PETA Criticized for Using DC Shooting to Protest Foie Gras Sale at Nearby Restaurant

PETA drew widespread condemnation Thursday after invoking a deadly shooting in Washington, DC, in a protest against Mallard restaurant’s planned foie gras dinner. “An active...
HomeUSElizabeth Holmes: Idealistic Innovator or Convicted Fraudster?

Elizabeth Holmes: Idealistic Innovator or Convicted Fraudster?

Critics have been lavish with their praise for this film, calling it “ingenious”, “stupefying”, “gloriously destabilising” and “more than fascinating”. One reviewer even described it as an “unalloyed masterpiece”. Five stars hardly seem sufficient.

Some are already predicting a Best Picture Oscar, while audiences in the US have reportedly been so captivated that they remain in their seats for all 174 minutes, apparently forgetting even the most basic need to visit the loo.

The film inspiring such fervour is You Can See Everything, a documentary about convicted Silicon Valley fraudster Elizabeth Holmes.

Now the excitement has crossed the Atlantic ahead of its UK release on Friday. Picturehouse Cinemas says demand for tickets has been “bonkers”.

Over London’s Piccadilly Circus, a huge billboard displays an extreme close-up of Holmes’s wide eyes. The 20ft-high gaze looks eerily down at the shoppers below.

If the eyes really are the windows to the soul, what is concealed behind Holmes’s unnerving stare? That is the central question driving the documentary.

Is she a sociopathic narcissist, an idealistic genius who overreached, or simply a misunderstood eccentric? One of the filmmakers suggests she is either “fully sincere” or “the most manipulative person who ever lived”. The uncertainty is what makes her so compelling.

Holmes is a remarkably fascinating figure, someone who appears to have been born with both a business plan and a contacts book filled with people from whom she could seek money.

If the eyes are the window of the soul, what lies behind Elizabeth Holmes's unsettling stare? This is the question that drives the film

If the eyes are the window of the soul, what lies behind Elizabeth Holmes’s unsettling stare? This is the question that drives the film

Nathan Fielder, left, and  Holmes are pictured in a scene from 'You Can See Everything'

Nathan Fielder, left, and  Holmes are pictured in a scene from ‘You Can See Everything’

Her grand idea was a machine capable of testing hundreds of health markers, from vitamin levels to thyroid function, using just one drop of blood. Holmes modestly called it “the most important thing humanity has ever built”, promising to transform healthcare and save millions of lives.

Once Holmes fixed her sights on global domination, little appeared capable of stopping her. She abandoned a chemical engineering degree at Stanford University to launch Theranos. In the company’s early days, she reportedly slept for just four hours a night and relied on chocolate-covered coffee beans to sustain her through the remaining 20 hours.

There was one significant problem: the machine did not work. During demonstrations, it clanked, malfunctioned and failed to deliver the promised results. Components even fell away. It resembled a GCSE science project being presented as a time machine.

Holmes nevertheless behaved as though she had created the greatest invention since the wheel. Some have linked this to an extreme form of cognitive bias known as the Dunning-Kruger effect, in which people dramatically overestimate their abilities. Lacking the skills to achieve greatness? Never mind: fake it until you make it.

That is precisely what Holmes did. Fake Pfizer logos appeared on laboratory reports to make them seem more credible. Regulators received fabricated blood-test results. False projections claimed the start-up would generate $100million (£76million) in a year, although the actual figure was closer to $100,000 (£76,000). Holmes even claimed the machine was being used in combat zones in the Middle East. The deception simply kept expanding.

Perhaps her monumental ambition was partly inherited. Her great-great-great-grandfather built Fleischmann’s Yeast, helping make the family one of America’s wealthiest at the turn of the century. Her great-great-grandfather founded Cincinnati General Hospital.

“I grew up with these stories about greatness,” Holmes has said, while recalling that her parents encouraged her to aim high. At one family dinner, her father sent a paper aeroplane gliding towards her with the word “PhD” written on it.

Here lies an intriguing theme in the tale of Elizabeth Holmes: her power to beguile and bewitch the men around her

Here lies an intriguing theme in the tale of Elizabeth Holmes: her power to beguile and bewitch the men around her

“No, dad,” Elizabeth replied. “I want to make money.”

Employees at Theranos who questioned the malfunctioning machine were dismissed harshly. “What matters is the company,” Holmes told staff, with the fervour of a cult leader. An investment fortune of $1.6billion (£1.2billion) was assembled on a foundation of deceit, in what became the most audacious fraud since the Eiffel Tower was supposedly “sold” to a gullible scrap-metal dealer. Holmes’s targets, in this case, were often older male investors.

This points to one of the most intriguing aspects of the Holmes story: her ability to charm and enchant the powerful men around her.

Former US Secretary of State George Shultz was among them. He joined the Theranos board, became deeply attached to its founder and called her every day, praising her as “brilliant”.

When his own grandson, who worked at Theranos, tried to expose the fraud, Shultz attempted to silence him and defended Holmes fiercely.

Shultz’s biographer went so far as to suggest that “he fell in love with Elizabeth Holmes… he was infatuated with her and she understood that and played on it in a calculating way”.

Other influential men were similarly captivated, and spoke about her in glowing terms. Another former US Secretary of State, Henry Kissinger, admired her “ethereal quality”.

Though Holmes is pretty enough, she is not a bombshell. In homage to her idol Steve Jobs, she dressed every day in a black polo neck and trousers, blonde hair swept back

Though Holmes is pretty enough, she is not a bombshell. In homage to her idol Steve Jobs, she dressed every day in a black polo neck and trousers, blonde hair swept back

Stanford professor Channing Robertson said she was unlike any other student he had taught.

