Wisconsin couple Paul VanDuyne and Andrea Whitaker charged in plot to kill ex-girlfriends with cyanide
Share and Follow

A couple from Wisconsin are facing charges for planning to use cyanide to kill two women. Investigators who were following the couple became ill after being exposed to the poison, as stated by prosecutors and accounts.

The accused individuals, Paul VanDuyne and Andrea Whitaker, allegedly manufactured toxins to carry out a complex scheme to murder two women who were former partners of VanDuyne, according to the Wisconsin Justice Department.

Prosecutors allege VanDuyne broke into a woman’s car in a Middleton Costco parking lot last month and contaminated her water bottle with cyanide.

One of the targeted women became aware of individuals near her vehicle who informed her about a potential tampering incident, even though she didn’t observe any abnormalities at the time, as reported by Fox 47.

She did find the water tasted funny, the outlet reported.

Two weeks later, the same thing is alleged to have happened again. This time, the woman brought the bottle to the police, who tested it and confirmed it contained cyanide. 

Around the same time, another woman in Rock County was hospitalized after drinking cyanide-tainted water found in her car after a gym visit. 

Both alleged victims briefly dated VanDuyne, prosecutors said. 

VanDuyne was arrested Sunday after the hazmat-linked investigations and after authorities caught him allegedly trying to help cover up evidence.

Police had been monitoring VanDuyne but were forced to move quickly when he tried to contact the Rock County woman last weekend. He was arrested and booked Sunday.

While in jail, VanDuyne called Whitaker and asked her to remove items from his house, prosecutors said.

Agents intercepted her leaving with her belongings. When searching her phone, they found multiple messages between the couple discussing different poisons.

Prosecutors believe the pair were planning to murder VanDuyne’s ex-girlfriends with poison.

At least seven state investigators on the case have been hospitalized for possible exposure to the poison, WISN.com reported. 

The outlet reported that Dane County Assistant District Attorney William Brown revealed Whitaker’s online history included searches for “Does potassium cyanide cloud water?” and “Sodium cyanide odor, sodium cyanide.”

Searches also included “What does cyanide look like?” and “Cyanide lethal,” he said. 

VanDuyne and Whitaker face charges in Rock County of attempted homicide, aggravated battery, reckless endangerment and stalking — all involving a dangerous weapon.

In Dane County, VanDuyne faces more charges for attempted homicide and stalking, while Whitaker is also accused of helping him and trying to cover it up.

Seven agencies were involved in the investigation, including the Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation, the Rock County Sheriff’s Office, the Wisconsin State Crime Laboratories and the FBI.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
What time is Bears vs Rams game today? Chicago hosts LA as temps plummet for subfreezing weather at Soldier Field for NFL playoffs

Frigid Showdown: Bears vs Rams Playoff Clash at Soldier Field – Game Time & Weather Update

CHICAGO (WLS) — As the Chicago Bears gear up to take on…
Stories Matter Foundation's Write Where You Are fellowship offers writers the tools to share their diverse stories

Empowering Diverse Voices: Stories Matter Foundation Launches ‘Write Where You Are’ Fellowship for Aspiring Writers

The Chicago-based nonprofit, Stories Matter Foundation, is thrilled to unveil its first-ever…
Rams-Bears game Sunday: Bears fan rally held downtown Chicago Saturday as NFL divisional round weekend kicks off

Chicago Bears Fans Ignite Downtown Rally Ahead of Epic Rams Showdown

CHICAGO (WLS) — Chicago is buzzing with excitement as Bears fans gear…
Argentina's bungled hunt for Hitler's right-hand man Martin Bormann revealed in declassified files

Unveiling Argentina’s Secret: The Failed Pursuit of Hitler’s Aide Martin Bormann – Declassified Files Expose the Truth

In an exclusive first reported by Fox News, a series of documents…
Mom groomed by man who seduced her and husband and kidnapped kid dies

Tragic End: Mother Deceived by Kidnapper Who Targeted Family Passes Away

Jan Broberg, known for her harrowing experience as depicted in one of…
Skokie fire: Family with newborn baby displaced after house fire on North Kostner Avenue in Skokie, Mohammed Fayyaz says

Skokie House Fire Displaces Family with Newborn on North Kostner Avenue, Reports Mohammed Fayyaz

A family with a newborn has been left without a home following…
NASA offering Artemis II 'boarding passes' ahead of space launch

Secure Your Spot: How to Get a NASA Artemis II ‘Boarding Pass’ for the Historic Space Launch

Have you ever dreamed of journeying to the moon and back? Now…
Krispy Kreme brings football-shaped doughnuts, $1 dozen deal to college championship day

Score Sweet Deals: Krispy Kreme’s Football-Shaped Doughnuts & $1 Dozen Offer for College Championship Day!

Krispy Kreme is scoring a touchdown with its latest offering just in…