Utah mother admits to luring husband to his death in fake self-defense plot with family
Share and Follow

A woman from Utah confessed to plotting to kill her husband, with assistance from her mother and brother, staging the deadly shooting as if it were self-defense.

Kathryn Restelli, 37, admitted to a reduced charge of murder and conspiracy to commit murder for the killing of her estranged husband, Matthew Restelli, 34. He was shot at her family’s home in American Fork in July last year, as reported by KSL.

In court, the mother of two revealed that on July 12, 2024, she tricked her husband into coming to her mother’s house by suggesting they could mend their relationship, and told him he was welcome to enter without prior notice.

Restelli and her family had set things up in such a way that they would accuse Matthew of breaking into their house, allowing Kevin Ellis, her brother, to shoot him and make a claim of self-defense, according to the plea statement.

Officers who arrived at the scene testified that they found Matthew with a knife in his hand, but its placement seemed unusual and raised doubts about the family’s self-defense claim.

Police said Matthew was gripping the knife in the wrong direction and that the weapon was in his right hand — despite the fact that he’s left-handed and that a bullet wound was centered on the wrist holding the blade.

Restelli’s mother, Tracey Grist, called 911 after the shooting, but the call from inside the house came minutes after a neighbor had already notified police, setting off more alarm bells.

Diane Restelli, Matthew’s mother, said her son was concerned after his wife took the kids and family truck to stay with her family in Utah.

Matthew had agreed to drive from his California residence to American Fork to pick up his family because Restelli told him she could not rent a vehicle to come back, Diane told the court.

Despite promising Matthew that the family would drive back together, police said Restelli had not packed anything for the supposed trip.

Restelli had also put a tracking device in Matthew’s truck to monitor his arrival and stayed in touch to make sure he would get to the house so her family would be ready to act, she admitted.

Grist allegedly prepared the home for the murder, which included covering the living room couch to prevent it from getting blood stains.

Along with pleading guilty to reduced count of murder and conspiracy to commit murder, Restelli was also hit with a Felony discharge of a firearm charge.

She is set to return to court on Sept. 9 for her sentencing, where she faces a maximum of life in prison.

Ellis and Grist have both been charged with murder, conspiracy to commit murder, obstruction of justice, and two counts of domestic violence in the presence of a child.

Ellis, whose trial is expected to start on Jan. 20, has also been charged with possession of a gun as a restricted person and drug possession.

Grist also has a jury trial scheduled to start on Jan. 12.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Verdict reached: Chicago man Juan Espinoza-Martinez, accused of putting hit on Border Patrol Chief Gregory Bovino, not guilty

Chicago Resident Juan Espinoza-Martinez Acquitted in High-Profile Case Involving Alleged Hit on Border Patrol Chief

In a courtroom in Chicago, a man facing serious allegations of placing…
Ryan Reynolds TORCHED over 'cringe' email he sent to Colleen Hoover

Ryan Reynolds Criticized for Awkward Email Sent to Author Colleen Hoover

Ryan Reynolds recently found himself in the spotlight for an email he…
Armed carjacker’s wild Corvette rampage turns downtown into war zone; sergeant wounded in deadly shootout

Downtown Chaos: Armed Carjacker’s Corvette Rampage Leads to Deadly Shootout, Sergeant Injured

The chaos of a violent carjacking spree that spanned several counties came…
Viral hacks to get ice off your windshield: How well do they work?

Discover Effective DIY Methods for Clearing Ice Off Your Windshield: Do They Really Work?

We explored trending social media tricks for de-icing car windshields, such as…
FILE - Children watch television at ABC Learning Center in Minneapolis, Minn., Dec. 31, 2025. (AP Photo/Mark Vancleave, File)

Federal Court Orders Trump Administration to Continue Child Care Subsidies Across Five States

On Friday, a federal judge mandated that the Trump administration continue distributing…
Olympian drug kingpin Ryan Wedding is CAUGHT

Former Olympian Ryan Wedding Arrested in Major Drug Trafficking Bust

Ryan Wedding, a former Olympic snowboarder now facing serious allegations of cocaine…
Jury begins deliberations in Julio Foolio's murder trial after Alicia Andrews' defense in court

Breaking: Alicia Andrews Convicted of Manslaughter in High-Profile Julio Foolio Case

After more than two hours of deliberation, the jury reached a verdict…
"Heated Rivalry" boosting demand for NHL tickets, SeatGeek says

Surge in NHL Ticket Sales Driven by Intense Rivalry, Reports SeatGeek

The National Hockey League (NHL) has recently found a surprising new group…