Katy Perry's legal victory in Montecito mansion
Share and Follow

Katy Perry has emerged victorious in a legal battle concerning the purchase of a luxurious Montecito home from disabled veteran Carl Westcott. The court has decided that Perry is entitled to nearly $2 million in damages related to the $15 million property acquisition that occurred five years ago.

The ruling, handed down by Judge Joseph Lipner from the Superior Court of California in Los Angeles County, concluded that the pop star should receive $1,842,142.84. This decision, detailed in court documents accessed by People, comes as a resolution to the ongoing dispute over the property.

The awarded sum was calculated by considering multiple factors: the rental value accrued during the delay in finalizing the sale, which exceeded $2.7 million, and deducting both the retained capital of over $1 million and Westcott’s lost interest of nearly $150,000. Additionally, the judge adjusted the amount Perry requested for necessary repairs to $259,581.84, aligning with a figure previously proposed by Westcott himself.

The transaction details reveal that Perry’s business manager, Bernie Gudvi, initially paid Westcott $9 million, withholding $6 million from the purchase price. According to People, this latest ruling allows Gudvi to deduct the $1.8 million in damages from the remaining $6 million. Initially, Westcott had filed a lawsuit against Gudvi, claiming that Perry was still liable to pay the $6 million balance of the home’s agreed price.

In regards to the $15 million sale, the judge noted that Perry’s business manager Bernie Gudvi paid Westcott $9 million for the purchase and kept $6 million of the purchase price. People says that Gudvi is now able to subtract $1.8 million from the leftover $6 million. (Westcott first sued Gudvi over the purchase and his lawyers said Perry actually owed Westcott $6 million of the $15 million she paid for the home). 

In addition, Gudvi has been tasked with preparing the judgement. A hearing in which he can challenge the judgement has been set for December 30, according to People.

A judge has awarded Katy Perry nearly $2 million in damages in her legal war against disabled veteran Carl Westcott over the $15 million Montecito home she purchased from him five years ago

A judge has awarded Katy Perry nearly $2 million in damages in her legal war against disabled veteran Carl Westcott over the $15 million Montecito home she purchased from him five years ago 

The legal battle over the home dates back to 2020, when the 41-year-old singer bought the home from 1-800-Flowers founder Westcott - but within days he tried backing out of the deal, claiming he was incapacitated at the time he signed the paperwork due to painkillers

The legal battle over the home dates back to 2020, when the 41-year-old singer bought the home from 1-800-Flowers founder Westcott – but within days he tried backing out of the deal, claiming he was incapacitated at the time he signed the paperwork due to painkillers 

The legal battle over the home dates back to 2020, when the 41-year-old singer bought the home from 1-800-Flowers founder Westcott – but within days he tried backing out of the deal, claiming he was incapacitated at the time he signed the paperwork due to painkillers.

His backtracking sparked a legal battle over the sale of the eight-bedroom, 11-bathroom home in the upscale community that counts Meghan Markle and Oprah Winfrey among its residents. 

The judge ruled in Perry’s favor in May 2024, finding that Westcott was of sound mind and presented ‘no persuasive evidence that he lacked capacity to enter into a real estate contract.’

The judge’s ruling comes in response to court documents Perry filed just days earlier. 

In documents reviewed by Daily Mail, Perry said Westcott is accountable for lost money in rentals as well as for repairs she needed to make on the mansion.

The I Kissed a Girl songstress asked the court to force Westcott to pay $4,718,698.95 to account for damages she says he caused with extended litigation over the real estate sale. 

Westcott initially sued Perry’s business manager Bernie Gudvi the month after the sale went through. 

Attorneys for the Roar artist, who bought the home with ex-boyfriend Orlando Bloom, 48, said that she is ‘entitled to $3,525,000 in rental value’ that she lost due to the extended legal battle with Westcott.

Westcott should also pay the Santa Barbara, California native a total of ‘$1,343,401.95 for necessary repairs for a total of $4,868,401.95,’ her attorney said in court documents.

Lawyers for Perry said that after deducting $149,703 for losses Westcott had suffered, the final sum came out to $4,718,698.95.

