This document included as an exhibit in a civil lawsuit shows a document 16 people submitted saying that Michigan's electoral votes went to then-President Donald Trump. Michigan's 2020 votes actually went to President Joe Biden.
Share and Follow

WYOMING, Mich. (WOOD) A group of so-called fake electors who tried to get Michigan’s 2020 electoral votes directed to President Donald Trump had their charges dismissed Tuesday.

District Court Judge Simmons said she saw no intent to commit fraud in the defendants’ actions. Whether they were “right, wrong or indifferent,” they “seriously believed” there were problems with the election, the judge said.

“I believe they were executing their constitutional right to seek redress,” Simmons said.

The group had been accused of meeting in December 2020 to sign a document falsely stating that they were Michigan’s electors and directing the state’s votes to former President Donald Trump. That document was sent to the U.S. Senate and the National Archives.

The Michigan attorney general argued that it was an attempt to unlawfully send Michigan’s electoral votes to Trump when they, in fact, went to former President Joe Biden. (Biden won Michigan by nearly 155,000 votes, a result confirmed by a GOP-led state Senate investigation in 2021.)

This document included as an exhibit in a civil lawsuit shows a document 16 people submitted saying that Michigan's electoral votes went to then-President Donald Trump. Michigan's 2020 votes actually went to President Joe Biden.
This document included as an exhibit in a civil lawsuit shows a document 16 people submitted saying that Michigan’s electoral votes went to then-President Donald Trump. Michigan’s 2020 votes actually went to President Joe Biden.

In 2023, the defendants were charged with a number of counts in connection with the scheme, including fraud, forgery and election law forgery.

One man accused in the Michigan case had the charges against him dropped after he agreed to cooperate with the state attorney general’s office in October 2023. The other 15 defendants pleaded not guilty and have maintained that their actions were not illegal.

Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, a Democrat, called Simmons’ ruling “disappointing” and a “very wrong decision” during a virtual news conference.

“It’s been claimed that these charges were vindictive or political, and I will say this: Nothing can be further from the truth,” Nessel said. “As prosecutors, we have a moral and ethical obligation to bring charges when there is evidence of a crime. And despite today’s very wrong decision, the evidence is clear and overwhelming. And to have not have brought these charges in the face of these facts because it would have been controversial or met with political accusations would really actually be the most political thing a prosecutor could do.”

Nessel said she believed evidence would support criminal charges if the case had been brought before a jury.

“They knew they were not electors,” Nessel said of the group. “They knew Donald Trump lost, but then they lied anyway. And that is a crime.”

Nessel said her office is considering appealing the decision.

Kent Vanderwood, the mayor of Wyoming, Michigan, and also one of the defendants who signed the document, shared a statement with Nexstar’s WOOD thanking Judge Simmons for a “thorough and thoughtful approach to this matter.”

“This entire episode has now been unmasked for what it always was: a partisan ploy to score political points,” Vanderwood stated. “I love my country, my State, and my City. We won’t always agree on every policy, but the use of state resources to harass law-abiding citizens needs to stop.”

Vanderwood added that he would continue to focus on serving the people of Wyoming.

“I have [a] lot left to do in the time God gives me, and I look forward to investing in my family and friends, as well as serving my community with energy and vigor in my remaining months in office,” he said.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Three US Air Force members dead in suspected murder suicide in Ohio

Tragic Incident in Ohio: Three Air Force Personnel Found Dead in Possible Murder-Suicide

The tragic deaths of three U.S. Air Force personnel have sent shockwaves…
Leaked plans reveal Kimberly Guilfoyle party with famous Greek celeb

Confidential Details Uncover Kimberly Guilfoyle’s Upcoming Party Featuring Prominent Greek Celebrity

America’s newly appointed ambassador to Greece is stirring the diplomatic pot with…
Florida executes Norman Mearle Grim Jr. marking 15th execution for state in 2025

Florida Executes 15th Inmate of 2025: The Controversial Case of Norman Mearle Grim Jr.

On Tuesday, Florida marked its 15th execution this year—a historic number under…
Elon Musk launches Grokipedia to compete with online encyclopedia Wikipedia

Elon Musk Unveils Grokipedia: A New Rival to Wikipedia

Elon Musk has unveiled a new venture called Grokipedia, an online encyclopedia…
Trump orders Pentagon to resume nuclear tests 'immediately'

Breaking: Trump Directs Pentagon to Restart Nuclear Tests – What This Means for Global Security

Just before a crucial meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping, former President…
Hurricane Melissa leaves trail of destruction across Cuba, Haiti and Jamaica

Hurricane Melissa Ravages Cuba, Haiti, and Jamaica: A Comprehensive Look at the Devastation

On Tuesday, Hurricane Melissa unleashed its fury as a Category 5 storm,…
Woman dies after oncoming car hits deer, sends it flying through windshield

Tragic Accident: Deer Thrown Through Windshield Claims Woman’s Life

PARAGON, Ind. (WXIN) — Tragedy struck in Indiana on Saturday when a…
Portland says 'manufactured crisis' spurred Trump's National Guard bid as trial begins

Portland Criticizes ‘Fabricated Crisis’ Behind Trump’s National Guard Proposal as Legal Proceedings Start

Portland, Oregon, has criticized President Trump’s attempt to deploy the National Guard,…