Prince William, Kate Middleton Reportedly Clash Over Markle Sr. Arrest

The Prince and Princess of Wales have maintained a relatively private, controversy-free relationship in public—at least by royal standards. Behind the scenes, however, insiders...
HomeEntertainmentFired Home Alone Actor Accuses Director Chris Columbus of Lying

Fired Home Alone Actor Accuses Director Chris Columbus of Lying

Actor Daniel Roebuck has responded after Home Alone director Chris Columbus described the performer he had to dismiss from the 1990 Christmas classic as a “horrible actor.”

Roebuck was initially chosen to play Marv, one of the film’s bumbling burglars, but was removed from the production only four days after being hired. Daniel Stern ultimately took over the role.

Although Columbus, now 68, did not identify Roebuck by name, he discussed the casting change during a Tuesday appearance on the Wildmen podcast, saying the actor from the screen test was “horrible.”

The filmmaker explained that the studio initially refused to pay Stern, who went on to portray Marv Murchins, prompting the production to test another performer opposite Joe Pesci, who played Harry Lime.

Roebuck, 63, addressed the remarks in an interview with Page Six, saying: “It hurts my heart, and it hurts my heart that every Christmas I have to deal with this.”

Columbus also recalled telling the actor after firing him that they would work together again someday—a promise that, according to the director, was never fulfilled.

Daniel Roebuck was originally cast as Marv in Home Alone, however, he was fired just four days later and ultimately replaced by Daniel Stern; Roebuck pictured in May

Daniel Roebuck was initially cast as Marv in Home Alone but was dismissed four days later and replaced by Daniel Stern; Roebuck is pictured in May

The 63-year-old actor hit back at director Chris Columbus, 68, calling him a 'horrible' actor as he explained why he had tio fire him from the beloved 1990 holiday classic

The 63-year-old actor responded to director Chris Columbus, 68, after the filmmaker explained why he dismissed him from the beloved 1990 holiday movie

Roebuck said he still holds Columbus in high regard, but remembered waiting in vain for the promised opportunity to work together again.

“I have the utmost respect for Chris Columbus,” he told Page Six. “When he did fire me, and he said he’d put me in his next movie, I waited by the phone, man.”

He also challenged the director’s recollection of the casting process, insisting that he never completed a screen test with Pesci.

“They never, ever, ever filmed me and Joe Pesci together,” Roebuck said. “I never, ever filmed anything with Joe Pesci. The camera never rolled on us.”

According to Roebuck, he spent only one day with Pesci, making it difficult for him to understand claims that the pair lacked chemistry.

“The other thing is, how horrible could I have been if I was the second choice for a $35 million movie?” he said.

More than 35 years after losing the role, Roebuck said he has had no further contact with Columbus.

“I can’t speak to his motivations. He’s a good Catholic guy. I try to be a good Catholic guy. I try to be a man of faith, and I’m certainly a man of forgiveness. So I never held a grudge against him for firing me,” Roebuck told Page Six.

“I’m disappointed that every Christmas I have to put up with this when I’ve contributed so much more to the world than not being in Home Alone.”

Roebuck was ultimately replaced by actor Daniel Stern (Above, right) who famously worked alongside Joe Pesci (Above, left), who starred as Harry Lime

Roebuck was replaced by Daniel Stern (above, right), who famously appeared alongside Joe Pesci (above, left), the actor behind Harry Lime

Roebuck fired back at Columbus as he told Page Six on Tuesday: 'It hurts my heart, and it hurts my heart that every Christmas I have to deal with this'; Pictured in October

Roebuck responded to Columbus in an interview with Page Six, saying, “It hurts my heart that every Christmas I have to deal with this”; pictured in October

Roebuck’s comments followed Columbus’ appearance on the podcast, where the director described the behind-the-scenes change involving the character Marv.

“We tried this other guy. And we did a screen test and they were horrible. I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful,” Columbus said.

“And I had to—that’s the only person I ever had to fire,” he added, without naming the actor.

Columbus said he brought the performer in for a difficult conversation after the actor apparently realized what was coming.

“He goes, ‘You’re going to fire me, aren’t you?’ I said, ‘Not fire.’ I said, ‘We’ll work together at some point again,’” the director recalled.

When the hosts asked whether he ever honored that commitment, Columbus answered “no,” adding of the promise, “What else am I going to say?”

Asked whether the actor was still alive, Columbus replied: “Yeah, he’s still alive. He’s worked, I think he’s fine.”

