Retired FBI Negotiator Reveals Bizarre Demand in Guthrie Note

According to a retired FBI negotiator, the latest developments concerning the alleged first ransom note in the Nancy Guthrie case raise doubts about its authenticity as a legitimate ransom demand. The details appear misaligned with typical kidnapping scenarios.

“The swift request to end communication suggests an ulterior motive that diverges from a genuine ransom demand,” explained Jason Pack, a former supervisory agent with the FBI. “It’s not consistent with the usual dynamics of a kidnapping.”

Pack elaborated that authentic kidnappers typically strive to maintain open lines of communication. This strategy facilitates negotiation for ransom payments and preserves leverage over the victim’s family. Therefore, the reported call to cease contact comes across as highly unorthodox.

Pack emphasized, “The demand for no further negotiations stands out as a red flag. Real kidnappers aim to keep communication flowing to better negotiate terms.”

The sender did, however, incorporate known pressure tactics, including setting a deadline, making threats and telling the family that Guthrie knew what would happen if they failed to comply, Pack said.

But cutting off communication before the deadlines passed was also unusual, he added.

Guthrie was taken from her home in Tucson’s Catalina Foothills neighborhood in the early morning hours of Feb. 1, according to the Pima County Sheriff’s Department and the FBI. She has not been seen since, and no proof of life was ever provided.

In a second purported ransom note, the sender indicated Guthrie had died soon after she was taken and been buried “with nature.”

New excerpts from what is reportedly the first note received by local media shed light on why Pack believes the communication departed from a traditional ransom demand.

Briana Whitney, who was working for the Phoenix-based AZ Family news outlet when the case broke, joined “Crime Junkie” host Ashley Flowers on Wednesday to discuss the note her former outlet received. “Crime Junkie” declined to share copies of the text.

“Hello Savannah, we have your mother Nancy,” she began, reading from what she said was the first note sent to local media. “She is safe but scared. She will be held for ransom, and once payment is received, she will be released unharmed. We will be holding her for a maximum of seven days.”

As previously conveyed by authorities, the sender gave two deadlines with increased money demands the longer it took.

“Once payment is received to the Bitcoin address below, she will be released within 12 hours of deposit to a safe drop-off location back in Tucson,” Whitney read. “If the payment is not received by the last deadline on Monday the 9th at 5 p.m., she will be killed. Your mother is aware of this, and her life is in your hands.”

The sender left no room for further dialogue.

“It is in the best interest of everyone to have this completed as soon as possible,” the note reportedly continued. “You will not be able to contact me from here on out. There will be no negotiation. Do not play games. Law enforcement will not be able to help you.”

The note also included details that may have only been available to investigators and the suspect at the time, including the location of Guthrie’s Apple Watch and details about the smashed floodlight in her backyard — but even that is not enough to pin down kidnapping for ransom as a motive, Pack said.

“The details about the security camera and the spotlight that was out, that proves that they know what the home was like, what the environment may have been like, but it’s not a real proof of life,” he said.

In most ransom kidnappings, he said, the abductors will want to prove they have possession of the victim and that the victim is alive.

“All these things put together don’t seem really like they go with the kidnapping for ransom,” he said.

Investigators appear to be split on the notes’ authenticity. While one person has already pleaded guilty to sending an impostor ransom note to Guthrie’s other daughter, Annie, and her husband Tommaso Cioni, that case is not believed to be connected to the notes sent to local media stations.

“The FBI and its task force partners have received several ransom notes over the course of this investigation,” the FBI’s Phoenix office said in a statement in June. “Some have been deemed to be extortion attempts without legitimacy. Other ransom demands may potentially be legitimate and are still being investigated as such. This case continues to be investigated as a kidnapping for ransom case. The FBI has and will continue to offer all assistance possible in the investigation — however local authorities remain the lead.”

Some investigators said they were confident that the ransom demands are all bogus, while others are cautious about reaching that conclusion while Guthrie’s whereabouts remain unknown, federal law enforcement sources told Fox News and News Media. Still, the two notes that Whitney mentioned have been deemed potentially authentic by investigators and by the Guthrie family.

The only known suspect remains publicly unidentified — a masked intruder who appeared on Nest doorbell camera video that the FBI recovered with help from Google.

He is described as standing between 5 feet, 9 inches and 5 feet, 10 inches tall with an average build. He was wearing a black Ozark Trail backpack. It remains unclear whether he acted alone.

The sum of rewards in the case is over $1.2 million.

Anyone with information is asked to dial 1-800-CALL-FBI. Tips can also be submitted anonymously to Tucson’s Crime Stoppers affiliate at 520-88-CRIME.