Nassau County man who killed family found to be mentally incompetent to stand trial
Share and Follow


William Broyles is accused of shooting his wife, daughter and son in their home. Broyles will be transported to a Florida State Hospital for competency restoration

NASSAU COUNTY, Fla. — A Nassau County man accused of killing his family last year has been found mentally incompetent to stand trial. 

William Broyles is accused of shooting his wife, daughter and son in their home. 

RELATED: Nassau County man accused of killing his family will have third mental health evaluation

Judge James Daniel says Broyles will be transported to a Florida State Hospital for evaluation and treatment for competency restoration. 

His ruling is based on the evaluation of two psychologists and their testimony in court Thursday afternoon.

Forensic Psychologist Dr. Allen Harris says he last evaluated William Broyles in October, observing him in his cell, not eating, lying in his bed and defecating on himself. 

“He would sit on the side of his bed, looking at the floor, playing with his feet for hours and hours at a time,” said Harris.

Harris says he cannot reach a clear conclusion about Broyles competency but recommends psychiatric hospitalization. 

Dr. Jennifer Rohrer agrees with Harris. She testified his psychological and physical well-being has declined significantly over the last few months. Rohrer says it is unknown why he is psychotic or if there is an unknown medical condition involved but says hospitalization can rule that out. 

“At the state hospital, he would be observed 24/7 the entire time he is there, when professional staff are there, when they are not when he doesn’t think he is observed he is being observed,” Rohrer said. 

RELATED: Prosecutors seeking death penalty after Nassau County man reportedly shot family, then called 911

The prosecution says it’s hard for them to make a decision on Broyles’ mental state because they believe he killed his family. Judge James Daniel says the evidence is clear. 

“The defendant in this case does not have a present ability to consult with his lawyer with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and he does not have a factual understanding of the proceedings against him,” Judge James Daniel said. 

Rohrer says based on her evaluations, she has provisionally diagnosed Broyles with major depressive disorder with psychotic features. 

RELATED: Nassau County man fatally shot wife, two children multiple times then called 911, deputies say

RELATED: Prosecutors seeking death penalty after Nassau County man reportedly shot family, then called 911

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Fourth body found in search for US and Australian surfers who mysteriously vanished in Mexico

Another body discovered in the search for American and Australian surfers who disappeared in Mexico

A fourth body has reportedly been discovered in a popular Mexican tourist…
Over 380K more NYC students had info leaked, bringing total to over 1M

More than 380,000 additional students in NYC had their information exposed, increasing the total number to over 1 million.

More than 380,000 more students attending public schools in the city had…
Lindsey Graham sends UNC counter protesters Chick-fil-A for 'protecting Old Glory'

Lindsey Graham Shows Support for UNC Counter Protesters by Sending Chick-fil-A to Honor Defense of American Flag

(The Hill) Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) said he is sending Chick-fil-A to…
Fourth body found where three missing surfers located

Fourth Body Discovered in Location of Previously Missing Surfers

Amber Coakley, Domenick Candelieri, Salvador Rivera Updated: May 4, 2024 / 01:11…
Will Harry get to see his busy father when he visits the UK?

Will Harry be able to meet his father who has a hectic schedule when he travels to the UK?

When Prince Harry visits Britain this week, he will attend an event…
Three suspects arrested in disappearance of three surfers in Mexico

Three individuals taken into custody in connection with the vanishing of three surfers in Mexico

In Baja California, Mexico, a fourth body has been found in a…
Irish Nobleman Pub targeted in West Town, Chicago robbery at 1367 West Erie Street, surveillance video shows

Surveillance video shows robbery at Irish Nobleman Pub in West Town, Chicago

CHICAGO (WLS) — No one can believe how fast it happened. Security…
Bodies found as Mexican police discover tents, question people in case of San Diego man, 2 Australians missing in Baja

Authorities believe that the bodies found in Baja California, Mexico are likely the remains of an American and two Australians who were reported missing.

MEXICO CITY — Three bodies recovered in an area of Baja California…