Defense rests in trial of Karen Read, who's charged in death of Boston police officer boyfriend John O'Keefe
Share and Follow

The defense in the second trial of Karen Read rested its case on Wednesday and said Read was framed for the killing of her Boston police officer boyfriend.

Read, 45, is accused of fatally striking O’Keefe with her SUV and leaving him to die in the snow outside another officer’s home when she dropped him off at a party in January 2022 after the two had been drinking. She’s charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter and leaving the scene in Canton, outside Boston.

Prosecutors have said Read intentionally struck O’Keefe with her sport utility vehicle and left him to die. Read’s defense has suggested she was the victim of a wide-ranging conspiracy that included planting evidence and using her as a convenient scapegoat for her boyfriend’s death.

Defense attorneys in the case have accused the prosecution of twisting Read’s words into a confession she never made. The state has pointed to a television interview in which Read said, “I mean, I didn’t think I ‘hit him’ hit him, but I could I have clipped him?”

That’s not a confession but a person expressing genuine concern during a desperate situation, defense attorney Alan Jackson has said.

“That’s a person trying to make sense of an unexplainable circumstance, a natural concern of a bereaved significant other,” he said.

A crash expert who testified for the defense said, based on tests he performed, the damage to Read’s taillight and O’Keefe’s clothing was inconsistent with her SUV striking an arm or body at the speed described by the prosecution.

Dr. Elizabeth Laposata, a former medical examiner called by the defense, said O’Keefe’s injuries were indeed consistent with blunt force trauma to the back of the head, but that his eye wounds were not consistent with being hit by the rear of Read’s SUV. She also testified she did not think O’Keefe was hit by the SUV at all.

The defense also unsuccessfully sought a mistrial earlier in the second trial. Read’s first trial ended in a mistrial due to a hung jury. The attempt for a second mistrial hinged on a defense theory that O’Keefe was beaten inside the home where the party took place, and that he was bitten by a family dog and then left outside as part of a conspiracy by the police that included planting evidence against Read.

Karen Read talks with her defense team before the start of court and the jury is seated during her retrial in Norfolk Superior Court, Wednesday, June 11, 2025, in Dedham, Mass.

Karen Read talks with her defense team before the start of court and the jury is seated during her retrial in Norfolk Superior Court, Wednesday, June 11, 2025, in Dedham, Mass.

(Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP, Pool)

The defense team tried for a second mistrial after the prosecution pointed out that no dog DNA was found on O’Keefe. The defense said there had been no mention in the trial about DNA and the dog bite, and argued that raising the subject while questioning Russell had prejudiced the jury.

Superior Court Judge Beverly Cannone said the trial could proceed.

The defense has also attempted to show that police were biased against Read from the start and wanted to pin O’Keefe’s death on her. Jonathan Diamandis, a friend of Michael Proctor, the lead investigator of Read’s case, was asked by the defense team to read text messages that Proctor sent to friends about the investigation.

Proctor was fired in March after a disciplinary board found he sent sexist and crude text messages about Read to his family and colleagues. His testimony played a key role in the first trial. Defense attorneys used his text messages to attempt to show that Proctor was biased and ignored the possibility of other suspects.

The next big step in the case is closing statements from both sides. The case will then go to the jury.

Copyright © 2025 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
House price crash warning as No2 homebuilder forced into drastic act

Major Homebuilder Takes Drastic Measures Amid Looming Housing Market Decline

The U.S. housing market is showing signs of a potential downturn, with…
Heartbreak after body found in search for missing teen

Tragic Discovery: Missing Teen’s Body Found in Heart-Wrenching Search

The mother of a missing teen heartbreakingly uttered “so close to home”…
2025 recap: New Bears era, Chicago-born Pope Leo, CPD officer killed, fiery CTA attack, Operation 'Midway Blitz', and more

Highlights of 2025: Chicago’s New Bears Legacy, Hometown Hero Pope Leo, Tragic Loss of CPD Officer, Explosive CTA Incident, and ‘Midway Blitz’ Unveiled

As 2025 draws to a close, ABC7 takes a moment to look…
Three hikers found dead on mountain with winds preventing recovery

Tragic Discovery: Extreme Winds Hamper Recovery of Three Deceased Hikers on Mountain

In a tragic incident on a California mountain, three individuals lost their…
New Orleans is still seeking permanent security solutions a year after deadly Bourbon Street attack

New Orleans Continues Pursuit of Lasting Security Measures One Year After Fatal Bourbon Street Incident

Almost a year has passed since a tragic New Year’s Day incident…
Trump WITHDRAWS National Guard troops from three Democratic cities

Trump Orders Withdrawal of National Guard Troops from Three Major Cities

Donald Trump has officially pulled the National Guard troops out of the…
$400K in lobster meat destined for Costco stores in Illinois, Minnesota stolen by a fraudulent trucking company: broker

$400K Worth of Lobster Meat Vanishes En Route to Midwest Costco Locations in Suspected Trucking Scam

CONCORD, N.H. — Picture a lavish seafood spread gone awry. In a…
Mali and Burkina Faso announce reciprocal travel ban on US

Mali and Burkina Faso Implement Mutual Travel Ban on U.S. Citizens Amid Diplomatic Tensions

Mali and Burkina Faso have announced a travel ban targeting U.S. citizens,…