A predatory sadist has been sentenced to life in prison after being convicted of kidnapping and murdering a vulnerable British music tutor whose suicidal thoughts he exploited for sexual gratification.
Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old mechanic who revered the Egyptian god of death, lured 32-year-old Sonia Exelby to Florida after grooming her for two years on an online fetish forum.
Ms Exelby had a long history of mental health difficulties and was manipulated into believing that she wanted Hall to torture and kill her. She even offered to pay him to carry out her violent death.
The confusion surrounding her decision was starkly illustrated by an email she sent to herself while flying from her home in Portsmouth to the United States in October last year.
She wrote: ‘As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, can’t get off the plane…oh god, I feel so sick, why am I here, why?’
The message showed that she appeared to have almost immediately regretted the journey, yet she continued with Hall to a remote Airbnb near the central Florida town of Reddick.
Although she was hesitant, Hall proceeded with his plan, torturing Ms Exelby over two nights and telling her that the only way to escape was to shoot him with a gun he carried at all times.
The Daily Mail can reveal the final message Ms Exelby sent to a friend. The message, sent during her second night in Hall’s hands, was not shown to the jury.
‘I f***ed up really bad I think it’s too late,’ she wrote. ‘I’m so scared.’
Dwain Hall has been sentenced to life in prison after luring 32-year-old British music tutor Sonia Exelby to Florida following two years of grooming on an online fetish forum
Hall looked towards the judge after being convicted of kidnapping and murdering Ms Exelby, whose suicidal thoughts he exploited for his own gratification
Sonia Exelby, 32, travelled from her home in Portsmouth to the United States in October last year to meet Dwain Hall
Hall, a 54-year-old mechanic who worshipped the Egyptian god of death, groomed Ms Exelby for two years through an online fetish forum
Ms Exelby’s sisters delivered emotional statements in court during Hall’s sentencing on Friday
Hall left the Airbnb with Ms Exelby on the morning of October 12. He drove first to a DIY store, where CCTV appears to have captured her for the final time, before travelling to a remote area of scrubland near his home in Marion Oaks.
There, in broad daylight, he stabbed her four times and buried her partially clothed body.
Hall was jailed for life today after being convicted of Ms Exelby’s kidnapping and murder following a trial in Ocala, Florida.
The verdict followed four days of distressing evidence heard by her family. Hall declined to testify in his own defence.
Passing sentence, Judge Timothy McCourt told Hall: ‘I know a lot of folks expect the judge to say something to sum everything up in some grand, eloquent way, but I don’t think that there’s anything I can say here that has not been said, except this: I hereby adjudicate you guilty of first-degree murder. You are sentenced to life in prison.’
All four of Ms Exelby’s siblings addressed the court before the sentence was imposed.
Her brother Barry Wilton spoke directly to Hall, saying: ‘Dwain, you pretended to care for Sonia – you didn’t at all.
‘You used her to fulfil your sick fantasies. You held her life in your hands and had the chance to save her, but instead you preyed on her vulnerabilities and took her away from us.
‘You will never receive forgiveness from us, even behind bars.
‘May your actions weigh on your mind for the rest of your pitiful life.’
Luke Wilton told the court: ‘This has been an exhausting and emotionally draining roller coaster. Nothing can bring Sonia back.
‘This tragedy has changed us forever, but because the truth has been established and accountability reached in this courtroom today, we can finally begin to heal.’
He was followed by their older sister Gemma Isaj, who broke down while describing the impact of the crime. She said: ‘A vulnerable person was preyed upon and a beautiful soul was taken. Without Sonia, our lives will never be the same, and we must learn a new way of living.
‘When this tragedy began to unfold, Sonia genuinely believed she could prevent other people from being hurt.
‘She also exposed the darkness of sites such as Motherless.com, and in some way we will continue to fight for mental health in her name.’
Sara Exelby, who was adopted alongside Sonia when they were young, was the final sibling to address the court. She also read a statement from their adoptive parents.
