Unsolved Baker County murder sheds light on importance of keeping cold cases front and center
Share and Follow

BAKER COUNTY, Fla. – Suwannee Valley Unsolved (SVU) is shedding light on an over 30-year-old unsolved murder case in hopes of helping the Baker County Sheriff’s Office finally get answers in the 1991 death of a Jacksonville woman last seen alive at a truck stop in Columbia County.

On Dec. 12, 1991, 24-year-old Kathy Barnaik was dropped off at a Lake City truck stop after a job fell through. She called her stepfather to pick her up, but he declined, so Barnaik told him she would get a ride back to Jacksonville from two truck drivers.

About a week later, her family hadn’t heard from her so they reported her missing to the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office.

Barnaik’s body was found in a garbage bag 18 months later under a bridge on Interstate 10 in Baker County.

Jason Futch, executive director for SVU, hopes that by bringing the case to light, it will change from unsolved to solved.

Read: MORE COLD CASES

“I believe that every case can be solvable,” Futch said. “Especially with the way modern forensics has moved along, I think that evidence could actually be salvaged, possibly, within the containment, so that duffel bag. Just because the integrity of the outside of the bag [was] damaged over time, what was inside could have probably been preserved.”

Futch said while DNA evidence is not available, he thinks fingerprints could be on the bag with Barnaik’s remains.

“I can’t necessarily delve into investigative methods at this moment. But we did suggest a method that they could use to try to do that. As far as if they will do that, that would be entirely up to the agency. But we think that would actually be a very helpful method,” Futch said.

Futch also hopes the renewed interest in the case will encourage the other woman who was hired to work in Lake City with Banaik will come forward with more information.

Baby Jane Doe Case: Georgia mother, boyfriend charged in death of 5-year-old found dead in 1988

Retired JSO Director Tom Hackney said technology can play a big part in solving cold cases, which was the case for JSO when investigators used a cold case grant to solve the Tammy Welch case from 1984.

“We decided to rerun everything in her case that had been ran before. And we wanted to take a new shot at it. That information that we got from that led us to a suspect and we were able to make an arrest in her case, decades later,” Hackney said.

Sharing unsolved cases can promote renewed interest or bring tips forward to help solve the case. After a News4JAX report about a 5-year-old girl referred to as Baby Jane Doe because her remains were found dumped in a trash pile in Ware County, Georgia, the Georgia Bureau of Investigations said a woman’s tip led a break in the case.

Hackney said the smallest piece of information can help bring closure to an unsolved case like Barnaik’s.

“It’s never too little. It’s never too late. And, you know, that little piece is what the detectives are going for. The fact that it’s listed as a cold case. You can make it the hot case, you pick up that phone and make it the hot case now,” Hackney said.

Anyone with information on Barnaik’s case is asked to contact Lieutenant Mancini with the Baker County Sheriff’s Office at 904-259-2861. You can also contact Crime Stoppers of Columbia County anonymously at 386-754-7099.

Copyright 2024 by WJXT News4JAX – All rights reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Mamdani mayoral campaign reports threatening, anti-Muslim messages to police

Mamdani mayoral campaign reports police about threatening, anti-Muslim messages

NEW YORK (PIX11) Assemblymember and New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani…
RFK Jr. adviser denies being anti-vaccine, cites career developing vaccines

RFK Jr.’s consultant refutes anti-vaccine claims, highlights work in creating vaccines

() Dr. Robert Malone, the mRNA vaccine researcher appointed to Health Secretary…
How to stay cool in the heat wave hitting parts of the US — even without air conditioning

Tips for staying cool during the U.S. heat wave without air conditioning

The first big heat wave of 2025 has arrived, coinciding with the…
Want to plant trees to offset fossil fuels? You'd need all of North and Central America, study finds

Study shows planting trees to balance fossil fuels would require North and Central America’s land mass

Planting trees has plenty of benefits, but this popular carbon-removal method alone…
UN nuclear chief says Iran has material to build bombs, but no plan to do so

UN nuclear chief says Iran has material to build bombs, but no plan to do so

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! As President Donald Trump…
Texans bring Damon Arnette back to NFL after death threat video

Texans reinstate Damon Arnette in NFL following video showing death threat

Damon Arnette is getting a second chance at an NFL life. The…
Texas approaches cap on state border wall spending, waits on feds for reimbursement

Texas is close to reaching the limit on how much they will spend on the state border wall and is currently waiting for the federal government to reimburse them.

HARLINGEN, Texas (Border Report) — The State of Texas is putting a…
Confirmed second victim in 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre Graves Investigation, George Melvin Gillispie.

Identification of Another Victim from the Ongoing 1921 Graves Investigation in Tulsa Race Massacre

TULSA, Okla. (KFOR) A major development Wednesday afternoon in the recovery of…