Young activists won a landmark state climate trial. Now they're challenging Trump's orders
Share and Follow


Billings, Mont. (AP) — Young climate activists and their attorneys who won a landmark global warming trial against the state of Montana are trying to convince a federal judge to block President Donald Trump’s executive orders promoting fossil fuels.

During a two-day hearing starting Tuesday in Missoula, Montana, the activists and their experts plan to describe Trump’s actions to boost drilling and mining and discourage renewable energy as a growing danger to children and the planet. They say the Republican’s stoking of global warming violates their constitutional rights.

A victory for the activists would have much broader implications than their 2023 win, where a state court faulted officials for permitting oil, gas and coal projects without regard for global warming.

But legal experts say the young activists and their lawyers from the environmental group Our Children’s Trust face longer odds in federal court. The Montnana case hinged on a provision in the state constitution declaring people have a “right to a clean and healthful environment.” That language is absent from the U.S. Constitution.

“Federal law doesn’t really offer anything to really work with for these groups,” said David Dana, a professor at Northwestern University Law School in Chicago.

Attorneys for the U.S. Department of Justice and 19 states plus Guam want Judge Dana Christensen to dismiss the case.

A previous federal climate lawsuit in Oregon from Our Children’s Trust went on for a decade and ended in a denial this year from the U.S. Supreme Court.

Our Children’s Trust attorney Andrea Rodgers acknowledged the Montana litigation faces challenges. But she said the Constitution contains protections for life and liberty that cannot be ignored.

“We’re asking the Court to apply traditional laws with respect to what constitutes the right to life and the right for liberty,” Rodgers said.

A 19-year-old from California plans to testify to Christensen about the harms of wildfire smoke. A 17-year-old from Montana is slated to speak about Trump’s actions frustrating her attempts to get electric buses for her school. And a 20-year-old Oregon woman going to school in Florida will talk about how Trump’s plans could result in worse hurricanes and wildfires.

“No matter where I live, I cannot escape extreme climate events resulting from fossil fuel pollution,” Avery McRae, the student from Oregon, said in a declaration to the court.

The 22 plaintiffs include youths and young adults from Montana and several other states. Only the Montana plaintiffs were involved in the 2023 trial.

It’s a similar playbook as the 2023 trial. Young plaintiffs spent days on the witness stand describing how worsening fires foul the air they breathe, while drought and decreased snowpack deplete rivers that sustain farming, fish, wildlife and recreation.

Carbon dioxide, which is released when fossil fuels are burned, traps heat in the atmosphere and is largely responsible for the warming of the climate.

The federal government and states do not plan to call any witnesses.

Amanda Braynack, a spokesperson for Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen, said the states were trying to prevent the litigants from “destroying our country’s energy security.”

Even if the activists lose, it could draw attention to Trump’s perceived failures to act against climate change, said Jonathan Adler, a climate law expert at William and Mary Law School in Virginia.

“These cases have always been about not just what occurs in the court of law, but also in the court of public opinion,” Adler said.

Montana’s Supreme Court last year upheld the ruling in the 2023 trial. However, to date that’s yielded few meaningful changes in a state dominated by Republicans who want to drill more oil and gas and dig more coal.

Utlitity regulators this month denied a petition from environmentalists who cited the 2023 case in a request for the Montana Public Service Commission to consider climate change when considering energy projects.

Gov. Greg Gianforte told The Associated Press that the state would follow the law but needs more electricity including from fossil fuels.

“We have an obligation to our constitution and just morally to protect the environment, he said. ”But I don’t think that’s inconsistent with electricity production, and we need to be using fossil fuels coal, gas, oil, hydro, wind and potentially nuclear.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Bodycam shows 'Slender Man' stabber captured by police after escaping group home

Bodycam Footage Reveals Police Recapture of ‘Slender Man’ Stabbing Perpetrator Following Escape from Group Home

Police body camera footage has surfaced, capturing the dramatic moment officers encountered…
Arlington Heights murder-suicide: Juan Medina kills Steven Weigensberg, turns gun on himself at Dana Point Condominiums, PD says

Tragic Murder-Suicide at Arlington Heights: Juan Medina and Steven Weigensberg Dead in Dana Point Condominiums Shooting

Residents of a condo building in Arlington Heights, Illinois, remain on edge…
Pam Bondi's blunt response after federal indictments thrown out

Pam Bondi Delivers Candid Remarks Following Dismissal of Federal Indictments

Pam Bondi delivered a straightforward critique of her competitor, beauty queen Lindsey…
Father of cheerleader who died on Carnival cruise subpoenaed to testify in custody case

Shocking Twist: Father of Deceased Cheerleader Faces Court Subpoena Amidst Carnival Cruise Tragedy

The tragic death of a Florida cheerleader, Anna Kepner, aboard a Carnival…
Bombshell report alleges Biden team forced airports to house migrants, risking safety

Explosive Report Reveals Biden Administration’s Controversial Use of Airports for Migrant Housing

The Biden administration is reportedly under scrutiny for allegedly urging U.S. airports…
James Van Der Beek shares playful new video amid cancer battle as wife gushes he's 'bouncing back'

James Van Der Beek Releases Uplifting Video During Cancer Fight, as Wife Praises His Resilience

She’s undoubtedly his biggest cheerleader. James Van Der Beek delighted fans with…
College freshman died after fraternity hazing led to 'horrific' abuse, family says

Family Alleges ‘Horrific’ Abuse in Fraternity Hazing Incident Resulting in College Freshman’s Death

The family of a college freshman from Texas has initiated a wrongful…
Ukraine agrees to peace deal brokered by Trump, US official says

Ukraine Reaches Peace Agreement with Trump as Mediator, According to U.S. Official

Ukraine has accepted a peace proposal from Donald Trump aimed at ending…