Migrant Accused of Rape Was Free to Come and Go From Asylum Camp

A man wanted in connection with an alleged rape in Germany was reportedly allowed to leave and return to a controversial migrant accommodation site...
HomeNewsMan Allegedly Lured Suicidal British Woman to Florida to Kill Her

Man Allegedly Lured Suicidal British Woman to Florida to Kill Her

A British woman with a history of mental illness and suicidal thoughts was manipulated by a self-described sadist who allegedly lured her to Florida intending to become her “executioner”, a court has heard.

Sonia Exelby travelled from her home in Portsmouth to the United States in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, 54, a man who described himself as a sadist and claimed to worship the Egyptian god of death.

The 32-year-old music teacher had spent two years communicating with Hall on an extreme fetish website. Prosecutors say she offered to pay him to help end her life in a violent act.

However, they allege Ms Exelby changed her mind after arriving in Florida and travelling with Hall to an isolated Airbnb close to Reddick.

Hall is accused of ignoring her apparent change of heart, continuing to assault her before stabbing her to death.

During the flight to Florida, Ms Exelby emailed herself, writing: “As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, I can’t get off the plane, I want to beg for help so badly.

“Oh god, I feel so sick… why am I here, why? If I wasn’t numb I would have never got out of the house, this would be impossible, although I’m hurting more than I have ever done.”

The message continued: “Why do I still not feel like I’m going to die… I fucked up so badly not leaving a trace at the end… If I even manage to get to him it’ll be so easy to find me I’ll be mutilated and disabled for the rest of my life.”

Sonia Exelby, 32, flew from her home in Portsmouth to the US in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old self-described 'sadist' who worshipped the Egyptian god of death

Sonia Exelby, 32, travelled from Portsmouth to the United States in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, 54, a self-described sadist who worshipped the Egyptian god of death

Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old self-described 'sadist' who worshipped the Egyptian god of death today went on trial in Florida, having pleaded not guilty to charges of murder and kidnap

Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old self-described sadist, appeared for trial in Florida after pleading not guilty to murder and kidnapping charges

Prosecutors allege Sonia got cold feet after she arrived in Florida and travelled with Hall to a remote Airbnb near the town of Reddick

Prosecutors say Sonia Exelby reconsidered the trip after reaching Florida and travelling with Hall to a secluded Airbnb near Reddick

Sonia's sister Gemma Isaj  (pictured) gave evidence just a few feet from where the man accused of killing her was sitting

Sonia’s sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence only a few feet from the defendant accused of killing her sibling

Hall went on trial in Ocala, central Florida, after denying charges of murder and kidnapping.

In her opening address, prosecutor Amy Berndt told jurors: “On Friday, October 10, 2025, 32-year-old Sonia Exelby flew from England to the United States.

“By October 12 she was dead. She was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself ‘Alphasadist’, a man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women. That man was the defendant Dwain Hall.”

Ms Berndt said Hall had waited until Ms Exelby was isolated, far from home and unable to make rational decisions before allegedly stabbing her and burying her body.

She described Ms Exelby as a kind and much-loved woman who had faced serious difficulties during her childhood. She and her five siblings were placed in care when they were young after their parents struggled with mental illness and their father battled drug addiction.

After spending three years in care, Sonia and her sister Sara were adopted. They did not re-establish contact with their older siblings until they were adults.

“Sonia was unable to escape the trauma of her childhood and when she was a teenager she started struggling with mental illness,” the prosecutor told the court.

Ms Exelby lived with bipolar disorder and bulimia, began self-harming and made two suicide attempts by overdosing.

Hall today went on trial in the city of Ocala, central Florida, having pleaded not guilty to charges of murder and kidnap

Hall appeared in court in Ocala, Florida, where he has denied allegations of murder and kidnapping

Sonia Exelby, pictured with her boyfriend Steve Hunt, flew to Florida 'seeking a violent death'

Sonia Exelby, pictured with her partner Steve Hunt, travelled to Florida in what prosecutors say was an attempt to find a violent death

When detectives examined Hall's phone, they would find he had tried 'to erase every trace of Sonia', including numerous nude photos of her and a video he attempted to delete

Detectives said Hall tried to remove every trace of Sonia from his phone, including nude images and a video he attempted to erase

“Unfortunately she found another outlet for her cutting two years before her death and that ultimately would end in her murder,” Ms Berndt said.

Ms Exelby began using Motherless, an extreme fetish website where users shared disturbing sexual material, including images depicting the torture and killing of women and children.

She spoke to several men on the platform, telling them she wanted to die but could not do it without assistance. Prosecutors said the grim exchanges paradoxically made her feel alive.

One user, however, became particularly significant: a man operating under the name “Alphasadist”.

“He groomed Sonia, he wanted the job of being her executioner and that person was the defendant Dwain Hall,” Ms Berndt said.

Ms Exelby initially tried to travel to the US to meet Hall in March last year, but the journey did not take place until October. She told her long-term partner, Stevie Hunt, that she planned to spend the weekend with her sisters.

Mr Hunt later discovered an email she had sent to herself from the plane. According to the prosecution, it was filled with “sorrow, depression, regret and death” and referred to suicide.

