NYC's No. 1 recidivist's rap sheet includes 134 arrests
Share and Follow

A notorious criminal known as “Recidivist No. 1” by Mayor Adams and considered a symbol of New York City’s flawed justice system continues to engage in criminal activities. The individual, Harold Gooding, has accumulated a staggering rap sheet with a total of 134 arrests, as reported by The Post.

Gooding gained notoriety when he appeared on the front page of The Post in August 2022 as the top person on the NYPD’s list of repeat offenders. At that time, he had only 101 arrests, indicating a pattern of repeated criminal behavior.

He’s been busted another 33 times in the 33 months since that report, records show.

A Manhattan police officer who has had dealings with Gooding, a 56-year-old repeat offender from Brooklyn and the Bronx, expressed frustration at the situation. The officer highlighted the cycle of Gooding being released either the same day or the next day, only to commit the same crimes repeatedly.

Most of the new arrests were for shoplifting from stores in Tribeca, but he’s also been collared for grand larceny and drug possession. His older arrests included armed robbery, grand larceny and burglary, the sources said.

He was slowed down a bit in June 2024 after he was arrested on grand larceny charges for shoplifting 11 different times, mostly at a Target store at 255 Greenwich St. in Tribeca, police sources said.

He pled guilty to petit larceny and was sentenced to 364 days in Rikers, police sources said. He was released in February.

And like clockwork, he’s been arrested four more times since.

The month after he got out of Rikers, he went to the Duane Reade on Broadway in Tribeca on March 28 around 10:30 a.m. and pilfered 30 bottles of vitamins worth $1,511.18, according to a criminal complaint filed with the Manhattan DA’s Office. 

A month later, on April 24, he went into the same store and stole cleaning supplies and three pairs of reading glasses, the records show. He was charged with grand larceny, criminal possession of stolen property, two counts of petit larceny, according to the complaint.

But in two days he was out again. The charges weren’t bail eligible. The state’s 2019 no-bail laws essentially made many lower level crimes like shoplifting penalty-free.

Four days later, on April 30, he was busted in Central Park with a crack pipe, three vials of crack, and five heroin strips in his backpack, police sources said.

The police source who knows Gooding said he’s got addiction problems — but that it shouldn’t give him a get-out-of-jail-free card.

“He has a drug problem that he has to feed,” the police source said. “It’s sad that he has to live that way but it doesn’t give him the right to commit crimes. We do our jobs arresting him and taking him in and the courts let him go.”

In the latest arrest he was given only a desk appearance ticket, and he is supposed to return to court on Monday.

“He’s not going to show up,” another police source said. “He’s going to get a [arrest] warrant and the whole process is going to repeat itself.”

Gooding has served three prison stints, starting with a one- to three-year sentence for an attempted-burglary conviction in Brooklyn in 1994, according to state records.

Using the name Jamiel White, he was sent upstate again in 1996 for an attempted-robbery conviction in Brooklyn, according to the state Department of Corrections and Community Supervision.

His most serious conviction, for first-degree robbery in Brooklyn, landed him a 10-year sentence in 2001. He was paroled in 2008, records show.

“It’s probably worth the squeeze for him,” said retired NYPD detective and John Jay College adjunct professor Michael Alcazar. “In an underground economy . . . for them, it’s worth the gamble. The police can only do so much. That’s their livelihood.” 

Just before he landed on the cover of the Post he was nabbed in a string of 2022 robberies, shoplifting from a Tribeca Target nearly half a dozen times, always wearing the the same distinctive white bucket hat, officials said. He was released without bail each time.

At one point, Gooding posted a glam photo on Facebook of himself wearing a baseball cap and added a sparkle effect. 

“Apparently he hasn’t learned his lesson nor will he,” said Joseph Giacolone,  retired NYPD sergeant and adjunct professor at Penn State University-Lehigh Valley.

“We’re living in a time we’re nobody on the City Council’s going to say this guy needs to go to jail . . . the City Council is trying to get rid of Rikers, and quite frankly, trying to abolish police. Trying to talk sense to them is futile.”

Gooding’s mother, Delores Stroy, 72, appeared surprised to learn her son was at the top of the NYPD’s “Worst of the Worst” list back in 2022.

“Not my Harold,” she said.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Cops swarm home of Jill Biden's ex amid probe into his wife's death

Authorities Investigate Home of Jill Biden’s Ex-Husband Following Wife’s Death

The distraught daughter of the woman who married Jill Biden’s former husband…
Mamdani fans disappointed by disastrous 'block party' inauguration with no food, bathrooms

Mamdani’s Inaugural Block Party Blunder: No Food, No Bathrooms, Just Frustration

The anticipated “block party” proved to be a disappointment for many. Supporters…
Woman in Florida Barnes & Noble stabbed to death, police seek motive

Homeless Drifter Claims ‘Fight or Flight’ Response in Fatal Barnes & Noble Christmas Shopper Incident

Authorities revealed Tuesday that the individual accused of the tragic stabbing of…
Anti-Iran regime protests grow across country as Trump admin boosts demonstrators offering support

Nationwide Protests Against Iranian Regime Gain Momentum Amid Stronger US Support

Protests erupted throughout Iran on Tuesday, coinciding with President Donald Trump and…
New Year's around the world: Cities across the globe welcome 2026 with thunderous fireworks and heightened security

Global New Year 2026: Cities Light Up the Sky with Dazzling Fireworks Amid Tightened Security

In Auckland, as the clock struck midnight, New Zealanders welcomed the new…
'See you in court': Muslim civil rights group responds to terrorist designation by Florida governor

Florida Tops U.S. Execution Charts in 2025: Unveiling the Reasons Behind the Record-Breaking Trend

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — As 2023 draws to a close, Florida has…
Ellen DeGeneres sparks concern with weight loss after jetting to US

Ellen DeGeneres’ Noticeable Weight Loss Raises Concerns Following Return to the US

On Tuesday, Ellen DeGeneres caught the public’s attention as she made her…
'At least ten killed' as explosion rips through bar in Switzerland

Tragic Explosion in Swiss Bar Claims at Least Ten Lives

At least 10 people have lost their lives and another 10 have…