Outrageous reason Liberty Mutual canceled CA woman's home insurance
Share and Follow

A woman from California is taking legal action against Liberty Mutual for terminating her home insurance. The reason given was the alleged discovery of mold on her roof through aerial photos that were deemed unreliable.

Maria Badin, 69, accused the provider of trying to ‘maximize profits’ with the decision to revoke coverage on her $1.8 million Poway home.

She filed a class action lawsuit in which she included the photo taken by Liberty, which it claimed showed evidence of ‘algae/mildew/mold/moss’.

The woman presented a detailed image from an independent inspection showing that her roof was actually in excellent condition, contradicting Liberty Mutual’s claim.

In the court filings, the woman’s legal team criticized insurance companies, including Liberty Mutual, for a pattern of canceling homeowners’ policies in California to boost their profits.

‘California homeowners, who have dutifully paid their premiums for years, have been, and are, being blindsided by Defendants’ nonrenewal notices informing them their policy will not continue—for stated reasons that are demonstratively false.

Badin is seeking unspecified damages and demanding a change to the way Liberty conducts such assessments.

The proposed class-action would also encompass around 17,000 homeowners who lost their insurance after Liberty subsidiary Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company refused to renew in the wake of the devastating wildfires.

A California woman is suing Liberty Mutual for cancelling her home insurance after it claimed to have spotted mold on her roof using this 'unreliable' aerial photography

A California woman is suing Liberty Mutual for cancelling her home insurance after it claimed to have spotted mold on her roof using this ‘unreliable’ aerial photography

The notices did not cite aerial photos as part of the decision, but just said the provider’s technology could no longer oversee the policies.

‘They’ve insured these homes for years with the same risks they had at the time,’ Attorney Michelle Meyers told the San Francisco Chronicle.

‘It seems pretty clear that (the non-renewal decision) was done for money,’ the higher premiums that can be charged for new policies, she said. 

Badin said she was notified last August that her more than 30-year policy would be coming to an end.

She received the long distance photograph and set about obtaining her own inspection, which revealed the roof was ‘in incredible shape’, according to her lawyers.

However, Liberty stuck by its initial decision and refused to renew her policy.

The use of aerial photographs, sometimes taken from up to 10,000 feet away, is not uncommon in the insurance world.

Maria Badin accused the provider of trying to 'maximize profits' with the decision to revoke coverage on her $1.8 million Poway home

Maria Badin accused the provider of trying to ‘maximize profits’ with the decision to revoke coverage on her $1.8 million Poway home

She got her own inspection done which she says came back totally clear and is now pursuing a class action lawsuit against Liberty Mutual

Badin is seeking unspecified damages and demanding a change to the way Liberty conducts such assessments. Pictured: Liberty Mutual CEO Timothy Sweeney

Badin is seeking unspecified damages and demanding a change to the way Liberty conducts such assessments. Pictured: Liberty Mutual CEO Timothy Sweeney

But many people have reported issues with the method, including occasions where their neighbor’s homes have been mistaken for theirs. 

Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara has already proposed a slate of reforms to help deal with an insurance crisis in California, which has seen several major providers refuse to renew policies over previously undetected defects.

A growing list of companies have limited or even stopped doing business entirely in the Golden State – many citing the intensifying risk of climate disasters.

As a result, over half of Californians say they have been affected by rising premiums for property coverage or have been dropped by their insurer in the last year, according to stark data from Redfin last year.

Anyone left without insurance faces being left on the hook for rebuilding their entire home should it be damaged by floods, fires or earthquakes. 

Liberty Mutual refused to comment when contacted by DailyMail.com.  

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Racial comments in video from Clay Co. School Board member prompt calls for resignation

Outrage Grows as Racial Remarks by Clay County School Board Member Spark Resignation Demands

The pressure is mounting on Robert Alvero to step down from his…
Jalen Brunson set to sit vs. Timberwolves as Knicks seek balance

Knicks Strategize Without Jalen Brunson Against Timberwolves to Enhance Team Dynamics

Managing player time on the court can be a challenge, and the…
Mayor Brandon Johnson has 5 days to decide whether to veto city of Chicago budget that would legalize video game terminals

Mayor Brandon Johnson Faces Five-Day Deadline to Approve or Veto Chicago’s Budget Proposal Legalizing Video Game Terminals

The clock is ticking for Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson, who is faced…
Two cruise ships crash killing tourist during Nile voyage

Two Cruise Ships Collide on the Nile, Resulting in Tourist Fatality

In a tragic incident on the River Nile, two cruise ships collided…
Brown University hires former US Attorney Zachary Cunha as possible campus shooting lawsuits loom

Brown University Appoints Former US Attorney Zachary Cunha Amid Potential Campus Shooting Legal Challenges

Exclusive to Fox News: Brown University has enlisted the expertise of former…
A sharps disposal bin to safely discard used syringes and lancets is installed in Austin, Ind., by the Scott County Health Department Tuesday, Nov. 23, 2025. (AP Photo/Obed Lamy)

Community Faces Challenges in Sustaining Vital Syringe Program Amid New Regulations

In Jeffersonville, Indiana, a storage room at the Clark County Health Department…
6 alleged members of Faceworld Chicago gang charged with racketeering conspiracy, indicted in 13 murders: U.S. Attorney's Office

U.S. Attorney Charges Six Faceworld Chicago Gang Members in Major Racketeering Conspiracy Linked to 13 Murders

In a significant legal development, a federal grand jury has brought charges…
Trump purges dozens of career ambassadors from positions

Trump Initiates Sweeping Replacement of Numerous Career Ambassadors

The Trump administration has initiated the withdrawal of nearly 30 career diplomats…