Ohio cold case solved after 30 years later as man convicted in 1995 double murder
Share and Follow


MARIETTA, OH (WTRF) An Ohio jury has convicted a man of murdering a woman and her young son nearly 30 years after the killings took place.

Scott Hickman, 53, was found guilty of four counts of aggravated murder and two counts of murder in the 1995 deaths of 28-year-old Kimberly Fulton and her 17-month-old son, Daniel.

The victims’ bodies were discovered on March 5, 1995, inside a burned mobile home in Palmer Township, a small town about 100 miles southeast of Columbus.

However, investigators later determined it wasn’t the fire that had killed them. Kimberly and Daniel didn’t have carbon monoxide in their lungs, the Parkersburg News and Sentinel reported, leading investigators to believe they had died before the fire was set.

The Ohio Attorney General’s office believed the fire was an attempt to cover up the murders.

Hickman was arrested in 1998 but ended up being released because there wasn’t enough evidence against him, according to the News and Sentinel.

The case went unsolved for decades until cold-case detectives with the Washington County Sheriff’s Office and the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation reopened the investigation in 2019. Hickman was indicted two years later in October 2021.

Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost credited investigators and prosecutors for their persistence in the case.

Hickman is scheduled to be sentenced on Oct. 14.

Another man, Johnny Ball of Marietta, was indicted last year on perjury and obstruction charges connected to the case. His trial is pending.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Chicago Christmas 2025: Hundreds of Christmas Day meals delivered to West Englewood shelter by St. Sabina Church volunteers

St. Sabina Church Volunteers Spread Holiday Cheer with Meal Deliveries to West Englewood Shelter on Christmas 2025

In a heartwarming gesture just in time for Christmas, hundreds of meals…
I was anxious and tired... I blamed my busy life but it was much worse

Uncovering the True Cause of My Anxiety and Fatigue Beyond a Hectic Lifestyle

In her early twenties, Rachel Christensen was navigating the typical whirlwind of…
Kentucky State University shooting suspect charged with murder is parent of a student

Kentucky University Shooting Case: Grand Jury’s Decision Sparks Controversy

A grand jury has decided not to indict a father charged with…
Who performed with Snoop Dogg during the Netflix Christmas halftime show?

Snoop Dogg’s Christmas Halftime Show Surprise: Special Guest Performer Revealed

Snoop Dogg’s halftime show on Netflix turned out to be a dazzling…
Santa Claus visits La Rabida Children's Hospital on Chicago's South Side on Christmas Day

Santa Claus Brings Holiday Cheer to La Rabida Children’s Hospital in Chicago on Christmas Day

CHICAGO (WLS) — On Christmas Day, La Rabida Children’s Hospital on Chicago’s…
Winner of $8.75 million lottery ticket sold at Jacksonville Beach store revealed

$22,000 Fantasy 5 Ticket Sold at Jacksonville Publix on Christmas Eve

While it wasn’t the Powerball, a lucky individual in Jacksonville scored a…
Trio of Palestinians arrested for allegedly torching Christmas tree at Catholic church in West Bank

West Bank Tensions Rise: Three Palestinians Arrested Over Alleged Arson Attack on Catholic Church Christmas Tree

Three individuals have been detained in connection with setting a Christmas tree…
Jamie Lynn Spears gifts 'accident-prone' daughter Maddie an ATV despite teen almost dying in crash

Jamie Lynn Spears Surprises Daughter Maddie with ATV, Stirring Up Memories of Past Incident

This holiday season, Jamie Lynn Spears stirred up some controversy with a…