The director also said the studio had to absorb the cost of paying the dismissed actor before hiring Stern, making the casting switch more expensive.

“But then we did the screen test with Stern and Pesci and it was amazing,” Columbus said.

Fired Home Alone Actor Accuses Director Chris Columbus of Lying

“We tried this other guy. And we did a screen test and they were horrible,” Columbus said during his Tuesday appearance on the Wildmen podcast

Though the director didn't name anyone, Entertainment Weekly reported that the actor was Roebuck, who previously confirmed he was fired from the film after four days (Above, Roebuck in 2024 film Saint Nick of Bethlehem)

Although Columbus did not identify the actor, Entertainment Weekly reported that it was Roebuck, who had previously confirmed he was fired after four days; above, Roebuck in the 2024 film Saint Nick of Bethlehem

While Columbus, whose credits include Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, did not name the performer, Entertainment Weekly reported that he was referring to Roebuck. The actor had previously confirmed that he was dismissed from Home Alone after four days.

The Daily Mail has contacted representatives for Columbus and Roebuck for comment.

During a 2023 appearance on the What a Character! podcast, Roebuck said he was never truly intended to play Marv in the finished film.

“I was never gonna be Marv,” he said. “That’s the one thing they never say. I was never ever ever going to film as Marv.”

Roebuck also recalled meeting writer and producer John Hughes, saying the interaction left him feeling unwelcome despite being a fan of Hughes’ work.

“I got the wettest handshake of my life with John Hughes. It was the most disappointing handshake I ever received because I was a fan of the guy. And he clearly didn’t want me to be there. It was all so obvious.”

Speaking to Entertainment Weekly about Columbus’ latest remarks, Roebuck said he respected the director and had enjoyed his films, but found the comments upsetting.

“I have enormous respect for Chris Columbus. I’ve enjoyed all of his movies. But I find these comments troubling,” he said.

Roebuck alleged that the production had made repeated efforts to push him into quitting.

He again rejected the claim that he had screen-tested with Pesci, saying: “There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened, so that’s impossible.”

Despite the disagreement, Roebuck has not closed the door on collaborating with Columbus in the future.

“I hope that Chris Columbus and I could work together. I think he’d find me to be a good actor and a nice person.”

Roebuck has also stressed that he does not resent missing out on the iconic role, acknowledging that Pesci and Stern were “terrific” in the original movie.

Stern famously played Marv Murchins, one of the bumbling burglars in the hit holiday films Home Alone (1990) and Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992) alongside a young Macaulay Culkin.

Daniel Stern played Marv Murchins, one of the hapless burglars in Home Alone (1990) and Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992), alongside a young Macaulay Culkin

Culkin, Pesci and Stern reprised the role for the 1992 sequel Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, but they did not appear in four subsequent films in the franchise released since then.

Culkin, Pesci and Stern returned for the 1992 sequel Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, but did not appear in the franchise’s four later installments

Stern became widely associated with Marv Murchins, the clumsy burglar he played opposite Joe Pesci in Home Alone and its 1992 sequel, alongside Macaulay Culkin’s young Kevin McCallister.

The original film also starred the late Catherine O’Hara, John Heard and John Candy.

Culkin, Pesci and Stern reprised their roles in Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, but none of them appeared in the four later movies released in the franchise.

Those films were Home Alone 3 in 1997, Home Alone 4: Taking Back the House in 2002, Home Alone: The Holiday Heist in 2012 and Home Sweet Home Alone in 2021.

The possibility of bringing Culkin back to the franchise emerged in July, when the actor was reportedly linked to a potential Disney reboot.

Journalist Matthew Belloni said on his podcast, The Town, that Culkin had met with Walt Disney Studios executives in Burbank, California, to discuss possible creative ideas for continuing the popular film series.

“I got a tip the other day that there was a very interesting sighting on the Disney lot—Macaulay Culkin was there,” Belloni said. “He’s talked about having an idea for a new Home Alone, and Disney is, like, salivating.”

Belloni claimed Disney executives were willing to be flexible in their efforts to persuade Culkin to return as Kevin, given the movie’s lasting popularity.

“They’re offering him another movie—like, he could do his own passion project if he could also do another Home Alone—and they have a good idea,” Belloni said.

A new Home Alone featuring Culkin would be a major opportunity for Disney, particularly as the franchise continues to draw strong streaming audiences during the holiday season.

“It may not happen, but I think it will,” Belloni said. “They are courting him like nobody’s business.”