Wisconsin Supreme Court refuses to take attorney general's case challenging Elon Musk's $1 million payment offers in justice race
Share and Follow

MADISON, Wis. — A unanimous Wisconsin Supreme Court on Sunday refused to hear a last-minute attempt by the state’s Democratic attorney general to stop billionaire Elon Musk from handing over $1 million checks to two voters, a ruling that came just minutes before the planned start of the rally.

Two lower courts had already rejected the legal challenge by Democrat Josh Kaul, who argues that Musk’s offer violates a state law. “Wisconsin law prohibits offering anything of value to induce anyone to vote,” Kaul argued in his filing. “Yet, Elon Musk did just that.”

But the state Supreme Court, which is currently controlled 4-3 by liberal justices, declined to take the case as an original action. The court gave no rationale for its decision.

Kaul had no immediate comment on the court’s order.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Musk’s attorneys argued in filings with the court that Musk was exercising his free speech rights with the giveaways and any attempt to restrict that would violate both the Wisconsin and U.S. constitutions.

The payments are “intended to generate a grassroots movement in opposition to activist judges, not to expressly advocate for or against any candidate,” Musk’s attorneys argued in court filings.

Wisconsin’s tightly contested Supreme Court election, where ideological control of the court is at stake, is on Tuesday. Liberals currently hold a 4-3 majority.

The court’s four liberal justices have endorsed Dane County Judge Susan Crawford, the Democratic-backed candidate.

Musk’s attorneys, about four hours before the rally was to begin, asked that two liberal justices who have campaigned for Crawford – Jill Karofsky and Rebecca Dallet – recuse themselves from the case. His attorneys argued their work for Crawford creates “the specter of inappropriate bias.” If they did recuse, that would leave the court with a 3-2 conservative majority.

Both justices rejected the request and said they would spell out their reasons why at a later date.

One of the court’s conservative justices has endorsed Waukesha County Judge Brad Schimel, who also has the backing of Trump and Musk. Schimel wore a “Make America Great Again” hat while campaigning Sunday.

At the rally scheduled in Green Bay for 6:30 p.m. CST, Musk promised to hand over a pair of $1 million checks to voters who signed an online petition against “activist” judges. Musk and groups he supports have spent more than $20 million to help Schimel get elected.

SEE ALSO | Hundreds protest Elon Musk at Chicago-area Tesla dealerships: ‘Not our president’

Schimel said in a national television interview that he does not control “any of the spending from any outside group, whether it’s Elon Musk or anyone else” and that all Trump asked was whether he would “reject activist judges” and follow the law.

“That’s exactly what I’ve committed to anybody, whether it’s President Trump, Elon Musk or any donors and donors or supporters or voters in Wisconsin. That’s my commitment,” Schimel told “Fox News Sunday.”

Schimel has not said whether he would attend the rally.

Crawford’s campaign declined comment on Kaul’s legal filing.

The contest has shattered national spending records for a judicial election, with more than $81 million in spending.

Musk’s political action committee used a nearly identical tactic before the presidential election last year, offering to pay $1 million a day to voters in Wisconsin and six other battleground states who signed a petition supporting the First and Second Amendments. A judge in Pennsylvania said prosecutors failed to show the effort was an illegal lottery and allowed it to continue through Election Day.

Musk on Friday initially said in a post on his social media platform, X, that he planned to “personally hand over” $2 million to a pair of voters who have already cast their ballots in the race.

Musk later posted a clarification, saying the money would go to people who will be “spokesmen” for an online petition against “activist” judges. After first saying the event would only be open to people who had voted in the Supreme Court race, he said attendance would be limited to those who have signed the petition.

Also on Friday, Musk’s political action committee identified the recipient of its first $1 million giveaway – a Green Bay man who had donated to the Wisconsin GOP and the conservative candidate in the court race, and who has a history of posting support for Trump and his agenda.

The judicial election comes as Wisconsin’s highest court is expected to rule on abortion rights, congressional redistricting, union power and voting rules that could affect the 2026 midterms and the 2028 presidential election in the state.

Associated Press writer Gary Fields in Washington contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2025 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Cheryl Hines snaps on The View after being grilled on RFK Jr

Cheryl Hines Responds Firmly to Intense RFK Jr. Questions on The View

Cheryl Hines engaged in a spirited debate with Sunny Hostin on The…
Trump storms most violent US city with federal muscle as police group warns of soft-on-crime consequences

Trump Deploys Federal Forces: Addressing Crime Surge in America’s Most Violent City

The Trump administration’s decision to send federal law enforcement to a predominantly…
Corpse abuse charges dropped after 'experiment' accusations

Charges Dismissed in Controversial Corpse Abuse Case Amid ‘Scientific Experiment’ Defense

In a notable turn of events in Austin, Texas, legal actions against…
Walmart partners with OpenAI to enable shopping through ChatGPT

Walmart Teams Up with OpenAI to Revolutionize Shopping via ChatGPT

In an innovative move, Walmart is revolutionizing the shopping experience by integrating…
How Zohran Mamdani could threaten public safety for decades

Unpacking the Potential Long-term Public Safety Impacts of Zohran Mamdani’s Policies

What actions can land someone behind bars in New York City? Last…
In Texas, new details about its execution drug underscore a closely guarded secret

Texas Execution Drug Revelations Unveil State’s Secrecy in Capital Punishment Practices

Texas, long known for leading the nation in the number of executions,…
Mom of three fatally shot by roommate who mistook her for intruder: police

Tragic Case of Mistaken Identity: Roommate Accidentally Shoots Mother of Three

A tragic incident unfolded in Columbus, Georgia, where a mother of three…
Florida Rep Cory Mills restraining order from Miss USA Lindsey Langston sextortion case

Florida Congressman Cory Mills Faces Restraining Order Amid Miss USA Sextortion Allegations

A Florida judge has issued a restraining order against Representative Cory Mills,…