President Trump accused outgoing Texas Sen. John Cornyn of doing a “tremendous disservice” by blocking his nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas during an appearance on Fox News’ “Saturday in America.”
“We’re going to have a radical left lunatic get in there, and we don’t want that,” Trump said.
The president’s remarks followed Cornyn’s statement to The Associated Press that he would not return the “blue slip” for T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Justice Department official Trump selected for the US District Court for the Northern District of Texas.
The longstanding blue-slip practice allows senators from a nominee’s home state to weigh in before a judicial nomination advances.
Returning the document signals approval for the process to continue, while withholding it can prevent a district court nomination from moving forward.
“Everybody tells me he’s outstanding, and he’s being held up by John Cornyn because John Cornyn’s feelings were hurt,” Trump said. The president backed Cornyn’s primary challenger, Ken Paxton, in the Texas Republican Senate race.
“And, by the way, John Cornyn would have lost. It was just a point in time. John Cornyn would have lost by a lot. You know, one of those things. But he was beaten in the primary. And he’s — he feels badly about it,” Trump continued.
“He’s a nice guy, John Cornyn, but he’s doing a tremendous disservice because Gaiser is fantastic.”
Cornyn responded later Saturday in a post on X: “If President Trump wanted to fill a judicial vacancy in Dallas, why did he wait until after the midterms to nominate someone?”
“The seat has been vacant since 2025. Then, without any consultation, he nominates a non-Texan with little connection to the Lone Star State, with no trial court experience and who has not been appropriately vetted for a lifetime job. The Senate has a constitutional responsibility to provide ‘advice and consent,’ which is impossible without consultation,” Cornyn wrote.
“Still, I would like to work with the President to fill the seat while we still have a Senate majority. I have forwarded an outstanding candidate who was highly rated by Senator Cruz’s and my bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee, and who has now been interviewed by White House Counsel.
“All that is needed is an FBI background check, which they stand ready to do on a timely basis,” Cornyn added. “Back to you, Mr. President. Time is of the essence.”
Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, described Cornyn’s decision as “really frustrating” and recounted a tense exchange with his fellow senator in Washington earlier this week during the Fox News program.
“I came to him on the Senate floor, and I asked him to please let this judge go. And I tried to make the case on the merits that he’d make a fantastic judge. And I asked him, ‘Will you just meet with him?’ Because Cornyn refused even to meet with him,” Cruz said.
“He wouldn’t talk to him. He just said, ‘No, no, no.’ And I was asking him, I said, ‘Look, you’re going to give this seat to the Democrats. Why would you want to do that?’ And, unfortunately, he got very angry. He began screaming. He began cursing at me,” Cruz added.
Cruz said that following Republican losses in the midterm elections, “All the Republicans agreed, ‘Let’s do everything humanly possible to confirm every judge we can before the end of the year, because we know the Democrats are going to come in January,’ and I expect they’re going to block all judicial confirmations.”
“We had two vacancies in Texas, one in Austin that we’re moving forward with. And we’ll have that judge confirmed by the end of the year. We had a second vacancy in Dallas, and the problem was that we did not have time to have a brand-new nominee go through the paperwork, the FBI background check,” Cruz told Fox News.
“That takes weeks and weeks and weeks, and we simply didn’t have time between now and the end of the year to get that done. And, so, the White House proposed a different idea, which is to go with a senior lawyer at the Department of Justice, a man named Elliot Gaiser, an incredibly qualified judicial nominee.
“This is someone who was a law clerk at the U.S. Supreme Court for Justice Sam Alito. He was a state solicitor general arguing cases before the United States Supreme Court,” Cruz said.
“And he’s right now the head of the Office of Legal Counsel, which is the senior constitutional advisor to the president and the senior constitutional advisor to the attorney general.”
Cruz also said he had interviewed Gaiser and found him to be “incredibly principled, smart, capable, ready.”
Gaiser, Cruz said, “was a fantastic nomination. I was enthusiastic. Unfortunately, my colleague John Cornyn decided to block the nomination, and any one senator can block a district court nomination from your state.
“And, so, Cornyn did what’s called — he refused to return the blue slip, which basically means he vetoed it — and the result of that is the seat is going to remain vacant. The people of Dallas are not going to have a judge in that seat. And he basically gave the seat to the Democrats,” Cruz said.