Jacksonville woman pleads guilty to killing girlfriend, leaving her remains out
Share and Follow


Shannon McCarthy, 46, was sentenced to 30 years in prison after changing her plea from not guilty to guilty on charges in her girlfriend’s murder.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — A Jacksonville woman was sentenced to 30 years in prison on Thursday after pleading guilty to killing her girlfriend and leaving her remains out on the front porch of their home for nearly a week in 2023, according to State Attorney Melissa Nelson.

Judge Meredith Charbula sentenced Shannon McCarthy, 46, after she changed her plea from not guilty to guilty on charges of second-degree murder, tampering with evidence and written threats to kill or do bodily injury for the murder of Heather Sheppard.

On July 3, 2023, Sheppard’s daughter contacted the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office to report Sheppard missing; she had been missing since June 29, 2023. 

On July 5, 2023, detectives found Sheppard’s remains in an “advanced state of decomposition” outside of her and McCarthy’s home on Colonial Avenue.

Police were at their home to investigate Sheppard’s disappearance, according to McCarthy’s arrest report. Nelson said in a release that McCarthy gave detectives permission to search the home, and that they witnessed her throw a tarp over items on the front porch. Detectives then removed the tarp, which led to the discovery of Sheppard’s remains.

Neighbors nearby the couple’s home reported smelling a “foul odor” before Sheppard’s body was located.

Sheppard’s family previously told First Coast News Sheppard’s phone was turned off, her credit cards were missing, a stained pair of shoes were found in the couple’s home, and that they found Sheppard’s truck with a bullet hole in it.

Sheppard’s autopsy confirmed she was shot multiple times, according to Nelson. 

“The Florida Department of Law Enforcement analyzed the projectiles and confirmed they matched McCarthy’s gun,” Nelson said in the release.

McCarthy was already facing charges from a reported battery against Sheppard in January 2023. She was out on bond on the battery charges, but her bond was revoked by a judge after Sheppard’s remains were found.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
All child care payments to Minnesota are FROZEN amid daycare scandal

Minnesota Halts Child Care Payments Following Daycare Scandal Investigation

The federal government has halted all child care payments to Minnesota amidst…
Who Jets, Giants need to watch as College Football Playoff unfolds

Key College Football Players the Jets and Giants Should Scout During Playoffs

This weekend’s NFL action has positioned the Giants and the Jets in…
Feds launch 'massive operation' in Minnesota amid fraud scandal

Federal Authorities Initiate Comprehensive Operation in Minnesota Following Fraud Scandal

Federal officers have rolled out a significant operation in Minnesota aimed at…
Is New Year's Day a federal holiday? Here's what's open and closed

New Year’s Day: Federal Holiday Status and What’s Open or Closed

Kicking off 2026, most workers will enjoy a day off, potentially complicating…

Devastating Christmas Storm Causes Mudslide to Ravage Southern California Home

The holiday season took a disastrous turn for one homeowner when a…
3 hikers, including 19-year-old, found dead on Southern California's Mount Baldy, sheriff's department says

Tragic Discovery: Three Hikers, Including Teen, Found Deceased on Mount Baldy in Southern California

A tragic incident unfolded in the Mount Baldy region of Southern California,…
FILE - Voters fill out their ballots Nov. 4, 2025, in Detroit. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, File)

Democrats on Alert: Concerns Rise Over Trump’s Potential Influence in Upcoming Midterms

Based on historical patterns, Republicans could face challenges in maintaining control of…
People fleeing NY, NJ in record numbers, survey says

Why New Yorkers and New Jerseyans are Leaving in Droves: Survey Reveals Alarming Exodus Trends

It’s a scenario reminiscent of “Escape From New York,” but for real.…