Pakistan Supreme Court Upholds Christian Man’s Death Sentence in Blasphemy Case

Pakistan’s Supreme Court has upheld the conviction and death sentence of a Christian man accused of blasphemy against the Prophet Muhammad, prompting widespread anger and condemnation.

Supporters of the accused say the ruling could have serious consequences for human rights in Pakistan and damage the country’s international reputation. Pakistan was listed among the 10 countries where Christians face the most severe persecution in the Open Doors 2026 World Watch List.

CeCe Heil, senior counsel and international legal director at the American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ), told News Media that the case involving brothers Amoon and Qaisar Ayub dates back to 2014.

Qaisar was arrested after a WordPress website published the brothers’ contact details alongside material deemed insulting to the Prophet Muhammad. Amoon was detained the next year. Heil said that throughout 12 years of legal proceedings, prosecutors have never produced evidence demonstrating that either brother was connected to the WordPress site carrying the offensive material.

The ACLJ began representing Amoon soon after his 2015 arrest through its Pakistani partner, the Organization for Legal Aid (OLA). Both brothers were sentenced to death in 2018, and their appeals were rejected by the Lahore High Court in 2022. Following further proceedings before the Supreme Court in 2025, Qaisar asked the OLA to take on his case.

After years of legal arguments and 13 delayed hearings, the Supreme Court issued its verdict on Oct. 7. Amoon was acquitted after spending roughly 10 years in prison, but the court upheld Qaisar’s conviction and death sentence.

Heil said blasphemy proceedings in Pakistan are increasingly conducted under intense pressure, with what she described as “mobs” regularly appearing in courtrooms.

In one case, she said, a mob recorded a video declaring that “if the judge does not enforce death by hanging, we will kill him by our own hands.” Another video, according to Heil, features a prominent lawyer involved in several blasphemy cases celebrating the 15-year legal journey that ended with Qaisar’s sentencing. A translation of the video’s description states: “There is only one punishment for one who insults the Prophet: The death penalty for Qaisar Ayub.”

Heil warned that the Supreme Court ruling could affect “every single person that is sitting in prison right now on blasphemy charges,” including at least three people represented by the OLA.

Among the other Christian men facing execution is Shahzad Masih, who was 16 when he was accused of blasphemy in 2017. He received a death sentence five years later, while his appeals have repeatedly been delayed since 2022.

IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Judge Rejects ‘Deal of the Century’ in Dad’s Face-Shooting Case

Intizar Masih is awaiting trial over a blasphemous post he allegedly shared on WhatsApp in 2023. Ahsan Masih was accused of uploading blasphemous material to TikTok that same year and was sentenced to death in 2024. Hearings on his appeal have also been postponed.

The OLA expects to submit a review petition to the Supreme Court as early as this week, challenging Qaisar’s conviction on the grounds that there is no supporting evidence. The group also plans to appeal directly to Pakistan’s government for assistance, including a presidential pardon for Qaisar.

Heil said it was “very strange” that Pakistan, while presenting itself as a “more tolerant” mediator between global powers during the ongoing conflict in Iran, would fail to safeguard the religious freedom of its own citizens.

The Pakistani Embassy in Washington, D.C., did not answer News Media’s questions about whether Qaisar could receive a presidential pardon, whether the Supreme Court ruling might affect Pakistan’s standing in the West, or whether a fair trial is possible in courtrooms surrounded by threatening crowds.

A State Department spokesperson told News Media that the United States “is concerned about religious freedom in Pakistan and throughout the world” and that officials “regularly discuss this concern with Pakistan, as we would with any country.”

Heil said the ACLJ has asked Morris Tidball-Binz, the United Nations special rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, to intervene on Qaisar’s behalf.

Tidball-Binz did not respond to News Media’s questions about whether he held concerns about the precedent set by the Supreme Court upholding Qaisar’s conviction.

The Human Rights Council secretariat provided a letter that Tidball-Binz and other U.N. officials wrote to the Government of Pakistan in September 2025, emphasizing their concerns about the cases of the Ayub brothers and Shahazad Masih. 

It stated, “Without making any judgment as to the accuracy of the information made available to us, we would like to express our grave concern about the imposition of the mandatory death penalty for blasphemy related charges against Mr. Shahzad Masih, Mr. Qaiser Ayub and Mr. Amoon Ayub, despite an apparent lack of conclusive evidence against them for acts and for offenses which do not qualify as ‘most serious crimes.’”

The U.N. officials concluded, “If the above allegations prove to be accurate, they would be in contravention of Mr. Shahazad Masih´s, Mr. Qaiser Ayub’s and Mr. Amoon Ayub’s rights to life, not to be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, not to be deprived arbitrarily of their liberty and to be afforded fair proceedings before an independent and impartial tribunal, to freedom of thought, conscience and religion or belief, the right to express their opinion in a peaceful manner and the right to be equal before the law and are entitled to the equal protection of the law without any discrimination.” 

The Government of Pakistan responded earlier this year, and outlined how “Under Pakistan’s Constitution, such matters fall within the judicial domain, and the Executive is constitutionally prohibited from intervening in individual cases.”

Heil said that while Amoon has been spared from the death penalty, their work is ongoing to keep him safe from reprisals.