Judge tosses defamation lawsuit against Nancy Mace 
Share and Follow


A federal judge on Wednesday tossed a defamation lawsuit against Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.) filed after she took to the House floor to accuse a man of being a predator. 

U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel ruled that even if the lawsuit could proceed, federal law entitles the Justice Department to step in and largely make Mace immune from damages. 

Gergel did not address whether Mace actually defamed the man, Brian Musgrave, and acknowledged the ruling means he may have no ability to recover damages even if the congresswoman falsely destroyed his reputation, as Musgrave claims. 

“Congress has weighed the risks and benefits….and concluded that libel and related claims against federal officials acting within the scope of their employment are barred under federal law. It is this Court’s duty to uphold the rule of law,” the judge wrote. 

Gergel was nominated to the bench by former President Obama. 

Musgrave sued Mace in March after she gave a stunning speech on the House floor that included a series of allegations of sexual abuse and voyeurism. 

Mace, who is now running for governor of South Carolina, celebrated the ruling. 

“Today the court proved the US Constitution is the LAW OF THE LAND,” Mace said in a statement. “They came after me because I stood up for victims and demanded crime be prosecuted. Today’s court decision proves their lies and attacks won’t break me. I’ve put my career on the line to fight crime and drafted legislation to strengthen our laws. And I’ll never stop fighting for law and order.” 

Musgrave was one of four men whom Mace singled out in a stunning speech on the House floor in February, in which she lobbed accusations of sexual abuse and voyeurism. In addition to Musgrave, Mace had accused her ex-fiancé and two other men of wrongdoing. 

Eric Bland, Musgrave’s attorney, said the decision allows politicians to “say and do anything they want” but vowed to “keep fighting” to clear his client’s name. 

“It seems patently unfair that a United States citizen who lives a law-abiding life can be grouped and called a rapist and a predator without any proof, and it can be done over and over again with immunity (and impunity),” Bland said in a statement. 

Mace in the speech claimed to have found a hidden camera on a property that Musgrave owns with Mace’s ex-fiancé that had intimate photos of women taken without their knowledge or consent. Musgrave’s suit said he didn’t place the camera and never had knowledge of it.

While he was not the subject of Mace’s more serious allegations in the speech, such as her belief she was raped after being “purposefully incapacitated,” Mace labeled Musgrave along with the three other men as a “predator.”

The lawsuit took aim at the speech, Mace’s social media posts and a poster displayed outside her congressional office titled “PREDATORS” with images of the four men. The case also included claims against some of Mace’s congressional staff. 

Last month, the Justice Department sought to step in and largely replace Mace and the staffers as the defendant by certifying they were acting in the scope of their jobs, making them immune and leaving taxpayers on the hook for damages. 

Gergel, the judge, agreed that the government could do so on all but one claim: that Mace owes Musgrave damages for violating his constitutional rights, known as a Bivens action.

But the judge went on to dismiss that claim, too, finding it isn’t permitted in defamation cases and that Mace was protected anyway by the U.S. Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause. 

Mace has made her accusations against the men a central part of her political identity in recent months.

In a May subcommittee hearing she led on private spaces, she showed a blurry screenshot of what her “naked silhouette” that she said was recorded on a hidden camera on the property that was mentioned in her speech.

She launched a bid for governor of South Carolina this month. Among her primary opponents is South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson (R), who she accused of not adequately investigating her allegations. Wilson’s office at the time said that Mace “either does not understand or is purposefully mischaracterizing” Wilson’s role. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Speaker Mike Johnson among slew of top Republicans expected to retire

Key Republican Figures, Including Speaker Mike Johnson, Set to Step Down

House Speaker Mike Johnson is reportedly among a significant number of Republicans…
Who is Brian Cole? January 6 riot pipe bomb suspect named

Unmasking the January 6 Pipe Bomb Suspect: Meet Brian Cole

In a significant development five years after pipe bombs were planted around…
Suspected thieves caught on camera smashing Washington state storefront with truck in ATM heist attempt

Bold ATM Heist: Thieves Caught on Camera Crashing Truck into Washington Storefront

Video shows botched ATM heist at Walgreens The Pierce County Sheriff’s Office…
13-year-old in the US illegally denied release after alleged gang ties come to light following school threat

Undocumented Immigrant with Prior DUIs and Deportation Order Suspected in Fatal Crash Killing California Girl, 8

An undocumented immigrant, previously charged with DUI offenses and facing deportation orders…
Hochul tells companies to deliver goods overnight to cut down on congestion pricing fees

Governor Hochul Urges Overnight Deliveries to Help Businesses Save on Congestion Fees

New York Governor Kathy Hochul has stirred controversy with her recent suggestion…
Krista Joseph replaced as St. Johns County commissioner chair two weeks after reelection

Krista Joseph Ousted as St. Johns County Commission Chair Just Weeks After Reelection Victory

During a contentious assembly, Commissioner Clay Murphy initiated a vote aimed at…
Chicago Public Schools reaches $17.5M settlement over Little Village Lawndale High School Dean Brian Crowder sex abuse case

Chicago Public Schools Settles $17.5M in Landmark Little Village Lawndale HS Abuse Case

In a significant development, Chicago Public Schools (CPS) has reached a settlement…
Florida sheriff calls massive drug operation ''Breaking Bad' on steroids' after record-breaking bust

Florida’s Record-Breaking Drug Bust: Sheriff Labels Operation ‘Breaking Bad on Steroids

In a dramatic crackdown, Florida law enforcement officials confiscated approximately 92,000 pounds…