When an image of comedian Bill Burr appeared behind Billy Corgan during a November 2024 podcast interview, the Smashing Pumpkins singer had plenty of reason to chuckle. For years, fans have remarked on the striking resemblance between the two bald stars.
Then Corgan made the conversation far more intriguing by suggesting that Burr might be his half-brother.
Corgan, 59, explained that his stepmother had first raised the possibility more than a decade earlier. She had told him that his father, a musician who spent years traveling for work, may have fathered Burr while touring during the 1960s.
The revelation immediately sent fans searching for evidence. Some placed photographs of the pair side by side, while others revisited images of Corgan’s late father and argued that he, rather than Corgan, bore an uncanny resemblance to Burr.
Burr has largely avoided discussing the theory in public. Corgan, meanwhile, has acknowledged seeing his father’s features in the comedian but has said he is not convinced they are related.
Now, Penny Andersen, the woman who first introduced the idea to Corgan, has spoken publicly about it for the first time. In an exclusive interview with the Daily Mail, she recalled what Corgan’s father allegedly told her about a secret son named Bill.
‘Billy’s dad did tell me all those things, that is true,’ Andersen said when asked about Corgan’s account.
Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan said his father may have fathered ‘multiple’ children while touring as a musician in the 1960s, and comedian Bill Burr could be one of them
Stand-up comedian Bill Burr has rarely spoken about the possibility that he is related to Corgan
Andersen separated from Corgan’s father in 1978 and raised Billy from the age of 11, along with his brother Rick and half-brother Jesse. Corgan’s mother had been absent from his life for years.
Andersen, now 79, first mentioned the possibility of a hidden half-brother during a family birthday gathering.
She told Corgan that she believed his father, who had played guitar for a group called The Puppets while traveling throughout the 1960s, could have fathered as many as a dozen children outside marriage.
She then asked whether he had ever heard of Bill Burr.
Corgan did not recognize the name, but Andersen suggested that the comedian ‘might be one of the children that your father sired in his days being a traveling musician.’
Corgan Sr was based in Chicago during the 1960s, playing guitar with the Midwest group The Puppets and touring nationally with other performers. Around autumn 1967, when Burr would likely have been conceived, Burr’s mother was living near Boston, almost 1,000 miles away.
In the following decade, Corgan Sr played with the band Crystal and traveled from Chicago to perform in locations as far south as Florida.
Looking back on the family conversation, Andersen said she remembered the private information Corgan’s father had shared with her.
‘His dad told me about this son of his named Bill,’ Andersen, a former flight attendant who later worked as a family therapist, told the Daily Mail.
‘There is an incredible similarity between the two of them, nobody can deny that.’
The Daily Mail has contacted Corgan and Burr for comment.
William Corgan Sr played guitar with the Midwest group The Puppets during the 1960s and frequently toured with other acts (source: Facebook/Billy Corgan)
Corgan and Burr met for the first time during an appearance on Howie Mandel’s podcast
Penny Andersen, now 79, first raised the possibility of a secret half-brother while speaking with her stepson Billy Corgan at a family birthday party
Corgan later recalled that on his 18th birthday in 1985, his father spoke to him while they were sitting inside an IHOP. He reportedly mentioned a half-brother named Bill who would have been close to Corgan’s age. Burr will turn 59 next year.
Years later, Corgan asked his father directly who this half-brother was and how he could locate him. According to Corgan’s recollection, his father replied: ‘I’m trying to protect you.’
Corgan’s father died in 2021. Aside from Billy Jr and Jesse, he appeared to have kept any possible additional children private, even from musicians who had worked alongside him for years.
‘He never mentioned any other sons to me, and we played together for a good eight years, seven years,’ bassist Nick Fortuna told the Daily Mail.
However, when discussing his former bandmate’s romantic life, Fortuna suggested that finding female companionship while touring was hardly unusual.
‘Come on, we’re rock musicians,’ he said.
Fortuna said meeting women on the road ‘wasn’t really hard to do’ for Corgan Sr during the more permissive 1960s, adding that the era was very different from the more conservative 1950s.
For decades, the possibility that Corgan Sr had fathered another son while touring remained a private family matter.
That changed after Corgan decided to discuss the theory publicly.
