A South Carolina woman accused of stabbing a Lyft driver 11 times and then stealing his vehicle will remain behind bars after a judge denied her bond Friday, despite her attorney’s argument that she was in the midst of a serious mental health crisis at the time of the alleged attack.
Naziyha Weatherall is charged in Greenville County with attempted murder, carjacking and possession of a weapon during a violent crime. Court records show the case is tied to an alleged incident on April 22.
During Friday’s bond hearing, prosecutors described the accusations as a “frightening factual scenario,” according to FOX Carolina, and urged the court to consider Weatherall an extreme threat to public safety.
“The victim was simply just trying to do his job and was stabbed 11 times,” a solicitor said, according to FOX Carolina. “Not only was he stabbed 11 times, his car was then carjacked by this defendant.”
Naziyha Weatherall faces charges of attempted murder, carjacking and possession of a weapon during a violent crime in Greenville County. (Greenville County Sheriff’s Office)
The driver’s wife appeared in court on his behalf, saying the trauma of the alleged attack prevented him from attending.
“What concerns us most is that happened while my husband was simply working,” she said. “He was not looking for any confrontation, he was providing a service to a person. If this level of violence could happen to someone who was simply doing his job, we are concerned about potential risks to other people in our community.”
Weatherall’s lawyer urged the court to view the allegations through the lens of her mental state, saying she had never previously been charged with a crime and was in the throes of a psychiatric emergency.
Naziyha Weatherall faces charges of attempted murder, carjacking and possession of a weapon during a violent crime in Greenville County, in which she is accused of stabbing a Lyft driver 11 times. (iStock)
The defense said paranoia had convinced Weatherall that others were monitoring her and trying to harm her, prompting her to summon a ride to report her fears to police.
“Her mother even called the police station to let them know she was on the way to make a report,” the attorney said. “During that, the crisis got worse.”
The attorney said Weatherall believed she was being trafficked, panicked during the ride and had been diagnosed with schizophrenia and other mental health conditions.
Greenville, South Carolina, is pictured beside a booking photo of Naziyha Weatherall. (Getty ; Greenville County Sheriff’s Office)
The defense said Weatherall is now medicated, stable and competent, and asked the court to release her so relatives and a social worker could arrange placement at a treatment facility.
Weatherall’s mother apologized to the driver’s family while asking the court to consider her daughter’s mental state.
“She’s not a criminal. She would never, ever, ever hurt anybody like that,” her mother said. “And I understand the family’s side, I truly do, because we are all suffering. We all are.”
Naziyha Weatherall was denied bond. (iStock)
A judge ordered competency and observation evaluations in June, court records show. On Friday, the judge denied Weatherall’s bond request and ordered that she remain jailed pending a psychological evaluation scheduled for September.
Lyft told News Media it permanently removed the rider accounts involved from its platform and has continued assisting law enforcement.
“Violence like this has no place in the Lyft community or in our society,” a Lyft spokesperson said. “The driver’s well-being has been our priority, and we have reached out to them and their family to offer support.”
News Media has reached out to Weatherall’s attorney for comment.