Man awarded $50 million after Starbucks hot tea causes permanent disfigurement
Share and Follow

A California delivery driver was awarded $50 million in damages after a jury agreed a Starbucks location was negligent in its handling of a scalding hot tea.

Michael Garcia sued the cafe chain after a tea spilled in his lap at a drive-thru and caused permanent disfigurement to his penis. His attorney Nick Rowley said in a press release that Garcia’s “life has been forever changed” by the accident.

A Starbucks barista passes three coffee cups in a drink carrier through a drive through window to Michael Garcia who is seated in the front seat of his car
Moments before an unsecured cup fell onto the lap of Michael Garcia at a Starbucks drive-thru in Los Angeles on Feb. 8, 2020.Trial Lawyers for Justice

“No amount of money can undo the permanent catastrophic harm he has suffered, but this jury verdict is a critical step in holding Starbucks accountable for flagrant disregard for customer safety and failure to accept responsibility,” Rowley said.

Starbucks said it plans to appeal, adding that it has “always been committed to the highest safety standards in our stores.”

“We sympathize with Mr. Garcia, but we disagree with the jury’s decision that we were at fault for this incident and believe the damages awarded to be excessive,” Starbucks said in a statement.

Garcia was working as a Postmates delivery driver on Feb. 8, 2020, when he arrived at the Los Angeles Starbucks to pick up three venti “medicine ball” teas, according to his attorneys. He was handed a cardboard carrier with the drinks at the drive-thru when a cup fell directly into his lap and the top popped off one of the drinks.

Video provided by Rowley’s firm shows the Starbucks employees preparing the drinks and the moment the tea spills into Garcia’s lap. Garcia’s attorneys argued in court that the employee at the window failed to properly secure that drink in the carrier.

Garcia suffered third-degree burns to his penis, groin and inner thighs.

Rowley’s firm said Garcia had two skin grafts to his penis at Grossman Burn Center and that any friction to the area causes Garcia pain.

The court case is reminiscent of the infamous McDonald’s coffee lawsuit. In 1992, 79-year-old Stella Liebeck suffered third-degree burns after a McDonald’s coffee spilled in her lap at a drive-thru in New Mexico.

Liebeck’s case is sometimes criticized as a frivolous lawsuit, but evidence at trial showed that McDonald’s coffee was significantly hotter than that of other restaurants. According to the American Museum of Tort Law, at least 700 other people had been burned before by McDonald’s coffee, yet the company hadn’t changed it’s policy of keeping its coffee between 180 and 190 degrees.

The 79-year-old initially asked McDonald’s to pay her medical bills and only filed suit after the company refused, according to the Journal of Consumer & Commercial Law.

She was initially awarded $2.7 million in punitive damages but a judge reduced the jury’s verdict. Liebeck and McDonald’s settled for an undisclosed amount.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Missing Camila Mendoz Olmos: Dashcam captures last sighting of Texas teen who vanished Christmas Eve

Texas Teen Camila Mendoza Olmos: Dashcam Footage Reveals Final Moments Before Christmas Eve Disappearance

FBI joins search for missing Texas 19-year-old The aunt and cousin of…
Harvard professor says white men get rejected in favor of minorities

Harvard Professor Highlights Challenges White Men Face in Diverse Hiring Practices

A prominent Harvard historian has announced his departure from the prestigious university…
ISIS exploiting Syria’s chaos as US strikes expose growing threat

ISIS Seizes Opportunity Amid Syrian Turmoil as US Airstrikes Highlight Rising Danger

In a significant development, U.S. and allied forces have successfully neutralized nearly…
Things to do on New Year's Eve: Chicago-area residents prepare to celebrate end of 2025 with big events, parties, at home

Unforgettable New Year’s Eve 2025: Chicago’s Top Events, Parties, and Home Celebrations

CHICAGO – As the year draws to a close, people across the…
After legal setbacks, President Donald Trump says he's dropping push for National Guard in Chicago, LA, Portland, Oregon, for now

Trump Halts National Guard Plans for Chicago, LA, and Portland Following Legal Challenges

CHICAGO — President Donald Trump has announced a temporary halt to his…
President Trump issues first vetoes since returning to the White House

President Trump Wields First Vetoes of New Term Following White House Return

In a rare move, President Donald Trump has exercised his veto power,…
Arlington Heights couple says free smoke detector installed by fire department helped save their lives during kitchen blaze

Arlington Heights Couple Credits Fire Department’s Free Smoke Detector with Life-Saving Role in Kitchen Fire

In Arlington Heights, Illinois, a couple is sharing their story, highlighting a…
Body found during search for missing Texas teen Camila Mendoza Olmos as another teen girl disappears

Remains Discovered Amid Search for Missing Texas Teen Camila Mendoza Olmos; New Case Emerges with Another Teen’s Disappearance

On Tuesday evening, a body was discovered in Bexar County, Texas, as…