Texas jury returns verdict in 2022 stabbing death of high school classmate: report
Share and Follow

A jury has decided the fate of a Texas teen who was charged with allegedly stabbing his high school classmate to death in a bathroom in 2022, finding him not guilty of murder and guilty of criminally negligent homicide.

After being unable to reach a verdict on Monday and tabling court till Tuesday, KWTX reported that a Bell County jury announced that they did not find Caysen Allison guilty of murder in the stabbing death of Joe Ramirez Jr. at Belton High School in May 2022. 

The jury found Allison guilty of criminally negligent homicide.

Allison was released under the conditions of his bond, the outlet reported, which will remain in place until his sentencing hearing on June 16, where he faces anywhere from six months to two years in a state prison, in addition to a possible fine of up to $10,000.

Mugshot of Caysen Tyler Allison

Caysen Allison found not guilty of murder, but guilty of a lesser charge, in the 2022 death of classmate Joe Ramirez (Belton Police Department)

Bittle also claimed he tried to step in once Ramirez punched Allison, but was hit by one of the other teens in the group, which cell phone video of the fight showed. 

Allison’s defense argued he acted in self-defense in a “fight for his life” after he was attacked by Ramirez in the school’s bathroom.

Officers went to Allison’s home following the fight after he fled the scene, where officers overheard him speaking to someone on the phone saying “I did something at school,” and asking them to come and take him to Waco.

Detectives also snapped photos of Allison’s white shoes being covered in blood as he told investigators what kind of knife he used to kill Ramirez and where he had dumped the weapon.

Madison Barnes, Ramirez’s ex-girlfriend and a close friend of Allison’s, testified that Allison made threats against Ramirez to her before the stabbing, according to KWTX. She also told the jury that Allison warned her that he “wanted Joe on life support, wanted to stomp his head in, wanted his jaw dangling from his face, and wanted him in the hospital.”

Ramirez Jr., a senior at the school, was described on a GoFundMe page raising money for his family as a “very kind, loving and gentle young man.”

Allison’s defense attorney, Zachary Boyd, told KWTX that he was happy with the jury’s decision in a very challenging case.

“The Allison family is so sorry for their loss, cause there is no good outcome to this. There is no happy ending in terms of everyone’s going to leave here feeling happy,” Boyd said.

“The world is not black and white. The world is shades of gray and, ultimately, we were left with the question of what do you do when the issue is one of bullying or one of a child who is so scared that he brings a knife to school to defend himself with?”

Nearly three years later, another Texas teen was violently killed while attending a high school track meet.

Karmelo Anthony, the 17-year-old accused of stabbing Frisco, Texas track star Austin Metcalf to death, was released from jail after his bond was dropped from $1 million to $250,000.

Like Allison, Anthony’s bond conditions include house arrest and an ankle monitor, and he will only be able to leave his home with the judge’s permission.

If convicted, Anthony cannot face the death penalty because he is a juvenile, thanks to a 2005 Supreme Court ruling in a case called Roper v. Simmons.

Fox News Digital reached out to Allison’s attorney for comment, but did not immediately receive a response. 

Fox News Digital’s Lorraine Taylor and Peter D’Abrosca contributed to this report. 

Stepheny Price is a writer for Fox News Digital and Fox Business. She covers topics including missing persons, homicides, national crime cases, illegal immigration, and more. Story tips and ideas can be sent to stepheny.price@fox.com

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Ohio dentist murders gun match a ‘big problem’ for surgeon ex: Defense attorney

Ohio Dentist Murder Case: Gun Evidence Poses Major Challenge for Surgeon Ex, Says Defense Attorney

A gun found on Michael McKee’s Illinois property has been preliminarily linked…
Illegal alien with 24 convictions among ‘worst of the worst’ arrested in Minnesota ICE operation: DHS

High-Risk Illegal Immigrant with 24 Convictions Captured in Minnesota ICE Sweep: DHS Labels as ‘Worst of the Worst

EXCLUSIVE TO FOX: In a significant development, the Department of Homeland Security…
Urgent questions Timothy Busfield's wife Melissa Gilbert must answer

Melissa Gilbert Faces Pressing Questions About Her Life with Timothy Busfield

He insists on his innocence. Actor and director Timothy Busfield, 68, has…
Online game threat prompts security increase at Putnam County schools Friday

Heightened Security Measures Implemented at Putnam County Schools Following Online Gaming Threat

An online gaming clash escalated into a cross-state school threat alert, prompting…
Marion County teen arrested for AI-generated child sexual abuse materials, police say

Marion County Teen Arrested for Creating AI-Generated Child Exploitation Content, Authorities Report

The Marion County Sheriff’s Office has revealed that a teenager was involved…
FILE - President Donald Trump gestures to a chart as he speaks at Mount Airy Casino Resort, Dec. 9, 2025, in Mount Pocono, Pa. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File)

New Poll Reveals Insights on Trump Supporters’ Satisfaction in His Second Term: Are Expectations Being Met?

NEW YORK (AP) — As President Donald Trump approaches the end of…
Affluent Virginia suburb rocked as trial begins for ex-federal agent husband in nanny love-triangle murders

Virginia Nanny Moves into Master Bedroom Amidst Shocking Love Triangle Murder Case: New Photos Uncovered

WARNING: GRAPHIC CONTENT The courtroom in Virginia was filled with tension as…
Hunter Biden's stripper baby mama asks for him to be ARRESTED

Hunter Biden Faces Potential Arrest as Legal Battle with Ex-Stripper Intensifies

In the latest twist of a high-profile legal saga, Hunter Biden finds…