders have four centermen in Bo Horvat, Mat Barzal, JG Pageau and Casey Cizikas, which would have blocked Ritchie from playing his natural position.

Barzal and Cizikas have both played wing as recently as last season, but the Islanders are committed to starting the season with Barzal playing in the middle, and moving Cizikas still would have displaced another NHL regular — possibly Max Tsyplakov — from the lineup.

Isles coach Patrick Roy said during camp that it was his preference to play Ritchie at center, though he can play on the wing as well.

In the preseason and training camp, Ritchie was used exclusively down the middle, with Roy often shuffling Cizikas to the wing as a result.

As for the possibility of using Ritchie as an extra forward, while the Islanders never explicitly ruled it out, it’s hard to see how that would have been better for his development than playing top-line minutes in the American Hockey League.

It also would have likely forced the Islanders to subject either Kyle MacLean or Marc Gatcomb, who are projected to start the season as the team’s two extra forwards, to waivers, where any team could have picked them up. Ritchie is waivers-exempt and can be sent to AHL Bridgeport with no risk.

While Roy publicly left the door open to the Islanders carrying eight defensemen earlier this week — which would mean waiving MacLean or Gatcomb to make room for Isaiah George — that does not seem to be a likely route for the club to take, given that George is also waivers exempt, and would also seemingly benefit more from playing every night than sitting in an NHL press box.

If the Islanders do indeed send George down to start the season in Bridgeport, it would mean that their 23-man roster is, in essence, set, though the short time frame on Ritchie’s injury all but guarantees it won’t be long before there is another decision to make.

Pierre Engvall’s looming return from hip surgery — Engvall has been skating on his own but has not rejoined the team for a practice as of yet — also has the potential to complicate matters.

Ritchie, who was subject to the CHL/NHL agreement while with the Ontario League’s Oshawa Generals, has never played in the AHL. He won an NHL job with the Avalanche in training camp last season, but played just seven games in Colorado before being returned to juniors. Assuming he starts off in Bridgeport, after returning from injury, it may not be long before he is knocking on the NHL’s door yet again.

Indeed, Ritchie would be the current betting favorite to be the Islanders’ first forward to be called up from Bridgeport, if the time frame given on his injury proves accurate. 

Ritchie’s health has removed what would have been Mathieu Darche’s toughest decision from his plate.

But that is very much a temporary situation.


Jonathan Drouin (illness) missed practice Friday.


The Islanders will spend the weekend on a team bonding trip in the Hamptons, practicing Sunday on Eastern Long Island before returning home.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
FBI director Kash Patel speaks during a roundtable on criminal cartels with President Donald Trump in the State Dining Room of the White House, Thursday, Oct. 23, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

FBI Director Patel Announces Arrests in Connection with Halloween Weekend Attack Plot in Michigan

Published: October 31, 2025 / 08:48 AM CDT Updated: October 31, 2025…
Sudanese TikTok-loving warlord dubbed 'Butcher of Century' is arrested

Sudanese Warlord Known for TikTok Presence and Violent Reputation Arrested

A Sudanese warlord, known as Abu Lulu and infamously labeled the ‘butcher…
Marine kidnapped, sexually assaulted 12-year-old girl: FBI

FBI Investigates Shocking Case of Marine Accused in 12-Year-Old’s Abduction and Assault

A U.S. Marine on active duty has been taken into custody following…
Migrant wails 'Help me, I have my papers' as she's detained at airport

Detained at the Airport: Migrant’s Heart-Wrenching Plea for Justice Despite Having Papers

In a distressing scene captured on video, a female migrant was heard…
Lynwood boy killed: Parents, grandmother charged after 8-year-old Isaiah H. found dead in cooler in Lynwood, California

Tragic Discovery: Lynwood Family Faces Charges After 8-Year-Old Isaiah Found Deceased in Cooler

In Lynwood, California, a grim discovery has led to serious charges against…
Arrest made in deadly stabbing at Jacksonville Anheuser-Busch facility

Breaking News: Suspect Apprehended in Fatal Stabbing at Jacksonville Anheuser-Busch Plant

A tragic incident unfolded at an Anheuser-Busch facility on Jacksonville’s Northside, resulting…
First Coast surfing legend, Biddy Hunter, dies at age 77

Celebrated First Coast Surfing Icon Biddy Hunter Passes Away at 77

Dennis “Biddy” Hunter, a prominent figure in the surfing community, brought international…
JK Rowling criticises Glamour over 'Women of the Year 2025' decision

JK Rowling Challenges Glamour’s 2025 ‘Women of the Year’ Choice: A Controversy Unfolds

Renowned author J.K. Rowling has sparked controversy by criticizing Glamour Magazine for…