Chicago Police Department applicant's interview leads to arrests in 2016 kidnapping, rape investigation, prosecutors say
Share and Follow

CHICAGO (WLS) — Stephon Arnold walked into a Chicago Police Department station last October looking for a job, but prosecutors said details he revealed during his interview led them to uncovering he and his brother were connected to a nearly decade-old kidnapping and rape investigation.

Arnold, 30, and his brother, Sherrow Harris, 35, were both arrested and charged on Friday with aggravated kidnapping and aggravated criminal sexual assault after investigators said they violently assaulted two 18-year-old women back in 2016, the ABC7 I-Team has learned.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

That investigation had been suspended until late last year when Arnold “applied to the Chicago Police Department and consented to a polygraph,” prosecutors revealed during a Friday hearing for the accused brothers.

“On that polygraph form, [Arnold] made admissions regarding this incident,” prosecutors said. “The details provided by [defendant] Arnold… allowed detectives to cross reference the facts and locate the original case incident report from 2016.”

According to police and court records reviewed by the I-Team, the night of Sept. 10, 2016, started as a sneaker shopping expedition at the Woodfield Mall in Schaumburg for the two young women, along with Harris and his cousin, who has since died.

Both women would later tell investigators the men took them to the mall to find “new Jordan 12 shoes” but when the store at the mall did not have their sizes, Harris and his cousin told the women they should go back to their apartment. There, they would meet someone the men knew who had the shoes in their sizes for sale, according to the police report.

Both men and women went to a south side apartment near 72nd and South Aberdeen, where prosecutors said Arnold was waiting to rob the women of their jewelry at gunpoint, and then force them into having sex with Harris and the brothers’ cousin.

Police records state both women went to the hospital the next day for injuries they suffered. Chicago police were called, took a report, noting where the victims alleged the crime occurred, but the investigation was ultimately suspended, according to prosecutors.

The investigation would have remained suspended if it wasn’t for Arnold applying for a job at the Chicago police department this past October.

After detectives began to look into the statements Arnold made in his application’s polygraph statement, prosecutors said the investigators found Arnold and Harris had both been previously arrested by Chicago police, and during those arrests, they listed the apartment near 72nd and Aberdeen as their home address.

Nearly nine years after the crime took place, prosecutors said in court on Friday that both victims identified Harris and his cousin in a photo lineup this past week.

Investigators believe the armed robbery by Arnold that took place at the brothers’ apartment was “a ruse.”

After reading Arnold his Miranda rights, prosecutors said he made statements to investigators “regarding the armed robbery being a ruse so that the other two [Harris and their cousin] could have sex with the victims.”

Arnold and Harris are currently being held in jail, according to the Cook County Sheriff’s Department.

The brothers have been appointed public defenders, but according to the court docket, they have yet to enter a plea to the charges they face.

A spokesperson for the Chicago police department would not comment on this specific case, but said background checks are critical when interviewing potential employees.

“While we will not comment on specific individuals, the Chicago police department conducts a thorough pre-employment background investigation process, including a polygraph examination,” a spokesperson told the I-Team. “The polygraph examination is an important component of the background process to determine an applicant’s eligibility for hire.”

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Andy Reid's wife lifts the lid on Christmas plans and Chiefs' season

Andy Reid’s Wife Reveals Exclusive Insights on Christmas Plans and Kansas City Chiefs’ Season

Amid a challenging NFL season for the Kansas City Chiefs, holiday cheer…
Late billionaire tax cheat Robert Brockman’s heirs agree to pay $750M to IRS in epic fraud case

Epic Tax Fraud Unveiled: Late Billionaire Robert Brockman’s Heirs Settle $750M with IRS

Robert Brockman, a billionaire and software mogul, orchestrated a colossal tax evasion…
Full story of Nickelodeon star Tylor Chase's fall to homelessness

From Stardom to Struggle: The Untold Journey of Nickelodeon Star Tylor Chase’s Descent into Homelessness

Tylor Chase, who captured hearts as a teenage actor in a popular…
Isis Ogunti ID'd as woman killed in Chicago shooting, car crash on 103rd Street; family offering $12K reward for arrest

Isis Ogunti Identified as Victim in Chicago Shooting and Car Crash on 103rd Street; Family Offers $12K Reward for Information Leading to Arrest

A Chicago family is reaching out to the public with a $12,000…
Jaguars punter Logan Cooke named AFC Special Teams Player of the Week

Jaguars’ Logan Cooke Honored as AFC Special Teams Player of the Week

Logan Cooke’s impressive 52.0 average on punts in Week 16 was the…
Emma Heming Willis dismisses 'loud' opinions about caregiving experience

Emma Heming Willis Shares Heartfelt Insights on Holiday Changes Following Bruce Willis’ Dementia Diagnosis

She crafted the blog to resonate with individuals navigating the season while…
Pope Leo XIV says he’s ‘very disappointed’ after Illinois approves assisted suicide law

Pope Leo XIV Expresses Profound Disappointment Following Illinois’ Passage of Assisted Suicide Legislation

Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker meets with Pope Leo XIV Governor Jay Robert…
Kevin Niemiec, Zachary Mascolo, Jon Clary II accused of sexually assaulting female classmate at Roselle St. Viator HS party

Three Roselle St. Viator High School Students Charged in Sexual Assault Case at Off-Campus Party

In Roselle, Illinois, three teenagers face accusations of sexually assaulting a fellow…