Killed after meeting a man in a fetish chatroom: The Trial of Sonia Exelby

The Florida trial is taking place this week, with journalists reporting from court each day

Man Allegedly Lured Suicidal British Woman to Florida to Kill Her

The Trial podcast examines the case of Sonia Exelby, a gifted Portsmouth pianist who travelled to America with plans to end her life. Online, she met Dwain Hall, who allegedly agreed to kill her in exchange for payment. Detectives say she later changed her mind…

Subscribe and listen here

Mr Hunt alerted police in Britain, who contacted authorities in Florida. American investigators traced Hall after finding that Ms Exelby’s bank cards had repeatedly been used by a vehicle-recovery business he operated.

Her partially clothed body was later discovered in a shallow grave near Marion Oaks, the suburban community where Hall lived. She had suffered four stab wounds.

Police were directed to the location by GPS information from Hall’s phone, which showed he had remained in the area for about 80 minutes.

Investigators established that Ms Exelby had travelled with Hall to an Airbnb. He told detectives they had engaged in consensual rough sex inside the property, but denied killing her.

Days after meeting Ms Exelby, Hall sent a parcel to his friend Rick Snider in Ohio, according to the prosecution.

When police searched the property, they found a knife, its sheath and a bracelet inside the package. Forensic experts later said Sonia’s blood was present on the items.

A search of Hall’s phone allegedly showed that he had tried “to erase every trace of Sonia”, including multiple nude photographs and a video he attempted to delete.

Investigators also found a collection of “horrific” images and videos depicting women being tortured.

The prosecutor said this evidence supported the allegation that Hall beat, stabbed and killed Sonia for his own sadistic gratification.

Four of Ms Exelby’s siblings travelled to the United States to confront the man accused of killing her after raising money online to meet the considerable cost of attending the trial.

They entered court with their partners after the prosecution’s opening statement and saw Hall seated with his lawyers in the well of the court, dressed in a lilac shirt and grey trousers.

Sonia’s sister Gemma Isaj later gave evidence just a few feet away from Hall.

Holding back tears, she told the court that Ms Exelby had confided in November 2024 that she was “really terrified” because men she encountered through online suicide forums were making “horrible threats”.

Sonia's sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence today just a few feet from where Hall was sitting

Sonia’s sister Gemma Isaj testified from the witness stand close to where Hall was seated

“On these forums there were people that were preying on Sonia and her friends she had made online,” Ms Isaj said. Sonia had told her she was collecting evidence because she could not bear to see others being harmed and wanted to prevent similar incidents.

“I could see how scared Sonia was,” she added.

Ms Isaj said she contacted both the police and a mental-health crisis team.

On the weekend of Ms Exelby’s journey to Florida, she had been expected to meet Ms Isaj to welcome their sister Sara home from Australia. Instead, she cancelled and sent a message saying, “I will see you Sunday at 2pm.” She also declined an offer to be collected, which Ms Isaj now considers out of character.

The family realised she was missing only after Mr Hunt contacted Ms Isaj on Sunday, October 12.

Giving evidence remotely from Britain, Mr Hunt described Ms Exelby’s longstanding mental-health difficulties. He said that following the 2024 incident, police involvement led him to remove her passport and keep it secure for about six months to protect her.

He eventually returned it when she planned to visit her sister in Australia, explaining that he “thought the threat of her wanting to leave was behind us”.

Mr Hunt described his partner of 16 years as “the most incredible woman I’ve ever met” and “the nicest, kindest person I ever met in my life”.

If convicted, Hall will not face the death penalty. British police declined to provide key evidence unless American prosecutors agreed not to seek capital punishment.

Under British law, police forces must withhold evidence for US prosecutions where it could contribute to a death sentence.

An earlier hearing was told that, in the days before her death, Ms Exelby had left material on her computer suggesting she was suicidal again.

Investigators found that Hall had recorded footage while with Ms Exelby at the Airbnb, in which he allegedly forced her to describe in graphic detail how she wanted to die

Investigators said Hall recorded footage at the Airbnb in which he allegedly compelled Ms Exelby to explain in graphic terms how she wanted to die

Her family, however, allege that she was groomed through the extreme fetish website where she met Hall, who used the username “alphasadist”.

Hall, who has two children, was first arrested on suspicion of fraudulent credit-card use and unlawful use of a two-way communications device connected to Ms Exelby.

Investigators later learned that he had filmed Ms Exelby at the Airbnb and allegedly pressured her to describe how she wanted to die.

In the footage, Ms Exelby is seen sitting on a chair and appearing “dishevelled”, with several bruises across her face, neck and breasts.

Hall, who maintained that their rough sex was consensual, is heard asking why she had travelled to America. In tears, she replied: “Because I am an awful person… I’ve crushed everyone who ever loves me.”

When Hall asked her how she wanted to die and told her to describe it, she initially refused. She eventually said she wanted “to be stabbed”.

The police arrest affidavit described Ms Exelby as subdued throughout the recording. It said she rarely looked towards the camera, became visibly distressed, cried, took deep breaths and appeared hesitant when responding to Hall.

During the ordeal, she also tried desperately to contact a friend through Discord. The undelivered message alleged that Hall had locked her inside and would not let her leave unless she shot him.

“I thought he’d do it quick and not give my mind time to stew,” she wrote.

“I’m so so scared I’m so broken and in so much pain all I can do is lay here.”

The trial is continuing.

For confidential support, call Samaritans on 116 123, visit samaritans.org or visit www.thecalmzone.net/get-support