Jack Nicklaus wins $50M defamation lawsuit over LIV Golf, dementia claims
Share and Follow

On Monday, golf icon Jack Nicklaus secured a $50 million judgment in his defamation lawsuit against his former enterprise, Nicklaus Companies. He charged the company, along with two of its executives, with disseminating untrue claims about him considering a $750 million agreement to join LIV Golf.

A jury in Palm Beach County, Florida, delivered the decision, concluding that Nicklaus suffered reputational harm. The jury recognized that the 85-year-old faced “ridicule, hatred, mistrust, distrust or contempt” due to the accusations, which also suggested he had dementia and was not competent to handle his personal matters, as reported by the Palm Beach Post.

Named in the lawsuit were billionaire banker Howard Milstein, the executive chairman of Nicklaus Companies, and executive Andrew O’Brien. However, the jury found in their favor, sparing them from any additional financial penalties.


Jack Nicklaus sits during a recess in closing arguments at the Judge Daniel T. K. Hurley Courthouse in West Palm Beach on Oct. 20, 2025.
Jack Nicklaus sits during a recess in closing arguments at the Judge Daniel T. K. Hurley Courthouse in West Palm Beach on Oct. 20, 2025. via REUTERS

Following the jury’s decision, Nicklaus embraced his family and friends, according to the Palm Beach Post, though he refrained from commenting directly, directing inquiries to his lawyer.

“In defamation cases, especially for someone like Jack with such a stellar reputation, it’s challenging to demonstrate the damage,” said Nicklaus’ attorney, Eugene Stearns, to ESPN. “The key issue arose 3½ years ago when the company falsely announced Jack’s departure from the PGA Tour in favor of Saudi-backed golf. We’re pleased that Jack has been exonerated.”

The allegations were first made in a lawsuit the company filed against Nicklaus in New York, which spread in the media.


Jack Nicklaus (l.) poses with Scottie Scheffler (r.) after Scheffler's win at the Memorial on June 1, 2025.
Jack Nicklaus (l.) poses with Scottie Scheffler (r.) after Scheffler’s win at the Memorial on June 1, 2025. Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

“These are the people who planted a story,” Stearns told jurors during the closing arguments, per the Palm Beach Post. “The story is a lie. … What that they wanted to create in the minds of the public is Jack Nicklaus is an old guy who sold out to the Saudis.”

The defendants’ attorneys said the execs never wanted to smear Nicklaus.

Nicklaus’ company, Golden Bear International, was folded into the new Nicklaus Companies in a $145 million transaction in 2007.

When Nicklaus retired from his executive role in 2017, it triggered a five-year noncompete clause that stipulated he couldn’t endorse products outside of his former company or design golf courses, per the Palm Beach Post.

Nicklaus sought arbitration in 2022 to confirm he could use his name, image and likeness again, and he was then sued by Nicklaus Companies for allegedly breaching agreements. The company’s suit included the LIV Golf accusations.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Report: Florida government workers make the least in the U.S.

Florida Ranks Lowest in U.S. for Government Worker Salaries: New Report Reveals Wage Disparities

Despite Gov. DeSantis frequently highlighting salary increases for state employees, a recent…
The new Gold Rush: Companies race to mine rare earths in Texas

Texas Becomes a Hub for Rare Earth Mining as Companies Enter a Modern-Day Gold Rush

DALLAS — As lithium’s importance grows, fueling everything from electric cars to…
Former coworkers arrested after manager of famed strip club found gunned down in street: police

Former Colleagues Apprehended Following Fatal Shooting of Renowned Strip Club Manager, Police Report

In connection to the tragic shooting of Mark Calcagni, the general manager…
Harvey, Illinois residents pack chamber as Harvey City Council, Mayor Christopher J. Clark meet for 1st time since mass furloughs

Harvey, IL Residents Rally at City Council’s First Meeting Post-Mass Furloughs with Mayor Clark

The Harvey City Council convened on Monday for the first time since…
CNN boss' order on East Wing demolition coverage leaves staffers 'taken aback'

CNN Chief’s Unexpected Directive on East Wing Demolition Coverage Surprises Staff

Sources indicate that CNN employees were surprised when their boss suggested they…
The Jericho School for Children with Autism permanently closes, cites government shutdown impacts

Jericho School for Autism Shuts Down: How a Government Shutdown Sealed Its Fate

The Jericho School for Children with Autism has made the difficult decision…
Pittsburgh SWAT officers break silence in film, 7 years after Tree of Life Synagogue massacre

Pittsburgh SWAT Officers Share Their Story in New Documentary, Seven Years After Tree of Life Synagogue Tragedy

Seven years after the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history, a new…

Breaking: Suspects Apprehended in High-Profile Murder Case at Iconic California Strip Club

In a significant development, authorities have apprehended a man and a woman…