HomeCeleb LifestyleIs Dancing With the Stars Rigged? Contestants Speak Out

Is Dancing With the Stars Rigged? Contestants Speak Out





Reality television often delivers moments that seem almost too perfectly timed to be genuine. Viewers have long suspected that producers shape storylines, edit footage, or heighten conflicts to keep audiences watching. After all, Hollywood is hardly synonymous with unscripted authenticity. On competition and game shows, eliminated contestants may be especially inclined to question the results when they believe they deserved a place in the final.

On “Dancing With The Stars,” celebrities with varying levels of dance experience are paired with professional dancers and tackle demanding choreographed routines each week. Advancing requires more than talent and practice; the connection between partners can also influence how a performance comes across. Still, some former “DWTS” contestants have suggested that the competition was not entirely fair, or that the show favored certain participants. Their comments have fueled uncomfortable questions about how the series works behind the scenes.

Alexa and Carlos Penavega recalled hearing a contestant question the show

A long list of celebrities has competed on “Dancing With The Stars,” including Alexa Penavega, known for the “Spy Kids” franchise. She joined Season 21 with her husband, “Big Time Rush” star Carlos Penavega, making them the first married couple to compete during the same season. Alexa placed sixth, while Carlos finished fourth, and Bindi Irwin ultimately won the Mirrorball Trophy. Years later, the couple revisited the experience on their podcast, “LexLos.” During an October 2026 episode, Alexa said she overheard contestant Hayes Grier say backstage, “I think this show is rigged.”

At the time, Grier had millions of social media followers, a factor that might have been expected to help him in the fan-voting portion of the competition. Even with that support, he became the sixth contestant eliminated that season, a result he reportedly found difficult to understand. Alexa said on the podcast that she believed the votes mattered, but added, “the show is also produced.” After the clip spread on TikTok, Alfonso Ribeiro, one of the show’s co-hosts, responded in the comments. “No chance. We want everyone who’s popular to stay on. It’s basic logic,” he wrote, according to People. His swift rejection of the claim became part of the online discussion, although neither the podcast comments nor Ribeiro’s response proves that the competition was rigged.

Sean Avery believed a disagreement with a producer contributed to his elimination

Former NHL player Sean Avery entered the “Dancing With The Stars” ballroom alongside professional partner Karina Smirnoff. His experience on the ice did not necessarily translate to the dance floor, but he progressed as far as he could before finishing 11th in a double elimination during Season 18. Avery later suggested that his short run may have involved more than dance ability alone.

Following his elimination, Avery explained to “Good Morning America” why he believed the show had sent him home early. “I had a conversation with Conrad, one of the producers, and I was upset at the package that they had brought in the week previous, and it was a very tacky attempt to show me as the bad boy of ‘DWTS,'” he said, according to ABC. Avery argued that reality programs can build storylines around contestants, even when the format is presented as a straightforward competition. He believed his refusal to play along damaged his chances, later saying, “I think in reality TV or some sort of competition, if you have a disagreement with the producers then generally that seals your fate quite early.”

Kyle Massey claimed the eventual winner’s finale routine was edited

Disney star Kyle Massey competed on Season 11 of “Dancing With The Stars” and finished as the runner-up, while actor Jennifer Grey won the season. Second place might seem like a strong result, but Massey later shared a behind-the-scenes account that raised questions about how the finale was presented. In 2024, he discussed his season with former “DWTS” professional Cheryl Burke on her podcast, “Sex, Lies and Spray Tans.”

According to Massey, one of the other finalists, Jennifer Grey, had a mishap during the finale. He said viewers on the East Coast saw the mistake, while the West Coast broadcast used an edited version that made the performance appear nearly flawless. Massey described the error as a misstep “when you trip, but you don’t actually fall.” If accurate, the account suggests that the broadcast was handled differently across time zones, though it does not establish that the outcome itself was predetermined. Massey nevertheless believed the incident added to the perception that the show’s producers already favored a particular winner.