Supreme Court revives lawsuit over mistaken FBI raid
Share and Follow


The Supreme Court on Thursday revived an Atlanta family’s lawsuit over a botched FBI raid on their home in 2017 but put off deciding its ultimate fate.

In a unanimous decision, the justices instead sent the case back to a lower court to take another crack at deciding whether the lawsuit can move forward.  

Federal agents smashed through Trina Martin’s front door in 2017 while executing a search warrant at the wrong address, believing it was the home of an alleged violent gang member. Martin and her boyfriend at the time were startled out of bed with a flash-bang grenade and guns raised, as her 7-year-old son screamed from another room.  

She sued the government in 2019, accusing the agents of assault and battery, false arrest and other violations, under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), which waives the government’s sovereign immunity and lets people injured by certain actions of federal officers bring some claims for damages against it under state law.  

But a federal judge in Atlanta dismissed the suit and the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision. The justices now say the lower courts erred.

“Where does all that leave the case before us?” Justice Neil Gorsuch asked in the court’s opinion.

“We can say this much: The plaintiffs’ intentional-tort claims survive their encounter with subsection (h) thanks to the law enforcement proviso, as the Eleventh Circuit recognized. But it remains for that court on remand to consider whether subsection (a)’s discretionary-function exception bars either the plaintiffs’ negligent or intentional-tort claims,” he wrote. 

Patrick Jaicomo, Martin’s lawyer, argued before the justices that “innocent victims” of the government’s mistakes must have an available legal remedy. The FTCA was amended in 1974 after a pair of wrong-house raids made headlines, which he suggested makes clear that Martin’s lawsuit should be allowed to proceed.  

Exceptions to the law make it more complicated.  

Frederick Liu, who argued for the government, said that an exception to the FTCA preventing plaintiffs from suing the government for damages that arise out of an officer’s discretionary acts applies to the case. He also suggested that entering the wrong home was a “reasonable mistake” and an example of the “policy trade-offs” officers make when placed in risky situations. 

In the court’s opinion, Gorsuch acknowledged that lower courts have taken different views on the discretionary-function exception and that “important questions” must be weighed regarding under which circumstances they apply.  

“But those questions lie well beyond the two we granted certiorari to address,” Gorsuch wrote. “And before addressing them, we would benefit from the Eleventh Circuit’s careful reexamination of this case in the first instance. 

“It is work enough for the day to answer the questions we took this case to resolve, clear away the two faulty assumptions on which that court has relied in the past and redirect it to the proper inquiry,” he said.  

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
TV weatherman arrested after allegedly punching girlfriend 'several times' while her kids were nearby

TV weatherman arrested after allegedly punching girlfriend ‘several times’ while her kids were nearby

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A meteorologist in New…
Ben Affleck's whispers to Jennifer Lopez on the red carpet revealed

Revealed: What Ben Affleck Secretly Told Jennifer Lopez on the Red Carpet

A hand on her lower back, intimate whispers, and the first sighting…
White House mocks Kamala Harris’ ‘cackle’ after she suggests Trump admin is ‘crazy’ at LA event 

White House Jokes About Kamala Harris’ Laugh Following Her Comments on Trump Administration at LA Event

The White House responded sharply to former Vice President Kamala Harris on…
NYC girls aged 12 and 13 meet tragic end after 'subway surfing' at 3am

Tragedy Strikes as Two NYC Teens, 12 and 13, Die in Late-Night Subway Surfing Accident

Two teenage girls who died after going subway surfing in New York…
Shooting at Wawa on Cassat Avenue in Jacksonville leaves man injured

Man Injured After Shooting at Cassat Avenue Wawa in Jacksonville

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office said the victim and suspect were arguing about…
Flight chaos as air traffic control systems go dark

Air Travel Disruption as Air Traffic Control Systems Experience Outage

The ongoing government shutdown has resulted in yet another major air traffic…
Beloved rock singer Ann Everton killed in car crash as she began tour

Rock Star Ann Everton Tragically Dies in Car Accident at Start of Tour

Rock star Ann Everton has been killed in a car crash on…
Feds charge ‘keyboard warriors’ who threatened ICE deportation officer and wife on Instagram

Feds charge ‘keyboard warriors’ who threatened ICE deportation officer and wife on Instagram

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A federal grand jury…