Two months after Corgan mentioned the possible sibling on Howie Mandel’s podcast, Burr appeared on the show himself. Midway through the interview, Mandel announced that he had arranged a surprise and brought Corgan into the studio.
Burr greeted the Smashing Pumpkins frontman before turning to Mandel and saying: ‘You’re an a**hole.’
‘I thought you would be cool with me bringing the family together,’ Mandel responded.
Corgan had assumed Burr knew he was coming. The mood became uncomfortable when Burr challenged him over his choice to share the family story publicly.
‘Did you ever think, the fact that I never told that story, that maybe you shouldn’t?’ Burr asked Corgan.
Corgan repeatedly asked his father who the supposed half-brother was and where he could be found. His father’s reported response was: ‘I’m trying to protect you’
‘Did you ever think, the fact that I never told that story, that maybe you shouldn’t?’ Burr asked Corgan
Burr also poked fun at one detail from Corgan’s recollection.
‘He had two kids this close together and he gave them the same f**king name?’
He then looked back at Mandel and asked: ‘What was supposed to happen? Are we gonna go play catch? We’re both in our 50s.’
Six days later, Burr remained angry about the surprise meeting, calling Mandel a ‘Hollywood w***e’ during an appearance on The Rich Eisen Show.
Mandel later insisted that he had not intended to embarrass or unsettle either man.
‘Corgan tapes his own podcast in the same building,’ Mandel told the Daily Mail. Since Burr was already there, he said he simply invited the musician to come in.
‘And then I got in trouble for it,’ Mandel said.
‘I was as uncomfortable as anybody else watching. My intention was not to make anybody uncomfortable.’
When asked whether Burr and Corgan might actually be related, Mandel offered a simple response: ‘I don’t know. Like, I just don’t know.’
Professional genealogists who reviewed the encounter said it was easy to understand why viewers noticed a resemblance. But they emphasized that only genetic testing could determine whether the two men are genuinely half-brothers.
Genealogists Ellen and Elizabeth Driscoll told the Daily Mail that the first step would be to measure the amount of DNA the men share, followed by a comparison of their Y chromosomes to determine whether they belong to the same paternal line.
‘Ideally, both would take an autosomal DNA test, along with a Y-DNA test, which could help establish whether they share a common paternal lineage and potentially identify their biological surname,’ the sisters said in an email.
An autosomal test could reveal whether Burr and Corgan share the quantity of DNA normally expected between half-siblings. A Y-DNA test would examine the male line by comparing the Y chromosome each man inherited from his father.
Even if only one of the two men agreed to testing, the findings could still provide useful leads.
‘We could then look for common ancestors, identify possible paternal connections, and possibly uncover their biological father’s identity,’ the Driscoll sisters added.
Stephanie Lazazzero-Kelley, a genealogist based in the Boston area, told the Daily Mail that family accounts can evolve like a game of ‘telephone,’ with important details altered as the story is passed along.
Corgan became famous in the 1990s as the singer, guitarist and songwriter behind Smashing Pumpkins songs such as 1979 and Tonight, Tonight
Still, Lazazzero-Kelley cautioned that both Corgan and Burr should be ready for the possibility that the truth could bring unexpected or painful information.
‘Someone might be thrilled to find a relative and still feel hurt that they didn’t know about them sooner,’ she said.
‘For someone else, it might explain something they’ve wondered about for years. Others have no interest in learning more, and that’s their choice.’
Fortuna said he could understand why Corgan might want clarity. ‘If I were him, I’d want to know if I had a half-brother out there. But that’s up to him.’
During an appearance on Joe Rogan’s podcast last year, Corgan said he had no plans to undergo a DNA test. He also admitted that he was not certain Burr was related to him.
‘All I know is…when I look at him he looks just like my father,’ Corgan said, describing the resemblance as ‘freaky.’
Andersen, despite being the person who first suggested the possible family connection, remains cautious about pursuing the matter further.
‘Bill Burr has got a nice family and I don’t think we should interrupt that,’ she told the Daily Mail.
‘And if there’s a family secret, then I certainly don’t want to be the one to blow that family secret. And if it’s just gossip, then I don’t want to disturb the family.’