HomeNewsAI Data Centres Offer Little Benefit as Electricity Supply Comes Under Strain

AI Data Centres Offer Little Benefit as Electricity Supply Comes Under Strain

The SNP government is backing plans for huge artificial intelligence (AI) data centres in Scotland despite warnings from experts and civil servants that the projects could place significant pressure on the electricity network.

A report commissioned by jobs agency Scottish Enterprise identified “clear tensions” between the centres’ enormous energy requirements and Scotland’s sustainability targets.

Although the study was completed in May, it has only now been released publicly, raising renewed questions about SNP ministers’ decision not to introduce a moratorium on the large-scale developments.

As many as 25 proposals for so-called “hyperscale” data centres are at various stages across Scotland. The facilities would contain thousands of servers supporting AI applications and cloud-computing services.

The report warned that unchecked growth could “stress Scotland’s electricity system without co-ordinated planning, data transparency and targeted mitigations”.

Prepared by Frazer-Nash Consultancy, the Scottish Enterprise study examined the potential “opportunities and challenges” associated with data centres.

Protestors take to the streets of Edinburgh to voice their opposition to date centres

Protesters march through Edinburgh to oppose the expansion of data centres

It found that most jobs linked to data centres are created during the temporary construction phase, while permanent staffing at the sites is “relatively light touch and modest”.

The study noted that Scotland has between 20 and 25 hyperscale data centre proposals under consideration. It said the country’s “abundant renewable energy sources” could support cheaper and greener developments.

However, it cautioned: “Rapid hyperscale expansion could stress Scotland’s electricity system without co-ordinated planning, data transparency and targeted mitigations.”

The report added that utility companies were concerned they could not connect several major new power users quickly in areas of the electricity grid already facing increasing demand.

It described the central challenge as balancing the centres’ use of resources and their impact on local communities against their potential contribution to Scotland’s digital economy and its role in global digital infrastructure.

The report also concluded that the direct economic value for local areas could be limited when facilities depend on imported equipment, with procurement bypassing Scottish supply chains.

To improve the benefits, it recommended developing domestic supply chains covering construction, grid services, operations and maintenance.

It also proposed setting targets for local employment and finding ways to reuse the waste heat produced by the centres.

Campaigners said the findings supported concerns they had raised with ministers for months.

Dr Kat Jones, of Action to Protect Rural Scotland, said: “For a research paper on a subject of such public interest, it is a surprise that this document, which was published back in May and circulating among civil servants as early as March, was not made public previously and that, now it is live, it has not been accompanied by any kind of publicity from the Government.

“A Government agency commissioned a report all about the economic benefits of hyperscale data centres and they couldn’t come back with a single one.

“In fact, it confirms a number of points of concern that we have been raising with the Government for months—that jobs are limited in data centres, that wider supply chain and economic benefits are limited, and that hyperscale data centres present a risk to Scotland’s already-strained energy system.”

Dr Jones said campaigners had voiced concerns similar to those set out in the report, but claimed ministers had known about its contents since March while ignoring requests to hear their views. She described the situation as “a kick in the teeth”.

Scottish Conservative energy spokesman Liam Kerr said: “Scotland should be ambitious about attracting investment and embracing new technology, but ministers must ensure our energy infrastructure is fit for the future and ready to support that growth.”

The report’s publication follows the release of internal Scottish Government emails in which senior civil servants raised comparable concerns.

The correspondence, obtained through Freedom of Information legislation, shows officials warning that communities could face higher electricity bills, energy shortages and additional pressure on water supplies.

In one exchange, one of Scotland’s two deputy directors for domestic climate change warned: “There is a clear risk here that locals bear the brunt of increased electricity prices—or even a shortage of energy, or unreliable power—while seeing little direct benefit from ‘hosting’ the data centre.”

The unnamed official also described data centres as “water hungry”.

Sam Richards, chief executive of Britain Remade, which campaigns for economic growth, said: “The data centres that will power Scotland’s digital economy need reliable, round-the-clock power, and the wind doesn’t always blow when it’s needed.”

A Scottish Enterprise spokesman said: “This report was published in full on our website in line with our usual procedures.

“Scottish Enterprise’s role is to drive sustainable, responsible economic growth in Scotland.

“We routinely publish impartial economic commentary and research, and this report follows this principle.”

A Scottish Government spokesman said ministers would publish new planning guidance for data centres before the end of the year. In parallel, the government is developing a strategic plan to maximise the economic and public benefits of data centre investment in Scotland.

He said: “Planning authorities are also now required to notify ministers of new data centre applications, with a new planning direction also mandating an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) to be submitted during planning for all new data centres with a power capacity exceeding 50 megawatts (MW).”