Surgeon ex-husband accused in Ohio dentist slayings retains lawyer who won prior high-profile murder trial
Share and Follow

A surgeon, charged with the fatal shooting of his former spouse and her dentist husband in their Ohio residence, has enlisted a seasoned local defense attorney known for handling significant murder cases.

Michael McKee’s legal defense is now led by Diane Menashe, who steps in as he confronts four aggravated murder charges, each accompanied by firearm specifications, as revealed in court documents accessed by Fox News Digital. Menashe officially submitted her notice of representation on January 22.

Menashe, with a 27-year career in law, currently operates her own law firm, as detailed on the Menashe Law Group’s website.

She previously defended Dr. William Husel, an Ohio physician who was cleared of all 14 murder charges in 2022. Prosecutors had alleged he overprescribed painkillers at the Mount Carmel Health System in Columbus.

Booking photo for Michael McKee

A representative from the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office confirmed that McKee has been extradited and is currently detained in Columbus, Ohio. (Franklin County Ohio Sheriff)

During Husel’s trial, his defense team called one witness to the stand – a Georgia anesthesiologist who testified that Husel’s patients died from their medical conditions and not Husel’s actions.

He was acquitted on all charges in April 2022 after a jury deliberated for more than a week. 

McKee is accused of shooting and killing Spencer Tepe, 37, and Monique Tepe, 39, inside their Weinland Park home in Columbus between 2 a.m. and 5 a.m. on Dec. 30. McKee is Monique’s ex-husband.

Defense attorney Diane Menashe

Defense attorney Diane Menashe smiles during the William Husel murder trial in Columbus, Ohio on March 7, 2022.   (Doral Chenoweth/The Columbus Dispatch via USA Today)

Following a weekslong manhunt, McKee was arrested in Illinois on Jan. 10 and subsequently extradited to Ohio after awaiting his hearing two days later, where he remains in custody at the Franklin County Jail. 

A sheriff’s spokesperson previously said that McKee faces upgraded premeditated aggravated murder charges, with three of the counts including specifications alleging the use or display of an automatic firearm or silencer. The fourth charge alleges a firearm was displayed or brandished. 

Additionally, McKee is charged with one count of aggravated burglary.

Defense attorney Diane Menashe

Defense attorney Diane Menashe walks out of the courtroom after closing statements in the murder trial of former Mt. Carmel physician William Husel in Columbus, Ohio on April 11, 2022.   (Doral Chenoweth/The Columbus Dispatch via USA Today)

Authorities have previously revealed that investigators recovered firearms from McKee’s home, including one that is believed to have been used in the murders. 

“At this time, again, unfortunately, I’m unable to answer that question,” Columbus Police Chief Elaine Bryant told Fox News Digital when asked whether the gun was legally obtained. She said investigators were “still doing some investigation as it relates to this case.”

Spencer and Monique Tepe on vacation

Spencer and Monique Tepe were preparing to celebrate their five-year wedding anniversary. (Rob Misleh)

Charging documents reveal police linked McKee to a vehicle that was seen arriving in the Tepes’ neighborhood shortly before the murders and spotted departing after the alleged homicides. The car was then tracked to Rockford, Illinois, where police learned it belonged to McKee.

McKee is set to appear for an arraignment hearing in the Franklin County Common Pleas Court on Friday, Jan. 23. 

Court records show McKee and Monique were married for seven months after their wedding on Aug. 22, 2015, before they split up, with divorce documents revealing Monique claimed the two were “incompatible.”

McKee was in the process of completing his residency at Virginia Tech Carilion Clinic when the pair split. 

Rob Misleh, Spencer’s brother-in-law, told WSYX that the couple was preparing to celebrate their five-year wedding anniversary one month before they were killed.

Menashe did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Ex-Michigan coach Moore is joined by loyal wife for court appearance

Ex-Michigan Coach Moore Attends Court with Devoted Wife: Latest Updates on Legal Proceedings

On Thursday, Sherrone Moore, a former college football coach, made his first…
REAL reason the Beckhams hate 'childlike' Nicola Peltz

Unveiling Tensions: Why the Beckhams Reportedly Disapprove of ‘Childlike’ Nicola Peltz

Brooklyn Beckham has officially severed ties with his family, a move he…
Jealous Texas woman allegedly launches 25-pound gym weight at romantic rival in fitness center

Texas Gym Drama: Jealous Woman Allegedly Throws 25-Pound Weight at Romantic Rival

A woman consumed by jealousy found herself in handcuffs after allegedly hurling…
Yale hosts controversial speaker Trita Parsi accused of promoting Iranian regime interests

Yale Sparks Debate by Hosting Trita Parsi Amid Accusations of Promoting Iranian Regime Interests

As tensions in Iran continue to escalate, a planned event at Yale…
California ‘party mom’ accused of grooming victims for sex, drinking in ritzy mansion, teens testify at trial

California Socialite Allegedly Facilitated Underage Parties and Misconduct in Luxurious Mansion, Teen Witnesses Testify at Trial

A jury is currently hearing testimony from teenagers who describe their experiences…
Kids' influencer Ms. Rachel says she liked antisemitic post by mistake

Children’s Influencer Ms. Rachel Clarifies Unintentional Endorsement of Antisemitic Post

Popular children’s YouTube personality Ms. Rachel, known off-screen as Rachel Accurso, recently…
'Sinners' sets Oscars record with 16 nominations

Historic Oscars Milestone: ‘Sinners’ Breaks Records with 16 Unprecedented Nominations

Ryan Coogler’s film “Sinners,” a vampire saga infused with blues, topped the…
Chris Noth reveals what led to fallout with Sarah Jessica Parker

Chris Noth Breaks Silence: The Truth Behind His Rift with Sarah Jessica Parker

Chris Noth became a household name thanks to his role as Mr.…