'American Psycho' casting director slams Austin Butler playing Patrick Bateman
Share and Follow

Too pretty for the job.

Kerry Barden, the casting director for “American Psycho,” shared his thoughts with The Hollywood Reporter regarding Austin Butler potentially playing the role of Patrick Bateman in Luca Guadagnino’s new adaptation of Bret Easton Ellis’ novel. Barden expressed his opinion that Butler’s striking looks might not align perfectly with the character’s essence.

Instead of playing Bateman, Butler, 33, would be better suited as Jared Leto’s character Paul Allen, Barden said.

“I would cast Austin in Jared’s role because he’s that beautiful, and that’s why we cast Jared, is because he’s that beautiful,” Barden told the outlet.

“Jared is certainly a great actor as well, and obviously, Austin has a lot of depth as an actor, too,” he continued. “But not every person has that kind of beauty.”

Christian Bale played the iconic investment banker-turned-serial killer in the 2000 film directed by Mary Harron and also starring Leto, Willem Dafoe, Josh Lucas, Chloë Sevigny, Cara Seymour, Justin Theroux and Reese Witherspoon.

In Dec., Variety reported that Butler was officially cast in the lead role in the new “American Psycho” film.

The project is said to be a new adaptation of the novel and not a remake of Harron’s movie.

Butler — who infamously did method acting for his Oscar-nominated role as Elvis Presley in Baz Luhrmann’s 2022 biopic — has yet to confirm the news of his casting.

According to Variety, Jacob Elordi was rumored to be in the mix to play Bateman. Ironically, Elordi, 27, also played Elvis in Sofia Coppola’s “Priscilla” movie.

Guadagnino, 53, teased his “American Psycho” adaptation at CinemaCon earlier this month.

“We are really working hard to bring to the screen a new adaptation of Bret Easton Ellis’ ‘American Psycho,’ a book that I deeply love that is something that influenced me so much,” the “Queer” and “Challengers” director said.

He also shared that Scott Z. Burns’ script “is coming out very handsomely” and that he’s in “conversation with very exciting performers to play the leads.”

Matt Ross, who appeared in the original film as one of Bateman’s co-workers, weighed in on the new movie while speaking to The Hollywood Reporter.

“I think they have their work cut out for them, for no other reason than Christian’s performance is exceptional,” he said.

Meanwhile, producer Chris Hanley told THR: “Everybody’s calling me, going like, ‘How stupid to make [‘American Psycho’]. I’m not like that. Luca is a great director. He’s never made a bad movie.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Meghan Markle named most disappointing celebrity of 2025 by Toronto

Toronto’s Surprising 2025 Verdict: Why Meghan Markle Tops the List of Most Disappointing Celebrities

Meghan Markle has been labeled as the “most disappointing celebrity of 2025”…
Feds launch 'massive operation' in Minnesota amid fraud scandal

Federal Authorities Initiate Comprehensive Operation in Minnesota Following Fraud Scandal

Federal officers have rolled out a significant operation in Minnesota aimed at…
Kate and William share some of their favourite unseen photos from 2025

Kate and William Reveal Exclusive Unseen Photos from 2025: A Sneak Peek into Royal Life

Princess Catherine and Prince William have delighted fans by unveiling a previously…
Wild video shows speeding car going airborne, ejects driver into backyard pool

Shocking Footage: Driver Ejected into Backyard Pool as Car Goes Airborne in High-Speed Crash

Shocking surveillance footage from a home in southern Nevada captures a dramatic…
Patriots' Diggs faces criminal charges over assault and strangulation

New England Patriots’ Player Diggs Charged with Assault and Strangulation: Legal Troubles Unfold

In a surprising turn of events, Stefon Diggs, wide receiver for the…
Missing Camila Mendoz Olmos: Dashcam captures last sighting of Texas teen who vanished Christmas Eve

Texas Teen Camila Mendoza Olmos: Dashcam Footage Reveals Final Moments Before Christmas Eve Disappearance

FBI joins search for missing Texas 19-year-old The aunt and cousin of…
Tatiana Schlossberg, JFK's granddaughter, dies at 35 after year-and-a-half leukemia battle

Heartbreaking Loss: Tatiana Schlossberg, JFK’s Granddaughter, Passes Away at 35 After Courageous Leukemia Battle

Tatiana Schlossberg, a dedicated environmental journalist and granddaughter of former President John…
Father of NASCAR driver Denny Hamlin dies after house fire in North Carolina, mother critically injured

Tragic House Fire in North Carolina Claims Life of Denny Hamlin’s Father; Mother in Critical Condition

STANLEY, N.C. — Tragedy struck the family of NASCAR driver Denny Hamlin…