The judge ruled in Perry’s favor in May 2024, finding that Westcott (pictured with son Chart) was of sound mind and presented 'no persuasive evidence that he lacked capacity to enter into a real estate contract'

The judge ruled in Perry’s favor in May 2024, finding that Westcott (pictured with son Chart) was of sound mind and presented ‘no persuasive evidence that he lacked capacity to enter into a real estate contract’ 

In court documents filed November 21, Perry said Westcott was accountable for lost money in rentals as well as for repairs she needed to make on the mansion, according to legal documents reviewed by Daily Mail

In court documents filed November 21, Perry said Westcott was accountable for lost money in rentals as well as for repairs she needed to make on the mansion, according to legal documents reviewed by Daily Mail 

Attorneys for Westcott said that it’s actually Perry that owes money, in terms of the financials involved.

Perry owes Westcott $6 million of the $15 million she agreed to pay for the property, Westcott’s lawyers said.

Westcott’s attorney said in legal docs filed in Los Angeles on November 7 that Perry has only paid $9 million.

Westcott would agree to deduct repair costs to whittle the amount down to $5,740,418.18, his legal team said.

In August, Perry testified via a Zoom stream to Los Angeles Court about her purchase of the property, which is spread over 2.5 acres.

Perry was asked by Westcott lawyer Andrew J. Thomas if she was positioned to ‘gain money or anything else from the outcome of this litigation.’

Judge Joseph Lipner of the Superior Court of the State of California in Los Angeles County has concluded that the Roar singer is owed $1,842,142.84

Judge Joseph Lipner of the Superior Court of the State of California in Los Angeles County has concluded that the Roar singer is owed $1,842,142.84 

The singer replied, ‘Yes … justice; I stand to lose money if it does not work in my favor.’

Perry has been romantically-linked with former Canada Prime Minister Justin Trudeau since her split with Bloom.

The California Gurls vocalist and the politician were first seen in late July dining at the Montreal restaurant Le Violon.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Eric Schmidt lashes out at ex-mistress after claims of rape and spying

Eric Schmidt Breaks Silence: Responds to Explosive Allegations of Misconduct and Espionage

Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt is entangled in a bitter legal dispute…
What stores are open, closed on Thanksgiving 2025? Grocery, drugstores and more

Thanksgiving 2025: Which Grocery Stores and Pharmacies Will Be Open or Closed?

If you’re considering a shopping trip around your Thanksgiving meal, there are…
Amazon warns customers of scams ahead of Black Friday shopping rush

Amazon Alerts Shoppers to Potential Scams Before Black Friday Frenzy

As the holiday shopping frenzy kicks off, Amazon is sounding the alarm…
Migrant teenagers charged in fatal stabbing of homeless man in Chicago

Tragic Incident: Migrant Teens Charged in Fatal Stabbing of Homeless Man in Chicago

A tragic incident unfolded in Chicago over the weekend, where three teenage…
DC Mayor Muriel Bowser not seeking reelection after 3 term

DC Mayor Muriel Bowser Announces Decision to Step Down After Three Successful Terms

Washington, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser announced on Tuesday that she will not…
FILE - The Rev. Jesse Jackson listens to speakers at the Tabernacle Baptist Church during the 60th anniversary of the march to ensure that African Americans could exercise their constitutional right to vote, March 9, 2025, in Selma, Ala. (AP Photo/Mike Stewart, File)

Jesse Jackson Discharged After Successful Treatment for Neurological Disorder: Civil Rights Icon on Path to Recovery

CHICAGO (AP) — The Rev. Jesse Jackson has returned home after being…
HCA Orange Park Hospital employee arrested, accused of assaulting 73-year-old patient

HCA Orange Park Hospital Staff Member Arrested on Charges of Assaulting 73-Year-Old Patient

In a disturbing incident at HCA Orange Park Hospital, a hospital employee…
Chicago crime: Thieves target cars parked near ZooLights at Lincoln Park Zoo, police say

Thieves Strike Cars Parked Near Lincoln Park Zoo’s ZooLights, Police Report

ByABC7 Chicago Digital Team Wednesday, November 26, 2025 5:31PM Live streaming newscasts,…