Supreme Court upholds phone and internet subsidy program for underserved areas
Share and Follow


WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Friday rejected a challenge to a Federal Communications Commission program that subsidizes phone and internet services in underserved parts of the country.

In a decision written by Justice Elena Kagan, the court ruled that Congress did not exceed its authority when it enacted a 1996 law that set up the Universal Service Fund, which requires telecommunications services to submit payments to subsidize “universal service.”

The court also said the FCC could delegate its authority to a private corporation called the Universal Service ministrative Company to administer the fund.

“Nothing in these arrangements, either separately or together, violates the Constitution,” Kagan wrote.

The justices were divided 6-3, with three conservative justices dissenting.

The fees, generally passed on to customers, raise billions of dollars a year that are spent on providing phone and internet services, including for schools, libraries and hospitals.

Challengers said the program violates the “nondelegation doctrine,” a theory embraced by conservatives that says Congress has limited powers to delegate its lawmaking authority to the executive branch.

Lower courts were divided over the issue, with both the FCC and a coalition led by Consumers’ Research, a conservative group, asking the Supreme Court to weigh in.

Opponents call the Universal Service Fund fee a form of tax and say only elected officials, not bureaucrats, have the power to impose it.

The 1996 law is particularly problematic because it does not tell the FCC how much money it can raise via the program, the challengers’ lawyers argued.

The court has a 6-3 conservative majority that has undercut the authority of government agencies in a series of recent decisions.

That had led some commentators to wonder if it would use the FCC case to turbocharge the nondelegation doctrine.

The current court has not yet embraced the nondelegation doctrine, although in different contexts, a majority of justices have indicated support for it. If the court did reinvigorate the idea, agencies would face new limits on their powers to implement existing laws and programs that seek to enforce open-ended laws enacted by Congress.

Although the Trump administration has sought to weaken federal agencies by firing thousands of workers, its lawyers defended the FCC in the case. The administration took over the case from the Biden administration, which had appealed the case to the Supreme Court.

President Donald Trump has tried to expand the powers of the presidency at the expense of Congress and the judiciary, so his administration’s position in the case is consistent with that approach.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Texas-based marine robotics company launches 55-day mission to find Malaysia Airlines flight wreckage

Texas Robotics Pioneer Embarks on Ambitious 55-Day Quest to Uncover Malaysia Airlines Mystery

A Texas-based marine robotics firm has launched a mission to unearth the…
At least 52 bears killed in Florida's first black bear hunt in 10 years

Florida’s Controversial Black Bear Hunt: 52 Bears Killed in Decade’s First Legal Hunt

The Florida black bear hunt has concluded, with official reports from the…
Surprising health risks of Dry January mocktails... including cancer

Discover the Hidden Health Concerns of Dry January Mocktails You Need to Know

Each year, millions of Americans engage in the tradition of Dry January,…
Europe's skiing 'ghost resorts': How hundreds of slopes lie abandoned due to lack of snow as videos show bare mountains

Unveiling Europe’s Abandoned Ski Resorts: A Haunting Journey Through Forgotten Winter Wonderlands

Hundreds of European ski slopes have been left deserted, transforming into ‘ghost…
Michelle Heston of Heston Cakes shares creative holiday cake decorating ideas and tips for extra wow

Michelle Heston of Heston Cakes Unveils Innovative Holiday Cake Decorating Techniques for a Stunning Festive Display

In the bustling culinary scene of San Francisco, one might stumble upon…
Brown University implements campus-wide security overhaul after mass shooting leaves 2 dead, 9 wounded

Brown University Initiates Comprehensive Security Revamp Following Tragic Mass Shooting Resulting in 2 Fatalities and 9 Injuries

In the wake of the tragic mass shooting at Brown University on…
Heartbreak after body found in search for missing teen

Tragic Discovery: Missing Teen’s Body Found in Heart-Wrenching Search

The mother of a missing teen heartbreakingly uttered “so close to home”…
OG Anunoby is Jalen Brunson's closing partner in crime for Knicks

OG Anunoby Emerges as Jalen Brunson’s Key Teammate in Knicks’ Clutch Performances

Jalen Brunson, the current NBA Clutch Player of the Year, has emerged…