Share and Follow

CULVER, Ind. A large lakefront property in northern Indiana, owned by late Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay, has been listed for sale with an asking price of nearly $20 million.

The eight-bedroom, 12-bathroom home situated on Lake Maxinkuckee sits on over 5.5 acres of land along South Shore Drive in Culver, Indiana. The estate, which is being sold by Encore Sotheby’s Realty, hit the market on Wednesday with a price of $19.9 million.

With over 35,000 finished square feet across multiple structures, the estate is laid out across four levels with partial elevator access and includes 250 feet of lake frontage.

Other amenities on the property include:

  • Indoor/outdoor poolhouse with hot tub
  • Four fireplaces with outdoor lounge area
  • Eight-car garage
  • Four-lane bowling alley
  • Arcade stocked with games
  • Shooting range
  • Live plant wall
  • Steam room
  • Several fitness areas
  • Club-style bar
  • Butler’s pantry
  • Outdoor fire pit
  • Sand volleyball court
  • Outdoor dining terrace

The European-inspired main residence includes 14,000 square feet of space with timber-framed ceilings and a lower-level walkout onto the lake. The 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath guest house offers private accommodations and is connected to the residence and garage by underground tunnel.

“This rare compound represents the ultimate in Midwest lake living, blending luxury, scale and lifestyle in an iconic setting,” the listing reads. “This exceptional Lake Maxinkuckee estate offers timeless architectural elegance with lifestyle amenities across two connected parcels.”

Photos of the estate, provided by Sotheby’s employee Andrea Kelly, can be seen below:

The estate was owned by the late Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay, who died in May at the age of 65. His daughters Carlie Irsay-Gordon, Casey Foyt and Kalen Jackson have assumed organizational control of the Colts since his death.

In a statement sent Thursday to FOX59/CBS4, the Irsay daughters commented on the potential sale of the Culver lakehouse:

“Our family’s lake home in Culver has been a place of peace, joy, and connection for decades. On the shore of Lake Maxinkuckee, this property has been a quiet retreat from the busyness of life, a place where we’ve gathered as a family, celebrated milestones, and created some of our most cherished memories.

From sunrise boat rides to long summer evenings on the porch, every corner of the property holds a story. We learned to fish off the dock, roasted marshmallows under the stars, and shared countless laughs around the kitchen table. It’s where we could simply be together, without distraction, just present with each other and nature.

While it’s bittersweet to part with a home that has meant so much to us, we believe it’s time for another family to experience the magic of Culver and write their own story here. This property isn’t just a beautiful lakefront home, it’s a place that brings people closer together. And we hope it brings the next owner just as much happiness as it has brought to us.”

– The Irsay Daughters

For more information on the property and to view the full listing, click here.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
LaFayette, Indiana shooting injures Tippecanoe Judge Steven Meyer, wife, Kimberly, in Mill Pond Lane home: officials

Shooting Incident in LaFayette, Indiana Leaves Judge Steven Meyer and Wife Kimberly Injured, Authorities Report

An Indiana judge and his spouse were victims of a shooting in…
Stunned Antiques Roadshow guest apologises for 'nearly swearing'

Antiques Roadshow Guest in Shock: Apologizes for Almost Letting a Swear Word Slip

An Antiques Roadshow participant found herself apologizing for almost uttering a curse…
Poison ends plans for 2026 comeback tour claims band member

Band Member Reveals Poison’s 2026 Comeback Tour Plans Have Been Halted

Plans for a 2026 reunion tour by the iconic heavy metal band…
This week on The Hill: Lawmakers scramble to avert partial shutdown

This Week on Capitol Hill: Legislators Work Diligently to Prevent Partial Government Shutdown

Lawmakers in both the House and Senate find themselves in a critical…
Venezuela’s acting leader was once a DEA 'priority target': report

Report Reveals Venezuela’s Interim Leader Previously Labeled as DEA ‘Priority Target

Venezuela’s interim President, Delcy Rodríguez, has been identified in intelligence files from…
West Virginia teacher fired after arrest on child sex abuse charge

West Virginia Educator Dismissed Following Arrest for Alleged Child Sex Abuse

A West Virginia educator has been dismissed from her position following her…
FILE - This Aug. 7, 2025, satellite image shows construction of large white tents for a new immigrant detention center at Fort Bliss, a U.S. Army base outside El Paso, Texas. (Planet Labs via AP, File)

Tragic Loss: ICE Reports Suicide of Detainee at Texas Detention Center

An immigrant from Nicaragua was discovered dead last week at a Texas…
Knott’s Berry Farm guard bloodied in viral brawl over line cutting

Knott’s Berry Farm Security Injured in Line-Cutting Clash Captured on Video

A day at Knott’s Berry Farm intended for family enjoyment spiraled into…