How fantasy baseball owners should adjust to post MLB deadline world
Share and Follow

The MLB trade deadline is a thrilling yet nerve-wracking time, especially for fantasy baseball enthusiasts.

Gone are the days when fantasy players in AL or NL-only leagues worried about their players moving to the other league. Now, the concern is more about players losing their starting positions, particularly closers.

It’s common to see a closer get traded to a contender only to be reassigned as a setup man instead of maintaining their role as the ninth-inning savior. This season reflected that trend.

As the Yankees restructure their bullpen, they added both Camilo Doval and David Bednar to their roster.

Doval was closing for the Giants, Bednar for the Pirates, and now both sit behind incumbent Devin Williams. If you play in a league that counts “saves plus holds,” you’re still in business, but unless something drastic happens to Williams, neither has the value they had before the deadline.

The same thing happened to both Kyle Finnegan of the Nationals and Ryan Helsley of the Cardinals.

They gave their fantasy managers 21 and 20 saves respectively, and now neither is likely to see another save opportunity the rest of the way.

Helsley may still have a bit of value as a reliever who can augment strikeouts and stabilize ERA, but Finnegan should probably be dropped. But the real blow comes when your closer’s team trades for a better closer.

Robert Suárez of the Padres currently leads the league in saves with 30, but the addition of Mason Miller and his triple-digits fastball pushes Suárez to setup.


Ryan Helsley still has value for fantasy baseball owners even though he's not the Mets closer.
Ryan Helsley still has value for fantasy baseball owners even though he’s not the Mets closer. Jason Szenes / New York Post

This happened in Philadelphia as well, as Jordan Romano gets shoved aside in favor of former Twins closer Jhoan Duran.

The Romano demotion doesn’t hurt as much, but losing Suárez is going to hurt several contending fantasy teams.

But most situations do have a silver lining in the form of those who were left behind.

With Bednar gone, the Pirates will turn to Dennis Santana, who likely is available on your waiver wire.


Dennis Santana is the the Pirates' new closer, now that David Bednar is a Yankee.
Dennis Santana is the the Pirates’ new closer, now that David Bednar is a Yankee. Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images

The Twins are expected to turn to Cole Sands, the Athletics are going to Jack Perkins and Michael Kelly, the Giants will use Randy Rodríguez and Ryan Walker, and the Nationals will lean on the lefty/righty platoon of Jose Ferrer and Cole Henry.

The Cardinals also will employ a committee until someone stands out, so give a look at the trio of JoJo Romero, Riley O’Brien and Gordon Graceffo.

None of the situations are ideal, but if you lost your fantasy closer and need saves, desperate times call for desperate measures.

Winning a fantasy championship requires intelligence, skill and knowledge, but it also is about being able to think on the fly and roll with the punches.

With any trade that slams the door shut on your saves, there is a window of opportunity that opens somewhere else.

Howard Bender is the head of content at FantasyAlarm.com. Follow him on X @rotobuzzguy and catch him on the award-winning “Fantasy Alarm Radio Show” on the SiriusXM fantasy sports channel weekdays from 6-8 p.m. Go to FantasyAlarm.com for all your fantasy baseball news and advice.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
UK police say 10 people hospitalized after train stabbing attack, 9 with life-threatening injuries

Breaking: Train Stabbing in the UK Leaves 10 Hospitalized, 9 Critically Injured

LONDON — A tragic incident unfolded on a train bound for London…
Teen injured after biting into Halloween candy bar

Teen Suffers Injury from Biting into Halloween Candy Bar

A startling discovery in Halloween candy left a teenager from Indy’s East…
FBI agents gather outside a home in a Dearborn, Mich., neighborhood on Friday, Oct. 31, 2025. (AP Photo/Mike Householder)

Michigan Attorney Challenges FBI’s Alleged Halloween Terror Plot Claims

In Michigan, a defense attorney is challenging claims made by FBI Director…
Florida man nabbed by Homeland Security for allegedly making online death threats against ICE 'Gestapo'

Florida Man Arrested by Homeland Security for Alleged Online Death Threats Against ICE

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) revealed on Saturday that Homeland Security…
2 new suspects handed preliminary charges in Louvre jewels heist case, Paris prosecutor says

Paris Prosecutor Announces Preliminary Charges for Two New Suspects in Louvre Jewel Heist Case

PARIS (AP) — On Saturday, the Paris prosecutor announced that two additional…
Carbon capture pipelines have struggled to advance. A project in Nebraska found success

Nebraska’s Breakthrough: How a Pioneering Carbon Capture Pipeline is Leading the Way

In September, a pioneering carbon capture pipeline spanning multiple states commenced operations,…
How a once‐Democratic seaside town turned into MAGA stronghold

Seismic Political Shift: How a Democratic Seaside Town Transformed into a MAGA Stronghold

In 2020, a coastal city just outside Los Angeles appeared to be…
Dog rushed to vet after ingesting methamphetamine during walk in park

Urgent Vet Visit: Dog Accidentally Consumes Methamphetamine at Local Park

A dog owner in Southern California faced a frightening situation when her…