Three children whose lives were upended after both parents died from carbon monoxide poisoning at a California property are suing the homeowners and the manufacturer of a gas-powered water heater.
John “Jay” Ruskey, 53, and his wife, Kristen, 49, were found dead in a guest bedroom at a home in the coastal town of Cambria on February 8.
In the hours leading up to their deaths, however, there had been a desperate emergency call, a frightening medical incident and, according to a lawsuit filed by their children, several missed opportunities to save the couple.
The Ruskeys, prominent figures in California’s specialty coffee industry, had traveled without their children to attend a birthday celebration with about 50 other people at the home of Ben and Robin Korman. They planned to spend the night in a guest bedroom.
Instead, the gathering ended with their three children losing both parents.
Their daughter Kasurina, who was 19 at the time, 16-year-old twin sons Aiden and Sean, and Brent Waldman, the children’s guardian, have filed suit against the homeowners and Navien Inc., which manufactured the property’s tankless gas water heater.
The lawsuit, filed October 26 in San Luis Obispo County Superior Court, alleges negligence and claims that a defective exhaust system allowed deadly carbon monoxide to enter the home while the couple slept.
According to the complaint, the water heater repeatedly switched on overnight to meet the hot-water demands of a house filled with guests.
The children of John and Kristen Ruskey, who died at a Cambria residence on February 8, have sued homeowners Ben and Robin Korman, alleging negligence at the property contributed to their parents’ deaths
Kasurina, 19, and 16-year-old twins Sean and Aiden allege that a failed venting system allowed carbon monoxide to enter the laundry room before spreading through a connecting doorway into the bedroom where Jay and Kristen were sleeping
The venting system allegedly malfunctioned, allowing carbon monoxide to fill the laundry room before it traveled through a connecting doorway into the bedroom where Jay and Kristen were sleeping.
The complaint also alleges that a combination smoke and carbon monoxide detector in the bedroom had been disconnected from its electrical wiring.
The homeowners should have known the alarm was not operational, the complaint claims, adding that no other carbon monoxide detector was installed near the bedroom or laundry room.
“No alarm ever sounded,” the lawsuit states. The most disturbing allegations, however, relate to the couple’s final hours.
At approximately 4:34am, about two and a half hours after they went to bed, Kristen called 911 because Jay was “in acute distress,” according to the lawsuit.
The complaint says he was screaming and vomiting, making seizure-like movements and losing control of his bowels while in bed. However, according to the Santa Barbara Independent, Kristen told arriving paramedics that Jay was “having a bad trip” after eating chocolate infused with psychedelic mushrooms.
He declined the medical treatment recommended by the paramedics and was not taken to hospital.
The lawsuit argues that these symptoms could have been warning signs of acute carbon monoxide poisoning.
The complaint names homeowners Ben and Robin Korman, pictured, and Navien Inc., maker of the home’s tankless gas water heater, as defendants. It alleges negligence, premises liability and product liability, claiming a defective or improperly functioning exhaust system allowed lethal carbon monoxide to enter the property
Despite the seriousness of Jay’s condition, the lawsuit claims that no one identified carbon monoxide poisoning as a possible cause.
No one allegedly tested the air, turned off the water heater or ventilated the property afterward.
Instead, the couple returned to bed. At about 10am, other guests checked on them and found Kristen unresponsive on the laundry room floor next to the bedroom. Jay was found in the bedroom, also “unresponsive, pulseless and not breathing.”
Guests performed CPR and called 911, but both victims were pronounced dead at the scene.
The San Luis Obispo County Coroner’s Office later determined that the deaths were caused by the toxic effects of carbon monoxide.
Autopsy and toxicology results confirmed carbon monoxide poisoning in both victims. Kristen’s death was also linked to the toxic effects of ethyl alcohol, with a blood alcohol level of 0.042.
The lawsuit also raises questions about carbon monoxide levels inside the property after the couple died.
Five days after the tragedy, the homeowners reportedly contacted a sheriff’s detective investigating the deaths and provided information indicating that carbon monoxide levels inside the home had been elevated.
John, who was often known as Jay, founded his exotic-fruit company Good Land Organics in 1992. Frinj Coffee was established in 2018 and became the first Californian coffee grower to compete in the Dubai Coffee Auction
According to the complaint, a deputy later examined the guest bedroom detector and confirmed that it was disconnected. There was no other carbon monoxide detector in the room.
The lawsuit accuses Navien of strict product liability and negligence, alleging that the water heater could release carbon monoxide into the building if its exhaust vent became detached or otherwise failed.
It further claims that the manufacturer had previously issued recalls related to venting problems.
The Kormans face allegations of premises liability and negligence for allegedly failing to ensure the property was safe and equipped with functioning carbon monoxide detectors.
The children are seeking monetary damages, saying they have lost not only their parents’ financial support but also a lifetime of love, guidance, protection and comfort.
Jay and Kristen’s sudden deaths devastated their friends, relatives and colleagues, who rallied around the three siblings afterward.
A fundraising campaign created to support the children raised approximately $195,500.
The defendants have not been found liable, and the allegations have not yet been tested in court.
Attorney David Shay said: “The deaths of Jay and Kristen Ruskey were a devastating and preventable tragedy that left three children without their parents.”
“Our focus remains on establishing the facts and pursuing accountability for this family,” Shay said.
The family is also using the case to highlight the dangers of carbon monoxide, an odorless, colorless gas produced by fuel-burning appliances that can kill without warning.
With colder weather approaching, the Ruskeys are urging households to install working carbon monoxide detectors, make sure they are properly connected and test them regularly.
The Daily Mail has contacted the Ruskeys’ attorneys and Robin Korman for comment.