Jacksonville woman pleads guilty to killing girlfriend, leaving her remains out
Share and Follow


Shannon McCarthy, 46, was sentenced to 30 years in prison after changing her plea from not guilty to guilty on charges in her girlfriend’s murder.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — A Jacksonville woman was sentenced to 30 years in prison on Thursday after pleading guilty to killing her girlfriend and leaving her remains out on the front porch of their home for nearly a week in 2023, according to State Attorney Melissa Nelson.

Judge Meredith Charbula sentenced Shannon McCarthy, 46, after she changed her plea from not guilty to guilty on charges of second-degree murder, tampering with evidence and written threats to kill or do bodily injury for the murder of Heather Sheppard.

On July 3, 2023, Sheppard’s daughter contacted the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office to report Sheppard missing; she had been missing since June 29, 2023. 

On July 5, 2023, detectives found Sheppard’s remains in an “advanced state of decomposition” outside of her and McCarthy’s home on Colonial Avenue.

Police were at their home to investigate Sheppard’s disappearance, according to McCarthy’s arrest report. Nelson said in a release that McCarthy gave detectives permission to search the home, and that they witnessed her throw a tarp over items on the front porch. Detectives then removed the tarp, which led to the discovery of Sheppard’s remains.

Neighbors nearby the couple’s home reported smelling a “foul odor” before Sheppard’s body was located.

Sheppard’s family previously told First Coast News Sheppard’s phone was turned off, her credit cards were missing, a stained pair of shoes were found in the couple’s home, and that they found Sheppard’s truck with a bullet hole in it.

Sheppard’s autopsy confirmed she was shot multiple times, according to Nelson. 

“The Florida Department of Law Enforcement analyzed the projectiles and confirmed they matched McCarthy’s gun,” Nelson said in the release.

McCarthy was already facing charges from a reported battery against Sheppard in January 2023. She was out on bond on the battery charges, but her bond was revoked by a judge after Sheppard’s remains were found.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Two new Buc-ee's are coming to Florida. Here's when

Two New Buc-ee’s Locations Set to Open in Florida: Here Are the Anticipated Opening Dates

St. Lucie and Ocala are set to welcome the iconic Buc-ee’s convenience…
Cops rule college freshman’s deadly dorm fall an accident, but DA delays closure as family fights for answers

Authorities Conclude College Freshman’s Dormitory Fall Was Accidental; District Attorney Holds Case Open Amidst Family’s Pursuit for Clarity

Almost a year after the tragic incident involving UC Santa Barbara freshman…
Taylor Swift makes surprise appearance at 'End of an Era' screening for family and tour crew

Taylor Swift Shocks Fans with Unannounced Cameo at ‘End of an Era’ Screening for Family and Tour Crew

Taylor Swift is marking the conclusion of a significant chapter with those…
Supreme Court hears Alabama's appeal to execute intellectually disabled man on death row

Supreme Court Faces Landmark Decision: Alabama’s Controversial Push to Execute Intellectually Disabled Inmate

WASHINGTON (AP) — On Wednesday, the Supreme Court grappled with the complexities…
Three arrested in connection with Waycross murder, police say

Waycross Murder Case: Police Arrest Three Suspects in Connection to Homicide

Following a shooting incident on Isabella Street, Waycross police have apprehended three…
Will Smith appears on'Bel-Air' series finale in surprise cameo

Will Smith Shocks Fans with Unexpected Cameo in ‘Bel-Air’ Series Finale – A Must-See Moment!

Will Smith has made a nostalgic return to Bel-Air, bringing a delightful…
Damning truth about Ilhan Omar marrying her BROTHER

Explosive Allegations: The Controversy Behind Ilhan Omar’s Alleged Marriage to Her Brother

Ilhan Omar has strongly criticized the President, labeling him a bigot for…
Israel's war in Gaza: 4 Palestinian children in need of medical care arrive at O'Hare Airport in Chicago

Streamwood Standoff: Police Encircle Home for Hours Near Yellowstone and Kings Canyon Drives in Suspect Arrest Attempt

STREAMWOOD, Ill. — A suburban neighborhood in Streamwood was the focus of…