Supreme Court to hear rare May arguments in birthright citizenship battle
Share and Follow


The Supreme Court scheduled a rare May oral argument on the Trump administration’s emergency request to narrow a series of nationwide blocks on President Trump’s executive order that would restrict birthright citizenship.

The administration has not yet asked the justices to settle the constitutionality of Trump’s order but has asked the high court to rein in lower judges that went beyond the parties who sued to block the president’s order nationwide.

Thursday’s order defers a ruling on the applications until after the newly scheduled oral arguments May 15, meaning Trump’s plan will remain blocked, for now.

The development is rare in multiple respects. The justices typically only hear oral arguments between October and April, and the vast majority of emergency applications are resolved without the justices holding an argument. 

Signed on his first day in office, Trump’s order would curb birthright citizenship for children born on U.S. soil to parents without permanent legal status, a sweeping restriction that multiple judges have found is inconsistent with the Supreme Court’s long-standing interpretation of the 14th Amendment’s Citizenship Clause.

The administration appealed nationwide injunctions issued by federal judges in Greenbelt, Md., Seattle and Boston, all of which were upheld by appeals courts. Trump’s order has come under nearly a dozen lawsuits in total, including some challenges that have not yet reached the justices. 

The request is part of a series of emergency applications the administration has filed at the Supreme Court urging the justices to stop a smattering of nationwide injunctions, insisting district judges are overstepping their authority and improperly stymying Trump’s agenda.

The Justice Department is asking the justices to limit the injunctions to only block Trump’s policy blocked as applied to the individuals, organizations and 22 Democratic-led states that are suing.

New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin (D), who is co-leading one of the lawsuits, said he looks forward to the Supreme Court arguments and called Trump’s order “blatantly unconstitutional.”

“Birthright citizenship was enshrined in the Constitution in the wake of the Civil War, is backed by a long line of Supreme Court precedent and ensures that something as fundamental as American citizenship cannot be turned on or off at the whims of a single man,” Platkin said in a statement.

Updated at 3:32 p.m. EDT

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Teens' viral prank targeting homeowners could have deadly consequences, police warn

Police Warn of Potentially Lethal Outcomes from Teenagers’ Viral Prank Targeting Homeowners

Kansas officials are alerting both parents and homeowners about a “dangerous new…
Tommy Lee Jones breaks silence on daughter Victoria's death at 34

Tommy Lee Jones Addresses the Tragic Passing of His Daughter Victoria at Age 34

In a heartbreaking revelation, the family of Tommy Lee Jones has spoken…
Runner fought off mountain lion with stick just weeks before fatal attack on same Colorado trail

Runner Successfully Defended Against Mountain Lion with Stick Weeks Prior to Fatal Attack on Colorado Trail

Just weeks before a tragic incident involving a hiker and a suspected…
FILE - The General Store is seen Oct. 24, 2006, in Glen Haven, Colo. (AP Photo/The Denver Post, Karl Gehring, File)

Colorado Faces Another Tragic Mountain Lion Attack: The Ongoing Threat to Public Safety

Authorities suspect a solo hiker, who tragically perished on New Year’s Day…
Woman killed in suspected mountain lion attack while hiking in northern Colorado

Hiker Fatally Attacked in Suspected Mountain Lion Incident in Northern Colorado

In a tragic incident in northern Colorado, a woman lost her life…
Austin Silverman charged with attempted murder of Woodstock Shell gas station clerk after being denied job application: Officials

Shocking Turn of Events: Austin Silverman Faces Attempted Murder Charges After Job Application Rejection at Woodstock Gas Station

A resident of Woodstock, Illinois, has been accused of attempted murder following…
911 call reveals possible cause of death for Tommy Lee Jones daughter

911 Call Sheds Light on Tragic Passing of Tommy Lee Jones’ Daughter

Tragedy struck the family of Tommy Lee Jones as his late daughter,…
Feud over disabled younger son ended in three murders and a suicide

Tragic Family Rift: Dispute Over Disabled Son Leads to Triple Homicide and Suicide

A long-standing and intense family dispute over the custody of a disabled…