Bipartisan support picks up for a natural disaster review board
Share and Follow

As Texans seek answers about the Hill Country floods, some top meteorologists and policymakers are calling for the creation of a disaster review board modeled after the National Transportation Safety Board, which investigates all civil aviation accidents and major transportation incidents.

The idea of a nonpartisan, independent board to review weather-related disasters is nothing new, but it appears to be gaining fresh traction after the flooding in Texas left more than 120 people dead and another 170 missing.

During his Senate confirmation hearing Wednesday to lead the National Oceanic and Atmospheric ministration (NOAA), Neil Jacobs endorsed the idea when Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, asked what he would do to ensure that Americans can better respond to emergency weather warnings.

“We also need more data and doing post-storm assessments,” Jacobs said. “One of the things that I’ve envisioned, because I’ve worked on several aviation accidents with NTSB, is something along the lines of what they do but for weather disasters because we need the data to understand what went right, what went wrong, whether people got the warnings.”

NOAA Presents The 2019 Atlantic Hurricane Season Outlook
Neil Jacobs in 2019.Win McNamee / Getty Images file

Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have taken this torch up before.

Sens. Brian Schatz, D-Hawaii, and Bill Cassidy, R-La., have introduced several bills since 2020 that would create a Natural Disaster Safety Board modeled after the NTSB. Rep. Katie Porter, D-Calif., and several GOP colleagues have introduced companion bills in the House.

In 2022, the House approved legislation that included a measure to create a Natural Disaster Safety Board, but it died in the Senate.

The bills would have created an independent, seven-member board with subpoena power to perform fact-finding and identify the underlying causes of disasters’ impact without assigning blame.

Cassidy and Schatz did not immediately respond to a request for comment on whether they think there’s renewed momentum on Capitol Hill for creating a disaster review panel. Porter is no longer a member of Congress.

In an email to NBC News, Congress’ only meteorologist, Rep. Eric Sorensen, D-Ill., said he was working with colleagues to create an NTSB-styled program to investigate deadly storms.

Rescue And Clean-up Efforts Continue In Katrina's Wake
A flooded home in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina in 2005.Michael Appleton / NY Daily News / Getty Images file

“It would be amazing if meteorologists could have access to investigative reports that help us to figure out what — if anything — went wrong and what we can do in the future to be better,” Sorensen said, adding that “clearly the tragic floods in Texas would benefit from such a report.”

Sorensen’s state was also hit with a powerful deluge this week, with about 5 inches of rain falling in 90 minutes over Garfield Park, on Chicago’s west side, prompting multiple rescues.

The Chicago and Texas floods were two of four extreme rainfall events in less than a week that researchers would expect once every thousand years.

In meteorology and disaster management circles, the concept of an independent board to review disasters has percolated for years. Mike Smith, a meteorologist and former senior vice president at Accuweather, has been pushing the idea since Hurricane Sandy in 2012.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Meet the 'Most Powerful Woman in Sports' Gayle Benson

Unveiling Gayle Benson: The Trailblazing Force Redefining Power in Sports

In a Baton Rouge YMCA, just days before Christmas, Gayle Benson stands…
US military reveals the unlikely reason it started tracking Santa

US Military’s Whimsical Tradition: The Unlikely Origins of Tracking Santa Claus

Seventy years ago, a child’s phone call inadvertently laid the groundwork for…
As MTV is axed... a look back at its best viral moments

Farewell MTV: Unforgettable Viral Moments That Shaped Pop Culture History

MTV’s launch on August 1, 1981, marked a pivotal moment in pop…
NORAD continues decades-long tradition of tracking Santa's trip around the world

NORAD Keeps Holiday Magic Alive by Tracking Santa’s Global Journey

In the lead-up to Christmas, the excitement surrounding Santa Claus reaches a…
California farming tycoon arrested in wife's killing

Prominent California Agribusiness Magnate Detained in Shocking Wife Murder Case

A California agricultural magnate was taken into custody on Tuesday, accused of…
Doctors blamed my baby's issues on weight... he had a brain disease

Doctors Initially Attributed My Baby’s Symptoms to Weight, Later Diagnosed Brain Disease

A mother from Kentucky alleges that medical professionals brushed off her infant’s…
North Korea releases images of development of nuclear-powered submarine

North Korea Unveils First Glimpse of Nuclear-Powered Submarine Development: Global Tensions Rise

North Korea has unveiled what seems to be significant advancements in its…
Retirement accounts roared back in 2025 after punishing losses during Biden years: study

Study Reveals Significant Recovery in Retirement Accounts Post-Biden Era Losses

After enduring four challenging years of inflation and declining bond markets that…