Victoria’s Liberals and Nationals are asking voters to back them as a united Coalition, ready to govern.
Privately, however, leaked text messages obtained by the Daily Mail tell a very different story.
In the marginal seat of Ripon, north-west of Melbourne, a senior Liberal official admitted the party was working to help elect either its own candidate or One Nation’s.
The assessment of Nationals candidate Jo Armstrong — the Liberals’ Coalition partner — was blunt: “Not bloody Jo.”
In further messages, a senior Victorian Liberal MP made an urgent appeal to prevent Pauline Hanson’s party from placing Armstrong ahead of Liberal candidate Megan Read on its how-to-vote card.
Armstrong could reasonably question the value of the Liberals’ public promise that the Coalition is united and ready to govern.
She is distributing a card asking her supporters to preference Read second while, at the same time, Liberal operatives are reportedly working against her.
One message from a senior Liberal official said: “We have a gold-star candidate and we are working to make sure that it’s either her or Donna not bloody Jo.”
The official accused the Nationals of “running totally rogue in Ripon” — an extraordinary complaint from a Liberal prepared to see the seat fall to One Nation rather than the Nationals.
What, exactly, would Armstrong have to do to be considered a team player? Put the Liberal candidate first and herself second?
One Nation stands to benefit from the Coalition’s internal conflict, with Liberal operatives reportedly working against a Nationals candidate in favour of one of Pauline Hanson’s candidates. Above, Hanson with her Victorian party leader Warren Pickering
WhatsApp messages obtained by the Daily Mail show a senior Victorian Liberal official saying: “We have a gold-star candidate and we are working to make sure that it’s either her or Donna (Buxton) not bloody Jo (Armstrong)”
Labor’s Martha Haylett currently holds Ripon by a margin of just 3 per cent. The seat is considered highly unlikely to remain with Labor.
A Nationals victory would deliver another seat towards a potential Jess Wilson government. A win for One Nation’s Donna Buxton, by contrast, would hand the seat to Pauline Hanson’s party.
Yet of those two possibilities, the leaked messages suggest the Liberal official was more comfortable with a One Nation victory.
It takes a particular kind of political miscalculation to look at a winnable Labor seat and decide that the person most unwelcome in victory is a Coalition partner.
With this level of internal hostility, is it any surprise the Victorian Liberals have spent so much of their time in opposition appearing divided?
Another Liberal MP was similarly direct as the deadline for printing how-to-vote cards approached.
“Can u please do me a favour – ON cannot support the Nat lefty Jo Armstrong in Ripon ahead of our (Lib) sensational candidate, Megan Read – they must not do this,” the MP wrote.
“Can u please put a stop to this.”
In a separate exchange, the official said One Nation was “very high on our tickets” and described a personal effort to put the Liberals “ahead of the Nats in Ripon with ON”.
A Victorian Liberal MP also intervened, urging One Nation to preference Liberal candidate Megan Read over “Nat lefty” Jo Armstrong
Jo Armstrong, the Nationals candidate for Ripon, has become the target of an alleged political campaign by Liberal operatives in Victoria
Liberal candidate Megan Read is pictured left; One Nation’s Donna Buxton is pictured right
Opposition Leader Wilson has ruled out reaching an agreement with One Nation to form government in the event of a hung parliament.
She has also publicly acknowledged that the Coalition would generally preference One Nation ahead of Labor.
What voters had not previously seen was how eager senior Liberals appeared to be to enlist Hanson’s party against the very Coalition partner Wilson hopes to govern alongside.
If Wilson is serious about leading a united team, she will need to put an end to this kind of internal manoeuvring. As premier, she would rely on Nationals ministers to support difficult cabinet decisions, particularly those that affect regional communities.
Those ministers are entitled to ask whether the Liberal Party would offer them the same loyalty. Based on the events in Ripon, why should they?
Despite the private lobbying, the official how-to-vote cards contain an irony of their own. Read places Armstrong second, while Armstrong places Read second.
On paper, at least, Coalition unity remains intact. Only on paper.