‘We will keep Sonia’s memory alive in our hearts and honour her life every day, so that her life was not in vain,’ she said.
‘My parents, Trevor and Sheila, want to share these words: ‘The loss of our beautiful, musically talented daughter has left us utterly devastated.
‘The depth of our grief cannot be expressed in words. Sonia, we love you. We miss you every day. We will always be your parents’.’
Ms Exelby’s siblings travelled bravely to the United States to confront their sister’s killer after raising money online to meet the enormous costs involved.
Her older sisters Gemma and Sara both wept as they gave evidence about how Hall had corrupted someone they described as a ‘beautiful soul’.
The trial heard that Ms Exelby’s mental health had fluctuated during the two years Hall groomed her online. She appeared ‘ambivalent’ about her suicidal intentions and had even booked a return flight for her trip to Florida.
Hall’s predatory intent, however, remained consistent. Using the name ‘Alphasadist’, he gradually drew Ms Exelby closer by presenting himself as her ‘mentor’.
Messages exchanged between the pair revealed the extent of his influence over her.
Jurors at the Marion County Judicial Center in Ocala, central Florida, were shown messages exchanged by Ms Exelby and Hall in the months before her death
The Airbnb where Ms Exelby stayed with Hall. He told detectives that they had consensual rough sex inside
Ms Exelby’s sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence in a Florida courtroom this week
Ms Exelby wrote: ‘I got worried about you, I’m lost without my alpha sadist.
‘I’ve missed my alpha more than I could imagine… absence does make the heart grow fonder. I can’t be without you.’
Prosecutor Amy Berndt told the jury: ‘He groomed Sonia; he wanted the job of being her executioner.’
On October 10 last year, Ms Exelby told her long-term partner Stevie Hunt that she planned to stay with her sisters for the weekend. Instead, she flew to Florida.
Two days later, Mr Hunt found an email she had sent herself from the plane. It was ‘full of sorrow, depression, regret and death and it talked about suicide’, the prosecutor said.
Mr Hunt alerted British police, who notified authorities in the United States. Detectives connected Ms Exelby to Hall after her bank cards were repeatedly used by a breakdown company he owned.
Investigators found Ms Exelby in a shallow grave, wearing only a bra and trainers. The floral dress she had worn to the airport had been placed over her remains.
Police established that Ms Exelby had gone to an Airbnb with Hall. He told detectives they had consensual rough sex there but denied killing her.
Police later discovered that Hall had mailed a knife to a friend. Tests showed that it contained Ms Exelby’s blood.
A search of Hall’s phone found that he had tried ‘to erase every trace of Sonia’, including numerous nude photographs of her and a video he had attempted to delete.
Investigators also found a collection of ‘horrific’ photographs and videos depicting women being tortured.
‘The evidence shows that the defendant beat, stabbed and murdered Sonia for his own sadistic pleasure,’ the prosecutor told the court.
Gemma Isaj gave evidence from just a few feet away from Hall, who was seated in court wearing a purple shirt and grey trousers.
Holding back tears, she described how Ms Exelby disclosed in November 2024 that she was ‘really terrified’ because men she encountered on suicide forums were making ‘horrible threats’ against her.
Ms Isaj told the court: ‘Sonia said she was trying to collect evidence because she could not bear the thought of people being hurt.
‘I could see how frightened Sonia was.’
She said she contacted police and a mental health crisis team at the time.
Mr Hunt gave evidence from the UK via a remote link. He said that after police became involved in the 2024 incident, he removed Ms Exelby’s passport and kept it safely for about six months to protect her.
He described his partner of 16 years as ‘the most incredible woman I’ve ever met’ and ‘the nicest, kindest person I ever met in my life’.
LISTEN: The Trial: Sonia Exelby is available now, wherever you get your podcasts
WATCH: You can also watch The Trial: Sonia Exelby by searching for The Trial on YouTube or clicking here