Video shows man detained by ICE, judge says he 'feels bad'
Share and Follow


OGDEN, Utah (ABC4) One man who appeared in the Ogden Justice Court for misdemeanor charges was informed by a judge that he would be taken into ICE custody following the hearing of his case.

Court records show the man was charged with three misdemeanors after rear-ending another driver while driving under the influence. He then fled the scene before later being confronted and taken into custody.

During the hearing, Judge Clay Stucki told the man that ICE had given an order to take him into custody – something he did not want to have to do.

“I personally feel bad that we’re going to have to take you into custody,” Stucki could be heard saying in the courtroom video. “That isn’t my choice or decision, but it’s something under federal law that I’m going to have to follow.”

Stucki ordered the man not to leave the courthouse as he wanted to give him a chance to resolve the case. Before leaving the stand, the defendant thanked Judge Stucki, who simply replied, “Don’t thank me. I am sad.”

The man was able to find a resolution to the case, having two of his charges dismissed and the other reduced to a lesser charge.

While the punishment for the crime required a jail sentence, probation, and regular drug and alcohol evaluations, Stucki waived it all as the man would be taken into ICE custody. Stucki argued that this would prevent the man from completing his state requirements.

“I don’t think impaired driving makes you a bad person or would make you a bad citizen. It’s just a mistake that you don’t need to make again,” explained Stucki. “I hope whatever judge you see in the immigration system sees it the same way.”

A memo obtained by ABC4 that was sent to Judiciary employees from the Administrative Office of the Courts explained that courts do not have the power to stop ICE. Chief Justice Matthew Durrant and State Court Administrator Ron Gordon said in the memo that judiciary employees cannot interfere with ICE enforcement nor warn courthouse patrons about any potential ICE plans to be on location.

“We recognize and understand that this may be concerning for some judicial officers and employees and that these issues can evoke strong personal feelings,” wrote Durrant and Gordon. “The judiciary values the well-being of all judicial officers and employees and remains committed to fostering a professional and respectful workplace. It is also essential that we uphold the judiciary’s role as a neutral and impartial institution.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Maserati-driving GOP staffer ordered to get psych treatment

GOP Staffer With Maserati Mandated to Undergo Psychological Treatment

A former GOP staffer, who staged an intricate hoax by faking her…
Former California deputy Marvin Morales suspected of killing his 11-year-old son is fatally shot during police pursuit

Tragic Pursuit Ends: Ex-California Deputy and Suspected Child Killer Shot Dead by Police

A former sheriff’s deputy from California, accused of the tragic stabbing of…
Death of Travis Barker's rapper pal POORSTACY eyed as suicide, but family suspects foul play

Travis Barker’s Rapper Friend POORSTACY’s Mysterious Death: Suicide or Foul Play?

The tragic passing of rapper POORSTACY, a close associate of Travis Barker,…
New Mexico man jailed for threatening Trump on social media

New Mexico Resident Arrested Over Online Threats Against Trump

An Albuquerque resident has been handed a federal prison sentence of approximately…
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania residents say windshield barnacles are predatory, question legality

Philadelphia Residents Challenge Legality of Windshield Barnacles, Labeling Them as Predatory

In Philadelphia’s Northern Liberties neighborhood, a contentious parking enforcement strategy has ignited…
DC National Guard shooting suspect formally charged: 'Nothing is off the table'

DC National Guard Shooting: Suspect Faces Formal Charges as Investigation Intensifies

The man accused of a shocking attack just steps from the White…
Texas Tech restricts teaching of race and gender, faculty could be disciplined for violating rule

Texas Tech Enforces New Restrictions on Race and Gender Education, Faculty Face Potential Discipline for Non-Compliance

In a recent move, Texas Tech University System Chancellor Brandon Creighton has…
De'Avion Smith, bicyclist killed in Elwood, IL hit-and-run crash near Route 53 and Tehle Road, remembered as beacon of positivity

Tragic Loss: Celebrating the Life and Legacy of De’Avion Smith After Elwood, IL Hit-and-Run

In Elwood, Illinois, emotions ran high on Tuesday evening as a fundraiser…