James Mattis, the retired four-star Marine general, regarded her as a “revolutionary”. Media tycoon Rupert Murdoch, who invested $125million (£94.5million) in Theranos, emailed after their first meeting to say that he had “enjoyed every minute” of it.

In Bad Blood, the definitive account of the scandal, author John Carreyrou writes that Holmes “wrapped people around her finger and persuaded them to do her bidding”. One after another, he says, they “fell under her spell”.

So how did she do it? Holmes is attractive, but not a conventional bombshell. Inspired by her idol Steve Jobs, she wore a black polo neck and trousers almost every day, with her blonde hair swept back. Occasionally she added red lipstick, but her appeal was not based on a traditional sex-kitten image.

Her magnetism came from something more difficult to define. Holmes combined two qualities that proved particularly intoxicating to the men she courted: confidence and vulnerability.

On one side, she was an extraordinarily self-assured woman in black, capable of overwhelming experienced investors with the force of her conviction. On the other, she could trigger a protective response. These men did more than invest in her company. They put an arm around her, invited her to family brunches, worried about her working in a dangerous neighbourhood and took it upon themselves to look after her.

She was also highly skilled at playing the protégé, winning over powerful men by deferring to them and giving them her complete attention.

You Can See Everything, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, was unveiled at the Telluride Film Festival's Sunday TBA

You Can See Everything, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, was unveiled at the Telluride Film Festival’s Sunday TBA

Above all, Holmes was captivating because of what might be called charismatic intensity, often conveyed through her wide, unwavering stare.

In Bad Blood, it is striking how frequently people describe the way she looked at them. A journalist who met her “felt himself drawn in by the young woman sitting across from him who was staring at him intently without blinking”.

A former school friend recalled that Holmes had “this intense way of looking at you while she spoke that made you believe in her and want to follow her”.

When Theranos’s chief financial officer entered her office, he was “immediately reminded of her charisma… the way she trained her big blue eyes on you without blinking made you feel like the centre of the world. It was almost hypnotic.”

That same hypnotic gaze appears repeatedly in You Can See Everything.

After being convicted on four fraud counts in 2022, Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in prison. Aware that her reputation had collapsed, the disgraced entrepreneur made the extraordinary decision to invite two filmmakers to live with her family for more than a month between her conviction and the start of her sentence. Her lawyers had lodged an ultimately unsuccessful appeal, and she remained at home on bail while it was being considered.

The filmmakers were able to “see everything” and potentially help reshape public perceptions of Holmes. One of them, Nathan Fielder, is an American comedian whose approach recalls Louis Theroux: an understated, awkward presence on screen who encourages his subjects to relax and lower their defences.

Yet as Fielder becomes more familiar with Holmes, it is he, rather than she, who appears to let his guard slip.

One minute she is showing flashes of the bleach–blonde tyrant of Theranos; the next she's crying or cuddling her three-month-old baby daughter or son

One minute she is showing flashes of the bleach–blonde tyrant of Theranos; the next she’s crying or cuddling her three-month-old baby daughter or son

Their exchanges linger, and the chemistry between them is unmistakable. In one breathless moment, Holmes silently stares at him with a half-smile, her expression impossible to read.

We watch Fielder being drawn in by her intensity, hypnotised despite knowing exactly what she had done. Unlike the investors she persuaded, he was aware that she had bullied employees, fired dozens of people and repeatedly lied.

He also knew those lies could have cost lives, since sick people had been used as guinea pigs for Theranos’s unreliable blood-testing machines.

Even so, the documentary strongly suggests that Fielder, too, has been affected by Holmes’s charm.

“She was so different than I thought she would be,” he recently admitted. “She was disarming in real life.”

Like the investors she enchanted, Fielder seems caught in Holmes’s mixture of certainty and fragility.

One moment she resembles the bleach-blonde tyrant who ran Theranos; the next she is crying, cuddling her three-month-old baby daughter or son, now nearly two, and looking like any other frizzy-haired mother encountered in Walmart.

“In my life, I’ve never been so confused by a person,” Fielder reflects.

The picture becomes even more complicated when the documentary examines toxic relationships. We expect Holmes to be the villain of You Can See Everything, yet another figure gradually emerges as a more troubling presence: her partner.

Billy Evans, heir to an extremely wealthy family, comes across as shifty and controlling, apparently oblivious to the damaging impression he creates.

He exerts influence over Holmes in numerous ways, from criticising how she scrambles eggs to taking control of her social-media account, becoming her power of attorney and boasting that he can “literally do anything”.

This was not Holmes’s first relationship with a controlling man. While she was building Theranos, she had a long affair with Sunny Balwani, a technology executive 20 years her senior.

During her trial, Holmes alleged that Balwani repeatedly criticised her, telling her she “came across as a little girl”. Testifying in court, she tearfully described a pattern of physical and psychological abuse.

Now she appears to have become entangled with another controlling partner. Even after her imprisonment, Evans has tried to profit from his connection to her, in ways I will not disclose for fear of spoiling the film. It is enough to say that he is a wrong “un”.

This creates another riddle at the heart of You Can See Everything. Has Holmes manipulated the filmmakers and viewers so successfully that she has cast her husband as the true villain and encouraged sympathy for herself? Or is she another woman controlled by an unpleasant man? Is she a victim or a manipulator, vulnerable or calculating?

Fielder rejects the notion that Holmes must be one thing or the other. “Different things can be true about Elizabeth Holmes at the same time,” he says.

She remains an enigma, a shape-shifter and a living riddle. Whether you loathe her or pity her, she is impossible to ignore—even if, in the end, you cannot truly see everything.