Judge weighs Trump administration's request to end protections for immigrant children
Share and Follow


McALLEN, Texas (AP) — A judge on Friday was considering a Trump administration request to end a decades-old policy on protections for immigrant children in federal custody that the government says is inhibiting its immigration crackdown.

The administration asked U.S. District Judge Dolly Gee in Los Angeles during a hearing to dissolve the policy, which limits how long Customs and Border Protection can hold immigrant children and requires them to be kept in safe and sanitary conditions.

Gee, who oversees what is known as the Flores agreement, expressed skepticism at the government’s request but did not immediately issue a ruling. It was not clear how soon she will rule.

The judge pressed government attorney Joshua McCroskey on why President Donald Trump’s administration was holding children at the border for longer than the 72 hours laid out in the agreement when border arrests have reached record lows. She said it seems like conditions should be improving but they “are deteriorating.”

“It seems counterintuitive that should happen unless it’s willful,” said Gee, who was nominated to the court by President Barack Obama.

McCroskey said some children are being held for longer because Trump as part of his crackdown ended the Biden administration’s policy that allowed expedited releases of immigrants. McCroskey also pointed to logistical challenges that resulted from the closure of temporary facilities that were set up under President Joe Biden to handle an influx of immigrants.

In May, CBP held 46 children over a week, including six children held for over two weeks and four children held 19 days, according to data revealed in a court filing. In March and April, CPB reported that it had 213 children in custody for more than 72 hours. That included 14 children, including toddlers, who were held for over 20 days in April.

Advocates for immigrant children asked the judge to keep protections and oversight in place and submitted accounts from immigrants in Texas family detention centers who described adults fighting children for clean water, despondent toddlers and a child with swollen feet who was denied a medical exam. The advocates also want the judge to expand independent monitoring.

“I have met children who have spent days in jail cells with barely more than ramen noodles to eat, lights on day and night, no sunlight or access to the outside world and the indignity of using the restroom in front of guards. On top of that trauma — then to be flown to family detention and locked up with no end in sight? It is truly shameful,” Leecia Welch, the deputy legal director at Children’s Rights, said in an interview after the hearing.

The Flores agreement, named for a teenage plaintiff, was the result of over a decade of litigation between attorneys representing the rights of immigrant children and the U.S. government over widespread allegations of mistreatment in the 1980s. It governs the conditions for all immigrant children in U.S. custody, including those traveling alone or with their parents.

In its written motion, the Trump administration said the government has made substantial changes since the agreement was formalized in 1997, creating standards and policies governing the custody of immigrant children that conform to legislation and the agreement.

The administration is looking to expand immigration detention space, including by building more centers like one in Florida dubbed “Alligator Alcatraz,” where a lawsuit alleges detainees’ constitutional rights are being violated. In court, an attorney for the government, Tiberius Davis, acknowledged that the agreement hampers the administration’s efforts, even though Trump’s tax and spending bill provided billions to build new immigration facilities.

Davis said the bill gives the government authority to hold families in detention until they are removed or during their removal proceedings. “But currently under the Flores settlement agreement, that’s essentially void because we can’t actually have family centers that aren’t state licensed,” he said.

The Biden administration successfully pushed to partially end the agreement last year. Gee ruled that special court supervision may end when the children are transferred from CPB custody to the Department of Health and Human Services. But she carved out exceptions for certain types of facilities for children with more acute needs.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
FILE - A crowd marches across the Lefty O

US Political Tensions Ignite Calls for Action on MLK Day

As the nation marks the 40th federal observance of Martin Luther King…
Viral protest video against Iran’s supreme leader sparks copycat demonstrations worldwide

Global Wave of Protests Erupts as Viral Video Challenges Iran’s Supreme Leader

A captivating video featuring an Iranian refugee setting aflame an image of…
Jadin O'Brien's rapid rise is complete. The track star is now a US Olympic bobsledder.

Jadin O’Brien’s Meteoric Journey: From Track Star to US Olympic Bobsledder

Just a year ago, Jadin O’Brien was sprinting on the track for…
This week on The Hill: Lawmakers scramble to avert partial shutdown

This Week on Capitol Hill: Legislators Work Diligently to Prevent Partial Government Shutdown

Lawmakers in both the House and Senate find themselves in a critical…
Bills fire Sean McDermott after 9 seasons of falling short of reaching Super Bowl, AP sources say

Buffalo Bills Part Ways with Sean McDermott After Nine Seasons Without a Super Bowl Appearance, Reports Suggest

ORCHARD PARK, New York — The Buffalo Bills have parted ways with…
West Virginia teacher fired after arrest on child sex abuse charge

West Virginia Educator Dismissed Following Arrest for Alleged Child Sex Abuse

A West Virginia educator has been dismissed from her position following her…
Florida triple murder of 3 tourists was 'senseless,' 'random,' sheriff says

Florida Sheriff Condemns ‘Senseless’ and ‘Random’ Triple Murder of Tourists in Shocking Crime

A man from Florida faces charges of shooting and killing three tourists…
Fans can't believe Sylvester Stallone is nearly 80 in gym video

Sylvester Stallone Stuns Fans with Vigorous Gym Routine as He Nears 80

On Sunday, Sylvester Stallone gave fans a glimpse into his $35.3 million…