NYC judge who freed brute accused of beating elderly man shuts door on Post reporter
Share and Follow

A judge in Manhattan who was responsible for releasing Johnson Earl, a repeat offender, after he reportedly attacked an elderly man, declined to discuss her decision when approached by The Post on Saturday.

When a reporter introduced themselves, Beverly Tatham, visibly annoyed, firmly stated, “Noooo – you cannot come to my home,” before promptly closing the door to her residence in Brownsville.

It appeared that the judge, who had allowed the 44-year-old Earl to be released under supervision, was not willing to justify her actions despite the fact that he was facing a charge of second-degree assault for allegedly assaulting an 83-year-old man on a subway train in Lower Manhattan the previous month, as per the police.


Johnson Earl's mugshot
Johnson Earl was charged with second-degree assault for the horrifying Dec. 20 attack on an 83-year-old man.

The horrifying attack unfolded on Dec. 20 after the senior accidentally stumbled over Earl’s foot as a southbound No. 5 train was approaching Fulton Street station, police said. 

Earl, enraged, apparently socked the elderly man in the face, sparking a brawl that ended with the perp putting the victim in a chokehold before continuing to pummel him, an assistant district attorney said during Earl’s Jan. 2 arraignment.

The assault left the man with cuts to his face and head, and he later took himself to the Kings County Hospital Center for treatment, according to police. 

Despite pleas from the Manhattan District Attorney’s office to set Earl’s bail at $75,000 cash or $100,000 bond – and a lengthy rap sheet that includes 13 prior arrests – Tatham opted to release him back onto the streets.


Judge Beverly Tatham posing in a chair
“Noooo – you cannot come to my home,” an irritated Judge Beverly Tatham said in response to a Post reporter identifying themself. Judge Beverly Tatham

In July, Earl was arrested for repeatedly punching a security guard at a 99-cent store in The Bronx, according to the criminal complaint, which alleges that he seethed “Why are you not attending to me?” during the beatdown.

He was ordered to stay away from the victim, but the case was later adjourned in contemplation of dismissal, according to Bronx prosecutors.

The career criminal has been arrested at least four other times for assault dating back to 1999, according to police sources.

He’s also been nabbed in the past for criminal possession of a weapon and marijuana possession, the sources added. 

Earl is next scheduled to appear in court on Feb. 27, records show. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
US strikes 'terrorist boat' lurking in international waters

U.S. Targets Suspected Terrorist Vessel Operating in International Waters

The U.S. military has once again targeted a narco-terrorism vessel in international…
FILE - Fourth District Court Judge Tony Graf presides over a hearing for Tyler Robinson, who is accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, Thursday, Dec. 11, 2025, in Provo, Utah. (Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, Pool, File)

Judge Mandates Release of Transcript in High-Profile Charlie Kirk Murder Case

A Utah judge has mandated the release of a transcript from a…
Cheryl Hines opens up about RFK Jr. offering fake split

Cheryl Hines Discusses the Misleading Rumors of a Breakup with RFK Jr.

Cheryl Hines recently disclosed that her husband, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., suggested…
Flu season 2025: Subclade K variant known as 'Super K' showing fast flu symptoms amid holiday gatherings

Prepare for Flu Season 2025: ‘Super K’ Variant Sparks Rapid Symptom Spread During Holidays

Health officials are raising alarms as this flu season intensifies, with conditions…
Congresswoman accused of stealing $5M in COVID funds maintains innocence

Congresswoman Denies Allegations in $5M COVID Funds Scandal: The Truth Behind the Accusations

Outside a Miami federal courthouse on Monday, U.S. Representative Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick firmly…
Southern Command takes out another vessel

US Military Executes Precision Strike on Narco-Terrorists in Eastern Pacific: Vessel Neutralized

In a strategic operation on December 29, the U.S. Southern Command’s Joint…
Actress with crippling mental illness plans to die by assisted suicide

Acclaimed Actress with Severe Mental Health Challenges Seeks End-of-Life Assistance

Claire Brosseau, a celebrated actress and comedienne, has made the heart-wrenching decision…
Missing child found at Humboldt Park, Chicago home after disappearing more than 7 years ago; sibling, mother arrested

Juveniles Arrested Following Major Disruption at Louis Joliet Mall: Police Report

JOLIET, Ill. (WLS) — A chaotic scene unfolded at the Louis Joliet…